FILE 471 / 29 February 2024 / 173 MIN / full

The Talented Mr Psychopath

Amity, MaineListen

The town

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

It's Amity, Maine... It's in Aroostook County about 0:05:25

History, in brief

1826

First settled in 1826 and incorporated in 1836 from a township originally called T-10 R-1 WELS.

about 0:08:17

1794

Some say the town was named for the 1794 Treaty of Amity Commerce and Navigation between England and the United States, which aimed to end the boundary dispute between Maine and New Brunswick.

about 0:09:00

1839

In 1839 the so-called Aroostook War ended with the signing of a treaty that gave Maine the town, whose ownership had been disputed.

about 0:09:45

Town note

Surveyors placed a monument in Monument Brook right on the border, known as Monument 1 and Monument 2.

about 0:10:03
All 6 history facts

1826

First settled in 1826 and incorporated in 1836 from a township originally called T-10 R-1 WELS.

about 0:08:17

1794

Some say the town was named for the 1794 Treaty of Amity Commerce and Navigation between England and the United States, which aimed to end the boundary dispute between Maine and New Brunswick.

about 0:09:00

1839

In 1839 the so-called Aroostook War ended with the signing of a treaty that gave Maine the town, whose ownership had been disputed.

about 0:09:45

Town note

Surveyors placed a monument in Monument Brook right on the border, known as Monument 1 and Monument 2.

about 0:10:03

1880

The town had its highest population in 1880, with 432 people.

about 0:10:13

1970

The population reached its low point of 156 in 1970.

about 0:10:31

The figures, as told

Religious

46%

Biggest faith: Jewish, 0.0%

about 0:14:17

Who lives here

White 84.8% · Black 3.4% · Asian 0.0% · Hispanic 0.0%

Ethnicity can overlap race.

Crime / national average

Property crime
▼ about one third below

about 0:23:52

Violent crime
▼ one third of

about 0:24:00

Money

Median home value$96,900
Two-bedroom rent$790
Median household income$28,594
Cost of living$75,000
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2024

Property crime

"about one third below"

Comparison: "national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2024 about 0:23:52

Violent crime

"one third of"

Comparison: "national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2024 about 0:24:00

Median age

"55.2"

Comparison: "37 in the rest of the country". No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:13:17

Divorced

"34%"

Comparison: "usually about 20%". No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:13:45

Single with children

"25%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:13:50

Two or more races

"12%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:14:08

Religious

"46%"

Comparison: "a little below the average". Direction: below.

As told in 2024 about 0:14:17

Unemployment rate

"14.8%"

Comparison: "3.6% in the United States". No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:14:49

Median household income

"$28,594"

Comparison: "$69,021 in the rest of the country". No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:15:20

Cost of living

"$75,000"

Comparison: "$100,000 average". Direction: below.

As told in 2024 about 0:15:42

Median home cost

"$96,900"

No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:15:49

Average two-bedroom rental

"$790"

No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:16:02

Halton four-bedroom house

"$219,900"

No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:17:23

Amity five-bedroom farmhouse

"$950,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:18:42

The reviews

3.5 / 5 · average of 4

3 stars

“The town I live in is very small, everyone knows each other and outsiders are kind of left out; the university two towns over brings diverse cultures together.”
about 0:10:47

5 stars

“A remote place to visit and an interesting piece of history; go in dry weather and wear high rubber boots to walk out to it.”
about 0:11:31

5 stars

“A once-in-a-lifetime experience, as in I'm not walking through the woods again to get there.”
about 0:12:26

In Maine

Closest episodes

  1. The Psycho SamuraiCaribou, Maine · 16 February 2023103 km / 64 miShow on map
  2. Facebook Catfish KillerOld Town, Maine · 24 August 2024127 km / 79 miShow on map
  3. A Diabolical Death ParadeMachiasport, Maine · 24 March 2022147 km / 91 miShow on map
  4. Surprising Serial KillerCarmel, Maine · 4 December 2025153 km / 95 miShow on map
  5. A Secret In Every HoleHartland, Maine · 11 February 2021171 km / 106 miShow on map

The story

Amity is a small town in Aroostook County in the far north-east of Maine, close enough to the Canadian border that James says you can walk east for five miles and be in Canada. Its population in 2010 was 217. In June of that year it became the scene of what a judge later called the worst massacre in the history of Maine. Jeffrey Ryan, known as Jeff, was 55. He was a disabled Vietnam veteran who had lived in the Amity area for about 12 years and took prescription painkillers for his injuries. He had been married twice. His second wife, Jamie Merrill, divorced him in about 2007, saying she had left after seven years of abuse and sought refuge in shelters for battered women before moving to New Hampshire. Their son Jesse was born in 2000 and was 10 in 2010. He had lived mostly with his father in a mobile home on Route 1 but moved back to his mother's in February 2010. In 2009 Jeff and Tamara began speaking again, and in 2010 he proposed to her and they planned to remarry. Jeff's best friend was Jason DeHaan, 30, who lived about a mile down Route 1 with his wife and three children and visited the trailer almost every day. He grew up in Ellsworth, where he ran track and wrestled and made the honour roll at Ellsworth High School before dropping out in his senior year. He had been removed from his mother's home at 12 because of physical abuse and lived with an uncle until he was 17. In 2008 he worked as a live-in aide on the congressional campaign of John Frary, a former college professor in Farmington, and he later stayed with Reverend Louis Glidden of St Stephen the Martyr Anglican Church in Oakland. Glidden put him out in February 2010 after he took a car without permission and the women at the church became afraid of his mood swings. On Father's Day 2010 Jeff drove to Lewiston, New Hampshire, to collect Jesse for a weekend of fishing. Jamie spoke to her son at about 8.30 on the Tuesday evening. On the Wednesday she rang Jeff's phone all day and got no answer, and Jason DeHaan did not come home either. Jason's brother Jake went to the trailer three times. On the third visit he shone a torch through the window and saw blood everywhere. In a back bedroom they found Jesse, stabbed repeatedly and lying on his hands and knees. Jeff's blue and silver 1989 Ford F-150 was missing. Investigators searching the property found Jeff in a small shed beside the trailer, also stabbed. An hour and a half later they found Jason in a ditch in front of the house, his throat cut so deeply that he was nearly decapitated. The medical examiner said all three died from multiple sharp-force injuries and that all of them appeared to have been trying to get away. A beer bottle and a cigarette butt at the scene gave a full DNA profile of an unknown man. Three days after the bodies were found, a burned pickup was found about 15 miles away on a field road off Bancroft Road in Weston. They found footwear impressions in the path that matched impressions near the burned truck. He said he had gone to the trailer because his father told him Ryan owed him $10,000 from a drug deal. He said he had met Jeff once and had left a beer bottle on the kitchen sink two or three weeks earlier. He denied ever meeting Jason or Jesse and agreed to give DNA and fingerprints. Three days later his fingerprints matched the bottle. The next day his DNA matched the bottle and the cigarette butt. Police interviewed him again, this time reading him his rights several times. He said his plan had been to kill Jeff Ryan and leave no witnesses or evidence, because Jeff was a bad man who hurt people and he thought something good could grow from taking him away. He asked Jeff about some nails, and when Jeff bent over in the woodshed he stabbed him in the back. He then went inside, stabbed Jason on the couch, chased Jesse into the back bedroom and stabbed him in the back as he cowered. He went outside, found Jason gone, chased him down the road and cut his throat two or three times. He said he had not planned to kill Jason or Jesse but did not want to get caught. The defence called no witnesses. Dr Catherine Thomas said he was out of touch with reality and believed he was ridding the world of a bad man and boosting his resume as an assassin. The state's experts said he had no mental defect, heard no voices and acted methodically afterwards by cleaning the scene, burning his clothes and throwing away the knife. Dr John Lorenz for the defence described a neglected, abused child who had never had counselling.

The case

Murder of Jeffrey Ryan, Jesse Ryan and Jason DeHaan

Victims

Jeffrey Ryan (55). disabled Vietnam veteran, lived in the trailer on Route 1
Jesse Ryan (10). his son, had just finished the fourth grade
Jason DeHaan (30). his best friend, lived about a mile down Route 1

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 29 February 2024.

Accused

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Jamie Merrill. Jeff's second ex-wife and Jesse's mother; six months pregnant and living in New Hampshire
Mariah Ryan. Jeff and Tamara's 16-year-old daughter
Shannon Ryan. Jeff's adult son, living in Texas
Jason DeHaan's family. his father , brother Jake and 12-year-old daughter
Jake DeHaan. Jason's brother, found the blood and the bodies
Donald Hiltz. acquaintance who spoke to in Dover after the murders
John Frary. former congressional candidate who sheltered during his 2008 campaign
Reverend Louis Glidden. Anglican priest in Oakland who sheltered then put him out
Janice Wilber. grandmother
Stephen. uncle
Dale Foley. neighbour in Orient who answered the press with a shotgun
Tara Jay. neighbour who lived up the route from the Ryan family
Larry Hamilton. Amity resident quoted about the killing
Dr John Lorenz. defence psychologist who testified about childhood
Detective Keegan. detective who interviewed

The timeline

  1. at age 12 is removed from his mother's home by the Department of Health and Human Services because of physical abuse and goes to live with an uncle until he is 17about 1:41:16
  2. September 1998 Jeff Ryan and Jamie Merrill marryabout 0:27:22
  3. 2000 Their son Jesse is bornabout 0:27:00
  4. about 2007 Jeff and Jamie Merrill divorce on the grounds of irreconcilable differencesabout 0:26:41
  5. 2008 works as a live-in aide on John Frary's congressional campaign (John Frary house)about 1:46:58
  6. 2009 Jeff and Tamara start speaking again and rekindle their romance; in 2010 he proposesabout 0:28:58
  7. January 2010 Glidden travels to China and leaves looking after his house and pets (St Stephen the Martyr Anglican Church)about 2:03:36
  8. February 2010 Glidden has removed from his property after he takes a car without permission (St Stephen the Martyr Anglican Church)about 2:04:22
  9. February 2010 Jesse moves out of his father's trailer and back to his mother's house (Ryan trailer)about 0:33:52
  10. April 22, 2010 posts 'life is good' on his Facebook pageabout 1:40:57
  11. just after Memorial Day 2010 comes to Orient to stay at the residence ( house)about 1:20:56
  12. June 2010 Jeff Ryan has a verbal altercation with and tells him to stay away from his daughter (Ryan trailer)about 2:09:39
  13. two or three weeks before the murders visits the trailer, drinks a beer and leaves the bottle on the kitchen sink (Ryan trailer)about 1:21:23
  14. Father's Day 2010 Jeff collects Jesse in Lewiston for a weekend of fishing in Amity (Ryan trailer)about 0:33:06
  15. Tuesday 22 June 2010, about 8.30 p.m. Jamie Merrill speaks to Jesse on the phone, the last time she hears from himabout 0:34:26
  16. the night of 22 June 2010 stabs Jeff Ryan in the woodshed, then Jason DeHaan on the couch and Jesse in the back bedroom, and finally chases Jason down the road and cuts his throat (Ryan trailer)about 1:35:44
  17. 22 or 23 June 2010 sees come out of the woods covered in blood; says 'I killed them all' ( house)about 1:13:04
  18. after the murders burns Jeff Ryan's truck on Bancroft Road and throws the knife into a bog on U.S. Route 1 (Bancroft Road)about 1:15:33
  19. Wednesday 23 June 2010 Jamie Merrill rings Jeff's phone all day and gets no answerabout 0:34:26
  20. Wednesday 23 June 2010 Jason DeHaan fails to come homeabout 0:35:25
  21. Thursday 24 June 2010 Jake DeHaan sees blood through the trailer window and returns with his father; they force the door and find Jesse, then Jeff in the shed and Jason in the ditch (Ryan trailer)about 0:35:58
  22. June 25, 2010 tells police he went to Sanford by himselfabout 1:11:15
  23. June 27, 2010 The burned remains of Jeff Ryan's pickup are found about 15 miles from the home on a field road off Bancroft Road (field road off Bancroft Road)about 1:08:15

Places and phrases

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode