1779
First settled as either Sterling or Starling; a Starling plantation covered 7,000 acres there in 1779.
about 0:05:41Spoilers are covered until your reading preferences load.
FILE 696 / 1 May 2026 / 72 MIN / express
We're going to Fayette, Maine ... this is in Kennebec County. about 0:04:45
First settled as either Sterling or Starling; a Starling plantation covered 7,000 acres there in 1779.
about 0:05:41Named for the Marquis de Lafayette, the French nobleman who offered his services to the Americans during the Revolution.
about 0:05:49The town has nine sizable ponds and lakes, including a 1,610-acre pond and a 1,185-acre lake.
about 0:06:37First settled as either Sterling or Starling; a Starling plantation covered 7,000 acres there in 1779.
about 0:05:41Named for the Marquis de Lafayette, the French nobleman who offered his services to the Americans during the Revolution.
about 0:05:49The town has nine sizable ponds and lakes, including a 1,610-acre pond and a 1,185-acre lake.
about 0:06:37Murders in Maine, 1983
24
Murder clearance rate in Maine, 1983
87.5%
Forcible rape clearance rate in Maine, 1983
79.8%
Aggravated assault clearance rate in Maine, 1983
80.2%
Motor vehicle theft clearance rate in Maine, 1983
39%
Burglary clearance rate in Maine, 1983
26.2%
National crime clearance rate, 1982
20.1%
Random match probability of the DNA sample
69 quadrillion to one
"1,274"
No direction stated.
As told in 2026 about 0:04:51
"$54,375"
Comparison: "about $15,000 below the national average". Direction: below.
As told in 2026 about 0:05:11
"$300,000"
Comparison: "not much less than the national average". Direction: below.
As told in 2026 about 0:05:18
"$48,000"
No direction stated.
As told in 2026 about 0:20:12
"24"
No direction stated.
As told in 2026 about 0:37:39
"87.5%"
No direction stated.
As told in 2026 about 0:37:47
"79.8%"
No direction stated.
As told in 2026 about 0:38:03
"80.2%"
No direction stated.
As told in 2026 about 0:38:09
"39%"
No direction stated.
As told in 2026 about 0:38:09
"26.2%"
No direction stated.
As told in 2026 about 0:38:16
"20.1%"
Comparison: "national". No direction stated.
As told in 2026 about 0:38:43
"69 quadrillion to one"
No direction stated.
As told in 2026 about 0:53:56
3.0 / 5 · average of 1
“It is pretty quiet here; there is a general store, groceries, coffee and restaurants are 15 minutes away, and the town has a private school and private summer camps.”about 0:07:16
On the evening of January 6th, 1983, Ted Flagg came home to Fayette, Maine, after a double shift at the James River paper mill in Chisholm and found his wife dead. Judith Flagg, 23, was lying on the living-room floor with the telephone still in her hand. Their 13-month-old son, Chad, was curled on her chest, covered in her blood but unharmed. She had been stabbed repeatedly in the chest, stomach and back, and had defensive wounds on her hands and left wrist. The medical examiner put her death at about 11 a.m., twelve hours before her husband found her. She had also been sexually assaulted orally.
Judith was born Judith L. Dion on January 3rd, 1960, one of the children of Pauline and Alex Dion, with siblings Doreen and David. She grew up in the Fayette area, graduated from high school in 1978, played field hockey, skied and was a cheerleader.
The police cleared Ted quickly, because the mill confirmed he had worked the whole double shift. The investigation then turned on a man who had telephoned the house that morning asking for Ted, saying he was an old friend who wanted to surprise him. Judith told her sister about the call at about 10.30 a.m.; while they were speaking, someone came to the door, and Judith told her sister the man was there and she would call back. At about 10.45 she telephoned her brother David, a mechanic, to say the man was in the drive complaining of car trouble; the man then said he would go elsewhere and David did not come. At about noon the mail carrier saw a maroon car with a tan top swerve into a ditch on the road uphill to the house, driven by a clean-shaven man in his early twenties with light brown hair, a tan coat, a grey wool scarf and no glasses. A brother-in-law spent 45 minutes to an hour at the house that afternoon fitting a starter to a truck and saw nothing.
As many as fifty people were said to have walked through the house before police arrived. The state police took over, setting up a command post in Fayette and working the case for about a month. Footprints in the snow led to the kitchen door, and there was blood in the baby's room, but the casts and the blood testing available in 1983 could tell them little. A reward reached $4,300 by February 1984.
He had been angry that the house went to his stepmother, and in 1981 had come to the house for belongings and left annoyed when Ted told him they were at the realtor. He was also seen at about 7 a.m. on the day of the murder driving a two-tone 1973 Ford Thunderbird north out of Portland on I-295. In 1984 police obtained his shoes and blood; his car was olive green with a tan roof and a maroon primer door, and his aunt Eleanor Foley produced a handwritten diary accounting for his day.
In 1996 the state crime laboratory began DNA testing; in 2003 Detective Jason Richards reopened the case and had the broken footprint casts rebuilt.
January 6th, 1983 / her home on Watson Heights Road, Fayette, Maine
As told in the episode, on 1 May 2026.
Accused
1985 / Standish, Maine
As told in the episode, on 1 May 2026.
Accused
Public places are marked on the map.
crime scene
about 0:13:42road
about 0:20:04business
about 0:11:48business
about 0:33:30school
about 0:18:47police
about 0:24:19police
about 0:32:39road
about 0:41:10business
about 0:44:51business
about 0:44:51