FILE 386 / 6 May 2023 / 72 MIN / express

Cheers To My Killer

Whitewood, South DakotaListen

The town

N ↑Public placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Whitewood, South Dakota, western South Dakota, only twenty minutes outside Deadwood, in Lawrence County, area code 605 about 0:04:57

History, in brief

1888

Whitewood was platted in 1888, when Deadwood was booming.

about 0:04:38

Town note

It grew when the Chicago and Northwestern Railway was extended to this point and towns were built along it.

about 0:04:46

Town note

The Pioneer Townsite Company purchased the town site of Whitewood, buying the land from early settler William Selby.

about 0:05:31
All 11 history facts

1888

Whitewood was platted in 1888, when Deadwood was booming.

about 0:04:38

Town note

It grew when the Chicago and Northwestern Railway was extended to this point and towns were built along it.

about 0:04:46

Town note

The Pioneer Townsite Company purchased the town site of Whitewood, buying the land from early settler William Selby.

about 0:05:31

Town note

Business lots sold for $250 to $500 and the town soon filled up.

about 0:05:36

Town note

The town had three hotels, two saloons, a barber shop, a drug store, a clothing store and a saw mill.

about 0:05:46

Town note

Seth Bullock, the hardware man from the Deadwood television show, was a real person who helped convince the Fremont, Elkhorn and Missouri Valley railroads to build a track from Whitewood into Deadwood.

about 0:06:16

1890

A train used that line for the first time in 1890; the same year the railroad built a track into Belle Fourche and St. Onge.

about 0:06:26

Town note

Because Deadwood kept catching fire, Whitewood's buildings were built of sandstone so they would not burn down.

about 0:06:55

Town note

The National Register of Historic Places says the people of Whitewood secured their future with formidable buildings and a developed main commercial street while neighbouring towns disappeared.

about 0:07:03

Town note

Whitewood recently had its 125th anniversary.

about 0:07:21

The figures, as told

Money

Median home value$303,800
Median household incomeabout $56,250
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2023

Population growth since 2020

"up about 200 people"

Direction: above.

As told in 2023 about 0:03:59

Median household income

"about $56,250"

Comparison: "right around the national average". Direction: about the same.

As told in 2023 about 0:04:22

Median home cost

"$303,800"

Comparison: "right around the national average". Direction: about the same.

As told in 2023 about 0:04:27

The reviews

3.8 / 5 · average of 5

5 stars

“Small and quaint, quiet, gorgeous scenery, friendly neighbours, a quick drive to market and short drives to surrounding towns for further necessities.”
about 0:07:33

5 stars

“A mean five stars: go away, don't move here, we like our small town small.”
about 0:07:52

5 stars

“Nondescript outside but you feel transported to another time: blond pine tongue and groove, twelve foot walls, original tin ceiling, historical guns, a beautiful bar and backbar, and a flirtatious red-headed bartender named Erika.”
about 0:08:28

1 star

“Many one-star reviews of one incident on August 16th, 2021, when the owner was extremely rude and told Shorty Rossi and his party to leave because he had his service dog with him.”
about 0:09:56

3 stars

“Not quite as good as it used to be; the burger has lost its juicy goodness but was better than lots of fast food.”
about 0:10:43

In South Dakota

Closest episodes

  1. Torture, Torment & TerrorSpearfish, South Dakota · 28 December 202314 km / 9 miShow on map
  2. Messy Methy Murder ConspiracyBelle Fourche, South Dakota · 10 May 202528 km / 17 miShow on map
  3. The Perfect CrimeHill City, South Dakota · 16 April 202259 km / 37 miShow on map
  4. Twin Marrying MadnessLemmon, South Dakota · 29 June 2024201 km / 125 miShow on map
  5. A Deadly Blame GamePierre, South Dakota · 22 November 2025264 km / 164 miShow on map

The story

They started dating in their senior year at Deadwood High School and married in September 1958, two months after graduating. They built their life in Whitewood, South Dakota, where Larry worked for years at the Wheeler Lumber Company, and raised three sons, Marshall, Leonard and Miles. Everyone else in the story described him as strict and loud and a heavy drinker, but not violent.

In 1981, at 40, Larry was diagnosed with bladder cancer and had successful surgery. Within a year she began an affair with a co-worker, Roger Schoon, whose family was friendly with theirs. The affair ran from late 1986 into 1991 and, by her account, nobody in the small town noticed. She left the company in the spring of 1990 but kept seeing him. In late 1990 Larry developed colon problems, had two rounds of colon surgery and had to wear a colostomy bag. A friend, Mick Roberts, said the bag left him deeply depressed and that Larry had said he might as well be dead.

She said they stayed together, sought marriage counselling and that Larry kept bringing it up over the following months. On an evening in early April 1991 the two of them went out drinking at a local diner. He went to the living room. She went downstairs, took a shotgun, came back and said, "Larry, I'm gonna kill you." He raised his glass in a toast. She fired from about four feet, hitting him in the chest, and he died face down by the couch. His blood alcohol content was 0.358.

Deputies Charles and Russell found her there, and she repeatedly said, "I killed my husband, I can't believe it." Interviewed that day, she said she did not remember whether he had threatened her. The next day her own doctor found a small bruise on her chest and upper arm and a large bruise on her hip, though the state said another examination showed no bruises.

His sons and their friends said Larry drank and was a strict disciplinarian but never hit anyone. Monica Jorganson, once engaged to Leonard, said he was domineering but not abusive. The defence, John Hughes and Mike Strain, argued mercy killing, self-defence, family violence and alcohol, and sought to suppress her interview, the death certificate signed by coroner Michael K. Chiput, gory photographs and video, a church bulletin and other evidence. They also sought to present a psychological autopsy of Larry by Dr. Richard Fairbarn. It was the first time the battered woman defence was used in South Dakota.

The prosecutor pointed out that Larry was unarmed and watching television, that she had passed three exits and three doors on her way to the gun, and that she could have called for help. She afterwards spoke at anti-domestic violence events, and her name remains on Larry's headstone in the Little Dane cemetery in Lawrence County, with no end date.

The case

Murder of Larry Dean Bertzlaff

Victims

Larry Dean Bertzlaff (49). husband of 32 years, a long-time Wheeler Lumber Company employee who had survived bladder cancer and wore a colostomy bag

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 6 May 2023.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Roger Schoon. lover, a co-worker at Wheeler Lumber Company
John Hughes. defence attorney
Mike Strain. defence attorney
Chuck Crawdy. Lawrence County sheriff, a lifelong friend and former neighbour of the couple, present during the interview
Dr. Richard Fairbarn. psychologist who prepared a psychological autopsy of Larry for the defence
Monica Jorganson. engaged to the middle son Leonard in the 1980s; testified she saw no abuse
Dwayne Reddick. neighbour who spoke to Larry about hunting four hours before the shooting
Dean Herman. plant manager at Wheeler Lumber Company
Bud Hudson. co-owner of the Whitewood Bar
Mick Roberts. Larry's friend, who said the colostomy bag left him deeply depressed
Marshall Bertzlaff. son
Leonard Bertzlaff. son
Miles Bertzlaff. son
Michael K. Chiput. county coroner who signed the death certificate

The timeline

  1. 1941 Larry Dean Bertzlaff is bornabout 0:12:54
  2. 1942 Jean Johnson is bornabout 0:12:54
  3. their senior year and Larry start dating at Deadwood High School (Deadwood High School)about 0:14:17
  4. September 1958 They marry two months after graduatingabout 0:14:28
  5. Their three sons, Marshall, Leonard and Miles, are bornabout 0:14:53
  6. Larry works for years at the Wheeler Lumber Company in Whitewood (Wheeler Lumber Company)about 0:14:58
  7. 1981 Larry is diagnosed with bladder cancer at 40 and has successful surgeryabout 0:17:13
  8. Larry pays way through four years of college so she could support the family if he diedabout 0:17:31

Places and phrases

N ↑Public placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode