FILE 612 / 11 July 2025 / 73 MIN / express

Behind The Murder Mask

Litchfield, MaineListen

The town

N ↑Town centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Litchfield, south central Maine, about twenty five minutes outside of Augusta, Maine about 0:03:27

History, in brief

Town note

The town was first called field Plantation, then renamed Litchfield.

about 0:04:32

1813

Town meetings were held in a resident's house until 1813.

about 0:04:56

1860

In 1860 the town bought a farm of 112 acres to support the town poor.

about 0:05:09

Town note

The annual expense for the town poor was $250 more than the proceeds of the farm, and a local man made up the difference.

about 0:05:28
All 4 history facts

Town note

The town was first called field Plantation, then renamed Litchfield.

about 0:04:32

1813

Town meetings were held in a resident's house until 1813.

about 0:04:56

1860

In 1860 the town bought a farm of 112 acres to support the town poor.

about 0:05:09

Town note

The annual expense for the town poor was $250 more than the proceeds of the farm, and a local man made up the difference.

about 0:05:28

The figures, as told

Money

Median home valueabout $307,800
Median household income$71,691
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2025

Population

"3,587"

No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:04:01

Median household income

"$71,691"

Comparison: "about two thousand over the national average". Direction: above.

As told in 2025 about 0:04:17

Median home cost

"about $307,800"

Comparison: "not higher than the national average, not too much lower". Direction: above.

As told in 2025 about 0:04:21

The reviews

3.5 / 5 · average of 4

4 stars

“Recreation is easy to access in this area.”
about 0:05:43

4 stars

“I don't need any more public services; what is available is plenty for my needs.”
about 0:06:02

3 stars

“There are very few violent crimes in this area and no concerns for safety; vacant home and camp thefts are one of the largest problems.”
about 0:06:20

3 stars

“Very small rural town with limited shopping and all mom and pop stores; residents must travel 20 minutes for built-up shopping, dining and box stores.”
about 0:06:47

In Maine

Closest episodes

  1. A Strangely Murderous GrudgeFayette, Maine · 1 May 202631 km / 19 miShow on map
  2. The Stranger & The PsychicScarborough, Maine · 26 August 202374 km / 46 miShow on map
  3. Murder Bubbling Under The SurfaceOld Orchard Beach, Maine · 12 April 201779 km / 49 miShow on map
  4. The Shining, But More QuaintNewry, Maine · 27 June 201983 km / 52 miShow on map
  5. A Secret In Every HoleHartland, Maine · 11 February 202187 km / 54 miShow on map

The story

Kimberly Jo Hutchins was born on 11 June 1970 in Rumford, Maine, one of the children of Arthur and Jeanette Hutchins. She graduated from Telstar High School and went on to Becker College in western Massachusetts, where she earned a degree in interior design in 1990.

She was 46 and was changing careers, enrolling at the Avita Maine Institute in Augusta to study cosmetology. Classmates remembered Kimberly as a warm, hard-working woman, but Anthony Coco, the school's owner, said she was afraid of her son.

They spent hours planning. In the early hours of 22 April they went upstairs. The medical examiner found stab wounds to her neck, defensive wounds to her hands and wrists, contusions and abrasions, and bleeding under her scalp; strangulation or stabbing could have caused death.

At about two o'clock that morning state police received several calls reporting a possible homicide. Officers found Kimberly dead on her bed, blood on the sheets, comforter, bed frame, rug and a light switch, a kitchen knife on the bed and a bottle of glass cleaner on the nightstand. A neighbour reported seeing three teenagers leaving the house. At the station they claimed an intruder had killed her and spared them. Investigators also found comic panels the boys had drawn depicting the killing.

The case

Murder of Kimberly Hutchins

Victims

Kimberly Jo Hutchins. Interior designer turned cosmetology student, 46 when she moved to Maine in 2017; mother

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 11 July 2025.

Accused

Accused

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Jeanette Hutchins. Kimberly's mother and grandmother
Arthur Hutchins. Kimberly's father
Beth. Kimberly's sister, who wrote a victim impact statement
Gale Donald. neighbour in Ashland, Massachusetts, who drove the boys to the commuter rail station
Anthony 'Tony' Coco. owner of the Avita Maine Institute
Sage Lockhart. classmate at the cosmetology school
Matt Finley. Long Creek staff member who testified about the chanting

The timeline

  1. June 11th, 1970 Kimberly Jo Hutchins is born in Rumford, Maine, to Arthur and Jeanette Hutchinsabout 0:11:41
  2. 1990 Kimberly graduates from Becker College in western Massachusetts with a degree in interior design (Becker College)about 0:12:06
  3. 2003 Kimberly marries Alex about 0:12:50
  4. 2004 Their son is bornabout 0:13:10
  5. 2005 father seeks emergency custody after mother overdoses with a needle in her arm while the toddler is in the homeabout 0:32:02
  6. 2008 Kimberly and Alex divorce; he pays $900 a month child support and has weekend visits with about 0:14:58
  7. when he was five, around 2009 is first diagnosed with mental health disordersabout 0:13:35
  8. the 2009-2010 school year is last enrolled as a student in Ashland, Massachusettsabout 0:18:08
  9. September 2017 Kimberly sells her condominium and moves with to Litchfield, Maineabout 0:18:50
  10. 2017 Kimberly enrols at the Avita Maine Institute in Augusta to study cosmetology (Avita Maine Institute)about 0:22:16
  11. April 2018 About halfway through her course, Kimberly takes part in the school's trashion show (Avita Maine Institute)about 0:25:41
  12. April 15th, 2018 takes the train to Massachusetts; Gale Donald drives and another friend to the Framingham commuter rail station to collect him (Framingham commuter rail station)about 0:36:02
  13. April 20th, 2018 Kimberly is called home from school over illegal bonfire, finds the boys stole her marijuana and refuses to drive and home (Hutchins home)about 0:37:13
  14. April 20th, 2018 suggests killing Kimberly and taking her car, and agrees (Hutchins home)about 0:45:49
  15. April 20th to 21st, 2018 The boys spend hours planning, test crushed medication in Kimberly's wine, then decide will stab her while strangles her (Hutchins home)about 0:46:43
  16. April 21st, 2018 Kimberly agrees to drive the boys home; wavers but insists they go through with the plan (Hutchins home)about 0:48:51
  17. the night of April 21st going into the early hours of the 22nd, 2018 and strangle and stab Kimberly in her bed while keeps watch downstairs with the dog (Hutchins home)about 0:49:41
  18. April 22nd, 2018, about two o'clock in the morning State police receive multiple calls reporting a possible homicide at Hallowell Road (Hutchins home)about 0:38:18
  19. April 22nd, 2018 Police find Kimberly dead in her bedroom and a neighbour reports seeing three teenagers leaving the house (Hutchins home)about 0:38:52

Places and phrases

N ↑Town centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode