FILE 650 / 22 November 2025 / 72 MIN / express

A Deadly Blame Game

Pierre, South DakotaListen

The town

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placePublic placePublic placePublic placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

We're going to South Dakota and we're going to the capital of South Dakota, which is called Pierre; this is in Hughes County. about 0:03:10

History, in brief

1817

Fort Pierre developed earlier, with a permanent settlement there since 1817; it began as a fur trading post.

about 0:05:22

Town note

Fort Pierre Chouteau was named after Pierre Chouteau, an American fur trader from St Louis of colonial French origin.

about 0:05:34

1880

The town itself was founded in 1880 on the east bank of the Missouri River, opposite Fort Pierre.

about 0:05:55

Town note

Pierre was selected as the state capital because it sits dead centre, the same distance for everybody.

about 0:06:04
All 5 history facts

1817

Fort Pierre developed earlier, with a permanent settlement there since 1817; it began as a fur trading post.

about 0:05:22

Town note

Fort Pierre Chouteau was named after Pierre Chouteau, an American fur trader from St Louis of colonial French origin.

about 0:05:34

1880

The town itself was founded in 1880 on the east bank of the Missouri River, opposite Fort Pierre.

about 0:05:55

Town note

Pierre was selected as the state capital because it sits dead centre, the same distance for everybody.

about 0:06:04

Town note

It is one of four state capitals not served by the interstate highway system.

about 0:06:24

The figures, as told

Money

Median home value$265,400
Median household income$73,787
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2025

Population

"14,126"

Comparison: "smallest state capital by population". No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:04:44

Median household income

"$73,787"

Comparison: "just above the national average". Direction: above.

As told in 2025 about 0:04:52

Median home price

"$265,400"

Comparison: "lower than the national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2025 about 0:04:59

The reviews

3.0 / 5 · average of 4

5 stars

“Best place to grow up, with a small country-town feel and the needed commodities to be comfortable thanks to the local state government.”
about 0:07:03

3 stars

“Likes the smaller town because it is easier to get around, but there is not much to do; great if you are very interested in fishing and hunting.”
about 0:07:20

3 stars

“A very average community of hard-working people; asks for more patrols by animal control units.”
about 0:08:09

1 star

“If you don't like fishing, hunting, drinking or bowling, this town is not for you; everyone is in each other's business, it is very cliquey, shopping means driving two and a half hours, there is no culture and it goes straight from summer to winter.”
about 0:08:22

In South Dakota

Closest episodes

  1. The Scariest StaircaseHighmore, South Dakota · 12 June 202672 km / 45 miShow on map
  2. A Deviously Hypocritical KillerWolsey, South Dakota · 27 September 2017147 km / 91 miShow on map
  3. The Great Kidnapping CaperAberdeen, South Dakota · 10 November 2022190 km / 118 miShow on map
  4. Twin Marrying MadnessLemmon, South Dakota · 29 June 2024226 km / 140 miShow on map
  5. Plans Of TortureCanistota, South Dakota · 6 June 2018257 km / 160 miShow on map

The story

Tamara Donell Burns, known as Tammy, was born on June 15th, 1964 in Lander, Wyoming, the oldest of Donald and Bonnie's three daughters. She graduated from high school there in 1982 and worked in women's retail before settling in Billings, Montana. In August 2004 Brad transferred with Walmart to Pierre, South Dakota, where Tammy took a job in the shoe department at Kmart. The marriage was not close: they slept in separate bedrooms, and he worked long hours.

At Kmart Tammy met Brian Clark, the assistant manager, and around December 2005 they began an affair. In the first days of February 2006 she told Brad she wanted a divorce and to see other people. He sank into depression and asked her mother Bonnie to talk his wife round. Tammy refused, but agreed to wait until Haley's school year ended.

That evening she watched Haley play basketball at Georgia Morse Middle School; afterwards they got fast food and were home by 8.30, with Tammy in bed by nine. In the middle of the night Haley woke to find her father at her door with an armful of clothes. He said nothing, lay with her and told her he loved her. The next morning the washing machine was running. Haley found her mother's bed unmade and Tammy gone, with her phone, purse and Dodge Durango still there. Brad said she had a boyfriend and was probably at his house, then told Haley on the drive to school not to tell anybody.

When Bonnie heard nothing from her daughter she phoned Haley at school, then Brian at Kmart, who said Tammy had not shown up for her ten o'clock shift. Brian went to the police and told them everything, including the affair, and suggested the husband might have done something. His alibi was solid, so he was quickly ruled out. Police found no answer at the house and saw the Durango and a reddish-brown stain in the garage. At the Walmart security office Brad said that when he got home around one in the morning Tammy was not there, that a vehicle pulled into the driveway and drove off, and that he chased it without catching it. He signed a consent to search. Detectives found a blood droplet on the garage floor, a strong cleaning solution smell from the Durango, and fresh laundry in his bed and the washer and dryer.

Haley was taken into foster care overnight.

On February 10th a National Guard helicopter pilot spotted a body near the Oahe Dam emergency spillway on Lake Oahe. It was Tammy, nude, her throat slashed and her body bearing 37 stab wounds. A T-shirt riddled with knife holes and a pair of bloody gloves lay nearby. The autopsy found wounds to the chest, back, face and arms, damage to the heart, aorta and lungs, and post-mortem wounds; there were more wounds than were needed to kill her. She had been stabbed first in the back, then repeatedly in the chest, and attacked again after being placed on a tarp. The spot where she was found was one she had visited with Brian Clark to have sex.

Agents searched those spots with a bloodhound and a cadaver dog and found three City of Pierre garbage bags in juniper hedges near the power station. Inside were bloody sheets, blankets and women's underwear, a six-by-eight-foot blue tarp with a four-by-six-foot patch of blood and 16 stab holes, a box of condoms with one missing, and cleaning bottles.

Acting on it, the medical examiner found a condom inside Tammy.

Haley testified that she had never hurt her mother and, at five foot one and 94 pounds, lacked the strength. Brad then testified, against his lawyer's advice, that he had found Haley catatonic and bloodied, and had planted the condom to make it look like a sexual assault.

Haley grew up with her grandparents, is now in her thirties, married under a different name, speaks against domestic violence and has disowned her father. Tammy is buried at Mount Hope Cemetery in Lander, Wyoming. The Kmart in Pierre closed in April 2016.

The case

Murder of Tamara 'Tammy' Rie

Victims

Tamara Donell 'Tammy' Burns Rie (41). Born June 15, 1964 in Lander, Wyoming; worked in the shoe department at Kmart in Pierre; mother of Haley; was asking her husband for a divorce.

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 22 November 2025.

Accused

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Bonnie. Tammy's mother, who called daily and raised the alarm
Donald. Tammy's father, who drove nine hours to collect Haley
Rakel. Tammy's sister, who phoned Haley at school
Holly. Tammy's other sister

The timeline

  1. June 15th, 1964 Tamara Donell Burns is born in Lander, Wyoming (Lander)about 0:12:38
  2. 1982 Tammy graduates from Lander Valley High School (Lander Valley High School)about 0:13:14
  3. 1984 After two years at Central Wyoming College on a volleyball scholarship she moves to Casper to work at the Sweet Briar clothing store (Sweet Briar clothing store)about 0:13:41
  4. 1993 Daughter Haley is born in Billings, Montana (Billings)about 0:15:38
  5. August 2004 Brad transfers with Walmart for a promotion and the family moves to Pierre (Rie house)about 0:16:45
  6. December 2005 Tammy and Brian Clark, the Kmart assistant manager, begin an affair (Kmart)about 0:21:57
  7. early February 2006 Tammy tells Brad she wants a divorce and to see other people; he asks her mother Bonnie to help save the marriage (Rie house)about 0:23:15
  8. February 7th, 2006 Tammy and Brian meet at a motel for several hours in the afternoon; he drops her home around 5 p.m. (motel)about 0:29:46
  9. February 7th, 2006 Tammy watches Haley play basketball at Georgia Morse Middle School, they get fast food and go shopping, and are home by 8.30 p.m.; Tammy is in bed by 9 p.m. (Georgia Morse Middle School)about 0:30:17
  10. night of February 7th to 8th, 2006 Haley wakes to find Brad at her door with an armful of clothes; he says nothing, lies down with her and tells her he loves her. In the morning the washing machine is running. (Rie house)about 0:31:32
  11. February 8th, 2006 Haley finds the bed unmade, Tammy's phone, purse and Dodge Durango still there, and no sign of her mother; Brad says she has a boyfriend and is probably at his house, and tells Haley not to tell anyone (Rie house)about 0:32:18
  12. February 8th, 2006 Bonnie, not hearing from Tammy as usual, calls Haley at school and then Brian at Kmart; Brian reports Tammy missing (Kmart)about 0:35:36
  13. February 8th, 2006 Police find no answer at the house, see the Durango in the garage and a reddish-brown stain on the garage floor (Rie house)about 0:39:39
  14. February 8th, 2006 Detectives interview Brad at the Walmart security office; he claims Tammy was not home when he got in around 1 a.m., that he saw a vehicle pull into the driveway and drove after it, but could not catch it (Walmart)about 0:40:30
  15. February 8th, 2006 A search of the house finds a blood droplet on the garage floor, a strong cleaning solution smell from the Durango and fresh laundry on Brad's bed and in the washer and dryer (Rie house)about 0:42:08
  16. February 8th, 2006 Haley is taken into foster care overnightabout 0:46:09
  17. February 10th, 2006 A National Guard helicopter pilot spots a body near the Oahe Dam emergency spillway; it is Tammy, nude, with her throat slashed and 37 stab wounds (Oahe Dam emergency spillway)about 0:47:52

Last meals

  • Tamara 'Tammy' Rie. fast food picked up on the way home, after Haley's basketball game eaten the evening before she was killed, February 7th, 2006about 0:30:26

Places and phrases

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placePublic placePublic placePublic placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode