FILE 418 / 26 August 2023 / 71 MIN / express

The Stranger & The Psychic

Scarborough, MaineListen

The town

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

James says this is Scarborough, Maine, in southern Maine, about 15 minutes outside of Portland; earlier he says the area is in Cumberland County. about 0:04:09

History, in brief

Town note

It is the most populous town in Maine, though still a town rather than a city.

about 0:05:35

Town note

Settlers came, Native Americans killed most of them and the rest ran away; the pattern repeated about five times over 150 years.

about 0:05:41

Town note

The survivors kept going back to Boston and returning with more people to try again.

about 0:06:01
All 3 history facts

Town note

It is the most populous town in Maine, though still a town rather than a city.

about 0:05:35

Town note

Settlers came, Native Americans killed most of them and the rest ran away; the pattern repeated about five times over 150 years.

about 0:05:41

Town note

The survivors kept going back to Boston and returning with more people to try again.

about 0:06:01

The figures, as told

Crime / national average

Reward offered by Amy's family
$35,000

about 0:40:02

Missing people in America
▲ over 100,000

about 0:41:08

Missing people who are found
90%

about 0:41:08

Money

Median home value$562,900
Median household income$105,960
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2023

Population

"21,857"

No direction stated.

As told in 2023 about 0:04:37

Population growth

"up 27%"

Comparison: "since 2020". Direction: above.

As told in 2023 about 0:04:41

Median household income

"$105,960"

Comparison: "almost double the national average". Direction: above.

As told in 2023 about 0:05:09

Median home cost

"$562,900"

No direction stated.

As told in 2023 about 0:05:14

Reward offered by Amy's family

"$35,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2023 about 0:40:02

Missing people in America

"over 100,000"

Comparison: "at the time". Direction: above.

As told in 2023 about 0:41:08

Missing people who are found

"90%"

Comparison: "of the 100,000 missing". No direction stated.

As told in 2023 about 0:41:08

The reviews

3.5 / 5 · average of 4

5 stars

“A great town to live in and a growing community with the best of both worlds: sandy beaches or rocky ocean shore, and countryside or mountains an hour away.”
about 0:06:18

4 stars

“A very safe suburban town with great beaches and trails, but not a lot of restaurants and no real town centre, and a very wealthy and well-known school district.”
about 0:06:36

3 stars

“The reviewer is not involved in local politics but is annoyed by the big hullabaloo whenever a local law is about to pass, with people standing about with signs promoting their side.”
about 0:07:05

2 stars

“The site's information needs updating: schools are ranked as well performing but the town has not increased services at the rate it has allowed growth, schools are overcrowded, school and library budgets have not passed by much of a margin, and beach parking is crowded.”
about 0:08:13

In Maine

Closest episodes

  1. Murder Bubbling Under The SurfaceOld Orchard Beach, Maine · 12 April 20175 km / 3 miShow on map
  2. Satanic StupiditySanford, Maine · 17 September 202238 km / 24 miShow on map
  3. Til Murder Do Us PartLebanon, Maine · 30 January 202550 km / 31 miShow on map
  4. Kinky Killer CoupleDover, New Hampshire · 30 November 202462 km / 39 miShow on map
  5. An Extra Terrible PersonKittery, Maine · 30 May 201863 km / 39 miShow on map

The story

Amy St. Laurent was twenty-five in the autumn of 2001. She grew up in New Hampshire and moved to South Portland, Maine, with her mother and stepfather after her parents divorced, and she graduated from South Portland High School with honours in 1994. Diagnosed with hip dysplasia at thirteen, she had two surgeries and months of physical therapy but recovered. Rather than go to college she moved out and worked at the Dunkin' Donuts on Broadway, then took an overnight shift making jet engine parts at the Pratt & Whitney plant in North Berwick and worked her way into an administrative job. She lived in a two-bedroom flat with her boyfriend Richard 'Dick' Swallow and a big black cat called Alex. The couple split in mid-2001 but stayed friends.

In late September 2001 Amy flew to Florida to visit Jason Calais, a boy she had liked at school, and he introduced her to his neighbour, Eric 'Rub' Wright. Wright was attracted to her; she told him they were only friends. A few weeks later he rang to ask whether he could stay with her for a couple of days on a trip north, and she hesitantly agreed. He rented a car, drove up from Florida and arrived on Thursday, 18 October 2001. The next night she, Wright and Swallow had a lobster dinner at her flat; Swallow said he wanted to meet the man.

On the Saturday they spent the day at the Museum of Fine Arts in Boston, and Swallow rang at about 11 a.m. to say he had bought Ozzy Osbourne tickets. That evening she and Wright drove to the Old Port in Portland, arriving about 10.30 p.m., and she rang her mother to invite her for a drink. At the Four Play sports bar she hugged two men she did not introduce, and the same two turned up at the Pavilion dance club on Middle Street at midnight and she danced with them. Wright went to the toilet, came out around one o'clock to find the bar closing and Amy gone, waited outside until 1.20 a.m. and drove back to her flat, assuming she had left without him.

He said he and a friend had taken Amy to a party at an apartment on Brighton Avenue that fizzled out, then driven her back to the Pavilion around 2 a.m. and gone home. Witnesses still outside the club had not seen him drop her off, his roommates said he got in between three and three fifteen, and police records showed he had been stopped at 3 a.m. for driving with his high beams on. His car had just been detailed. A few days after Amy vanished his friend Ryan Campbell reported a stolen 9mm handgun. Wright, meanwhile, submitted to an inconclusive polygraph, slept in his car in her driveway, showered in her flat, left her belongings on the kitchen table and an angry note, and flew home on the Tuesday.

Amy was declared missing on 23 October; her family offered a $35,000 reward two days later. Detectives brought in a psychic, Vicky Monroe, who named Russ, spoke of a blow to the head, a yellow house, a man who had lived in two states and was now with his mother, a large farm, and said Amy would be found before the first snow. It began snowing heavily as she was recovered. The autopsy showed she had been beaten, sexually assaulted and shot in the head, with traces of GHB in her system.

The next day, at a petrol station in Alabama, he pointed a pistol at a man and asked what he was looking at; on 12 December a four-to-six-hour standoff at a house outside Troy, Alabama ended when negotiators traded a cigarette and a can of soda for his two guns.

Amy's mother and family have spent the years since running RAD, a rape aggression defence programme, and two of the detectives wrote a book about the case, Finding Amy.

The case

Murder of Amy St. Laurent

Victims

Amy St. Laurent (25). from South Portland, Maine; worked at the Pratt & Whitney plant in North Berwick and lived in a two-bedroom flat with her ex-boyfriend

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 26 August 2023.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Richard 'Dick' Swallow. Amy's ex-boyfriend, who stayed on her couch while Rub Wright visited
Jason Calais. a boy Amy liked in high school, living in Florida, who introduced her to Wright
Mary Young. Westbrook's friend in Delray Beach, Florida, who called the police
Ryan Campbell. friend, who reported his 9mm handgun stolen
Kush Sharma. roommate on Brighton Avenue
Jason Cook. roommate
Vicky Monroe. the psychic brought in by investigators
Diane Jenkins. Amy's mother
Katy. Amy's best friend from high school

The timeline

  1. 1994 Amy St. Laurent graduates from South Portland High School with honours (South Portland High School)about 0:15:33
  2. At thirteen Amy is diagnosed with hip dysplasiaabout 0:13:40
  3. by the time she was 16 She has two surgeries, spends a long time in a body cast and does months of physical therapyabout 0:14:00

Last meals

  • Amy St. Laurent. lobster dinner dinner at her flat with Wright and Swallow the night before she went out, October 2001about 0:24:34

Places and phrases

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode