FILE 274 / 16 April 2022 / 60 MIN / express

The Perfect Crime

Hill City, South DakotaListen

The town

N ↑Public placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

This is in southwestern South Dakota down there, in the corner. about 0:02:25

History, in brief

Town note

Hill City started as a mining town, like Deadwood, except that tin mining was what they were into.

about 0:03:21

Town note

Mount Rushmore in the 1940s, Custer State Park and the Sturgis Motorcycle Rally help the area's tourism a lot.

about 0:03:58

Town note

A Tyrannosaurus rex fossil was found and named Sue after Sue Hendrickson, the paleontologist who found it.

about 0:04:44

Town note

A controversy followed over who owned the fossils, with the landowner, the tribe who originally owned the land, the federal government and the Black Hills Institute all involved.

about 0:05:03
All 6 history facts

Town note

Hill City started as a mining town, like Deadwood, except that tin mining was what they were into.

about 0:03:21

Town note

Mount Rushmore in the 1940s, Custer State Park and the Sturgis Motorcycle Rally help the area's tourism a lot.

about 0:03:58

Town note

A Tyrannosaurus rex fossil was found and named Sue after Sue Hendrickson, the paleontologist who found it.

about 0:04:44

Town note

A controversy followed over who owned the fossils, with the landowner, the tribe who originally owned the land, the federal government and the Black Hills Institute all involved.

about 0:05:03

1992

On May 12th, 1992, FBI agents seized the dinosaur from the institute over the course of three days and shipped it to the South Dakota School of Mines and Technology.

about 0:05:25

Town note

It was auctioned off by Sotheby's Auction House and sold to the Field Museum in Chicago for $8.36 million, after Maurice s was found to be the rightful owner as the landowner.

about 0:05:35

The figures, as told

Money

Cost of livingabout average
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2022

Population

"1,074"

No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:03:06

Population growth

"almost doubled since 2000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:03:10

Cost of living

"about average"

Comparison: "average". Direction: about the same.

As told in 2022 about 0:04:25

The reviews

No rated reviews

No reviews recorded.

In South Dakota

Closest episodes

  1. Cheers To My KillerWhitewood, South Dakota · 6 May 202359 km / 37 miShow on map
  2. Torture, Torment & TerrorSpearfish, South Dakota · 28 December 202365 km / 40 miShow on map
  3. Messy Methy Murder ConspiracyBelle Fourche, South Dakota · 10 May 202585 km / 53 miShow on map
  4. The Definition Of DepravityScottsbluff, Nebraska · 8 November 2017230 km / 143 miShow on map
  5. Tragedy At The Trailer ParkWheatland, Wyoming · 17 January 2018238 km / 148 miShow on map

The story

Hill City, South Dakota, lies in the southwestern corner of the state in the Black Hills. It began as a tin-mining town, like Deadwood, and by 1993 had a population of 1,074, with tourism from Mount Rushmore, Custer State Park and the Sturgis motorcycle rally. His father, a retired oil field worker, died when he was young, and his mother ran a seasonal gift shop called Betty's. He joined the army and served in the Persian Gulf in the first Iraq war. Neighbours called him a loner who carried a survival knife and fake grenades.

By October she knew his wife Tracy and Randy Dixon, a man who had attached himself to the couple in Arizona, and the four spent time at Henson's house in Rapid City.

Henson parked at the intersection of China Gulch Road and Marshall Gulch Road and they walked to a campsite with a trailer and a tent.

Dixon leaned against the car smoking. He dragged the body across the road, then made her hold the flashlight while he cut off Dixon's head and hands with the axe; she said she looked away.

He bagged the head and hands separately, took Dixon's wallet and the axe, and drove to Sheridan Lake Road, where he stopped on gravel near a steep overlook, switched off the lights and threw the bags over the edge. He then took her to the Oyster Pub, ordered oysters and beer for himself and a soda for her, and chatted with the bartender while she played the gambling machines. Afterwards he let her collect her daughter and take her home, asked for sex, which she said she acquiesced to, and told her he had committed the perfect crime. The next day he told her to remove her licence plates and report them stolen.

On the morning of 15 November a deer hunter found the body, without head or hands, about 30 feet from the edge of a forest service road, and flagged down a deputy. He gave a voluntary statement claiming he had been with campers Andrea and Chris Drain and knew nothing of Dixon, and went with officers to the campsite. The Drains denied seeing him; through the names he gave, the police found Henson, who first denied everything and then said she had watched the killing. A couple of days later they recovered the head and hands.

The defence argued post-traumatic stress disorder and paranoia and asked for first-degree manslaughter, but psychologists found no organic mental disorder and judged him sane. The state Supreme Court found the admission of other statements to be harmless error and affirmed.

The case

Murder of Randy Dixon

Victims

Randy Dixon. friend of who had latched on to and his wife Tracy in Arizona; shot in the head and dismembered

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 16 April 2022.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Angela Henson. friend of who worked at his mother's gift shop; drove him to the campsite, witnessed the killing and testified
Leo Ham. former neighbour who said did not spook him
Andrea Drain. camper named as an alibi; said she had not seen him
Chris Drain. camper named as an alibi; said he had not seen him
deer hunter. found the body beside the forest service road and flagged down a deputy

The timeline

  1. 1988 yearbook lists him in the debate club, photography and on the wrestling team (Rapid City Stevens High School)about 0:12:11
  2. April 1989 A newspaper reports injured in a motorcycle accident after passing a vehicle at over 80 mph on a blind curve (Sheridan Lake Road)about 0:14:10
  3. 1989 and his mother leave the house they were living in at Hill City ( family home)about 0:21:12
  4. early 1990s joins the army and goes to the Persian Gulf for the first Iraq warabout 0:18:58
  5. August 1993 Angela Henson first meets while working for his mother at the gift shop (Betty's)about 0:26:15
  6. October 1993 Henson meets wife Tracy and Randy Dixon, who had latched on to the couple in Arizonaabout 0:27:01
  7. November 13, 1993 and Randy Dixon stay overnight at Angela Henson's house (Angela Henson's house)about 0:27:46
  8. November 14, 1993, about 4 or 5 pm asks Henson and Dixon to drive him to his campsite for his belongings (Angela Henson's house)about 0:28:02
  9. November 14, 1993 Henson drives them to the intersection of China Gulch Road and Marshall Gulch Road and they walk to the campsite (China Gulch Road and Marshall Gulch Road)about 0:29:16
  10. November 14, 1993 At the trailer takes a silver case and a nine millimetre submachine gun and hands the bag to Henson to carry ( campsite)about 0:30:23
  11. November 14, 1993, evening shoots Randy Dixon behind the car (China Gulch Road and Marshall Gulch Road)about 0:32:14
  12. November 14, 1993 tells Henson she knows nothing and saw nothing, and threatens her daughter (China Gulch Road and Marshall Gulch Road)about 0:32:37
  13. November 14, 1993 drags the body across the road and cuts off the head and hands with a double-bladed axe while Henson holds the flashlight (Forest service road outside Hill City)about 0:36:09

Places and phrases

N ↑Public placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode