FILE 319 / 17 September 2022 / 66 MIN / express

Satanic Stupidity

Sanford, MaineListen

The town

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

"We're going to Sandford, Maine, and this is southern Maine in the little panhandle there next to New Hampshire"; not too far from Old Orchard Beach. about 0:03:37

History, in brief

1745

The Mousam River runs through the town and provided power for industry; there was a saw mill on it as early as 1745.

about 0:05:02

1867

The Goodall mills came to Sanford in 1867, making mohair plush for upholstering railroad seats, carpets, draperies, auto fabrics, military uniform fabric and Palm Beach fabric for summer suits.

about 0:05:09

1954

In 1954 Burlington Mills, the nation's largest textile firm, bought the mills, then closed the plants and left large numbers of people unemployed, ruining the town's economy for a while.

about 0:05:44

Town note

The town now has diversified industries, including biotech.

about 0:05:59
All 6 history facts

1745

The Mousam River runs through the town and provided power for industry; there was a saw mill on it as early as 1745.

about 0:05:02

1867

The Goodall mills came to Sanford in 1867, making mohair plush for upholstering railroad seats, carpets, draperies, auto fabrics, military uniform fabric and Palm Beach fabric for summer suits.

about 0:05:09

1954

In 1954 Burlington Mills, the nation's largest textile firm, bought the mills, then closed the plants and left large numbers of people unemployed, ruining the town's economy for a while.

about 0:05:44

Town note

The town now has diversified industries, including biotech.

about 0:05:59

Town note

A film about the town and how it perseveres starred Jason Robards.

about 0:06:11

Town note

Because of the murder the town was referred to all over the country as Terror Town.

about 0:06:29

The figures, as told

Money

Median home valueabout $261,800
Median household incomeabout $44,213
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2022

Population

"21,253"

No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:04:07

Median household income

"about $44,213"

No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:04:29

Median home price

"about $261,800"

No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:04:35

The reviews

3.5 / 5 · average of 4

5 stars

“Written in all capital letters: there need to be more things to do in Sanford besides the bowling alley and movie theatres, the schools are pretty good and the town itself is pretty calm.”
about 0:06:45

4 stars

“The Applebee's here is great, located in a plaza where it is always busy, family oriented with great service.”
about 0:07:06

3 stars

“A very short review: the weather changes daily and is always different.”
about 0:07:38

2 stars

“A former resident says Sanford is a pretty crappy town with not a lot to do and definitely not the safest; describes a woman trying to get into her car and a stabbing in a school bathroom, and says the town has always had a heroin and cocaine problem that is getting worse.”
about 0:08:05

In Maine

Closest episodes

  1. Til Murder Do Us PartLebanon, Maine · 30 January 202513 km / 8 miShow on map
  2. Kinky Killer CoupleDover, New Hampshire · 30 November 202428 km / 17 miShow on map
  3. Murder Bubbling Under The SurfaceOld Orchard Beach, Maine · 12 April 201735 km / 22 miShow on map
  4. An Extra Terrible PersonKittery, Maine · 30 May 201837 km / 23 miShow on map
  5. The Stranger & The PsychicScarborough, Maine · 26 August 202338 km / 24 miShow on map

The story

Sanford, Maine, in 1984 was a mill town of about 21,000 people in the southern part of the state, close to the New Hampshire line. He had been born without a hip joint on one side, had several operations and walked with a limp that everybody in the neighbourhood knew. He played drums in the school band, smoked weed, took the odd hit of acid and liked metal. A year earlier he had been put on six months' probation after he and some other boys broke into a car and stole grapes.

He had also become fixated on a fifteen-year-old flute player in the band. He wrote asking her to meet him and she did not come. He wrote again that he would get his rightful due and that she would be repaid. In the days before the murder he put a note in her flute case saying her days were numbered unless she wore a purple top and purple socks and acknowledged him. He stole her shoes and said she would get them back only if she met him alone, warning that if anyone else was involved she would lose not only her clogs but possibly her life.

On Sunday 29 April 1984 the clocks had gone forward that morning, and nobody in Sanford was sure what time it really was. The school band had been hired to play at the opening day of harness racing at Scarborough Downs. He said he was going for a walk to get something to eat.

Giselle Cote was twelve. She liked stickers and Michael Jackson and was a normal, well-liked neighbourhood child. She left her house on Jackson Street at about quarter past five to meet friends near the woods on Pikes Hill and was due home by quarter past six for Sunday dinner. She never arrived. By eight o'clock her parents had called the police, and the search went on all night.

About twelve hours after she left home her body was found on the edge of the Mousam River, half in and half out of the water, lightly covered with leaves and sticks, some five hundred yards from her house. She was wearing a purple blouse. Detectives found white plastic nylon rope tied to a steel reinforcement bar inside a large square section of sewer pipe about a hundred yards from the body, a pipe the local teenagers used to hang out in. Marks on her body showed she had been strangled or hanged, and there were ligature marks on her wrists.

Witnesses came forward. Two people described a slender teenager guiding a twelve-year-old girl in a purple shirt through the woods with his hands on her shoulders. At half past six four people had seen him stooping by a shallow pool near where she was found, saying he was looking for a fishing spot while carrying no gear.

A search of his locker and his room turned up what the police called satanic artwork, the Satanic Bible, and handwritten Satan's prayers and Satan's rules. On the interrogation tapes he admitted being a Satanist and explained hexes and destruction rituals, saying Satanism did not advocate killing anyone. He denied being near the river, then admitted it, and said he had tripped over the body, said "here's a body", kicked at it and told nobody because he did not want to get involved.

The autopsy found sperm cells on her shirt just below the neckline and on a pair of green underwear about twenty-five feet from the body, with no sperm in or near the vaginal area.

By October the town had lost its head. Anonymous death threats were sent to teenage girls, a note on a time card at Oncore Shoe said a woman's sister would be dead by Halloween, and a taxi driver reported a similar threat. A crowd gathered at the abandoned mill on Spruce and High Streets talking of getting the cult they believed was inside, and a fire damaged the upper storeys. The police said it was all kid stuff and rumour.

His defence complained of a gruelling three-hour interrogation. The prosecution said he killed Giselle for the hell of it and as part of a game, that he had tied her wrists to put her at his mercy, and dwelt on the satanic holidays. Afterwards the police chief said there was no evidence of any organised cult.

The case

Murder of Giselle Cote

Victims

Giselle Cote (12). schoolgirl from neighbourhood; liked stickers and Michael Jackson

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 17 September 2022.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

the flute player. fifteen-year-old girl in the school band whom wrote threatening notes to and whose shoes he stole
Arthur D. Mateya. friend, an avowed devil worshipper
Arthur J. Kelly. Sanford chief of police, who said the cult rumours were invented
Giselle's father's girlfriend. said justice was done and it was a hard day for everybody

The timeline

  1. is born without a hip joint on one side; he later has a knee operation, two hernia operations and a ruptured disc in his back, and always walks with a limpabout 0:11:34
  2. 1983 and some other boys break into a car and steal grapes; he gets six months' probationabout 0:14:24
  3. the Wednesday or Thursday before the murder, 1984 puts a note in the flute case of a fifteen-year-old girl saying her days are numbered unless she wears a purple top and purple socks and acknowledges him; he has also stolen her shoes and demands she meet him alone (Sanford High School)about 0:18:40
  4. April 29th, 1984 The clocks are put forward that morning, so nobody in town is sure what time it isabout 0:10:34
  5. April 29th, 1984 The school band plays at the opening day of harness racing; plays the snare drum (Scarborough Downs)about 0:16:38
  6. about 5 p.m., April 29th, 1984 The band gets back to Sanford; mother picks him up at ten past five and he says he is going for a walk to get something to eatabout 0:17:17
  7. about 5.15 p.m., April 29th, 1984 Giselle Cote leaves her house on Jackson Street to meet friends near the woods on Pikes Hill; she is due home by 6.15 for Sunday dinner (Giselle Cote's house)about 0:24:46
  8. 6.30 p.m., April 29th, 1984 Four people see stooping next to a shallow pool of the Mousam River; he tells them he is looking for a good fishing spot but has no fishing gear and will not meet their eyes (Mousam River)about 0:33:57
  9. shortly before 7 p.m., April 29th, 1984 Three teenagers who know see him walking over a bank of the Mousam River, pale and slouched, and he buys weed from them (Mousam River)about 0:33:07
  10. about 8 p.m., April 29th, 1984 Giselle's parents call the police; neighbours search all night without finding her (Pikes Hill woods)about 0:25:36
  11. April 30th, 1984 About twelve hours after she left home her body is found on the edge of the Mousam River, half in and half out of the water, covered with leaves and sticks, about five hundred yards from her house; she is wearing a purple blouse (Mousam River bank)about 0:26:19

Places and phrases

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode