FILE 708 / 12 June 2026 / 74 MIN / express

The Scariest Staircase

Highmore, South DakotaListen

The town

N ↑Town centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

"This is Highmore, South Dakota", right in the middle of South Dakota, in Hyde County about 0:04:26

History, in brief

Town note

Named Highmore because it sits on the high plains at a high elevation.

about 0:06:39

1882

In 1882 developers A. E. Van Camp and E. O. Parker established competing business districts along parallel streets, Iowa Avenue and Commercial Avenue, creating a dual main street layout that still exists.

about 0:06:59

1883

Hyde County was formally organised in 1883, with disputes over the county seat that were smoothed out by 1884.

about 0:07:29
All 3 history facts

Town note

Named Highmore because it sits on the high plains at a high elevation.

about 0:06:39

1882

In 1882 developers A. E. Van Camp and E. O. Parker established competing business districts along parallel streets, Iowa Avenue and Commercial Avenue, creating a dual main street layout that still exists.

about 0:06:59

1883

Hyde County was formally organised in 1883, with disputes over the county seat that were smoothed out by 1884.

about 0:07:29

The figures, as told

Money

Median home value$111,300
Median household income$60,208
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2026

Median household income

"$60,208"

Comparison: "slightly below the national average of $69,000". Direction: below.

As told in 2026 about 0:05:52

Median home price

"$111,300"

Comparison: "less than one third of the national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2026 about 0:05:59

Land owned and leased by the Asoffs

"4,844 acres"

Comparison: "7.5 square miles". No direction stated.

As told in 2026 about 0:13:46

The reviews

5.0 / 5 · average of 1

5 stars

“The only review of the whole town says Highmore is the small town you hear about on every TV show and movie, where you know everyone's first name and are friends with most people; Highmore is home.”
about 0:09:29

In South Dakota

Closest episodes

  1. A Deadly Blame GamePierre, South Dakota · 22 November 202572 km / 45 miShow on map
  2. A Deviously Hypocritical KillerWolsey, South Dakota · 27 September 201778 km / 48 miShow on map
  3. The Great Kidnapping CaperAberdeen, South Dakota · 10 November 2022130 km / 81 miShow on map
  4. Plans Of TortureCanistota, South Dakota · 6 June 2018200 km / 124 miShow on map
  5. Chief Horny The LadykillerTea, South Dakota · 24 June 2021240 km / 149 miShow on map

The story

Tanya Jean Bushler was born on 8 October 1949.

By 1993 she feared him. She told the same to her sister Robin, a priest, Father Anderson, friends Jan and Carol, her cousin Vicky, a car salesperson, Jeanine Rathart, and a Sioux Falls divorce lawyer, Lee Bird.

In 1994 Lee Bird prepared a divorce on the grounds of extreme cruelty, but Tanya withdrew it before it was filed, for the sake of the children, then aged nine to 17. Counselling did not help. Their daughter Jessie said that in the summer of 1999 he was drunk and threatened to throw Tanya through a wall.

In October 1999 Tanya emailed a daughter that she was looking for a place in Faulkton and would file for divorce. On 7 November, while he slept, she moved out with her youngest daughter. On 16 November she called Lee Bird to reinstate the divorce.

Afterwards he drove her to the bank and they met an attorney in Highmore about the divorce. Sheriff Mike Vollick saw them returning at 11.10. Between 11.43 and 11.55 they called their daughter Rebecca in Italy for twelve minutes. Tanya's 1 p.m. appointment with Father Randy Phillips in Faulkton never happened.

At 3.01 he told the former sheriff, Martin Wortman, that Tanya had fallen down the stairs and died; at 3.16 he rang the current sheriff. He later admitted wiping blood off the left stair railing.

Tanya lay at the bottom of the carpeted basement stairs, with no blood on the stairs. The garage floor had scuff marks, blood spatter matching her DNA on the inside of the door, a clump of her hair under a car, and appeared recently cleaned. The autopsy found a blackened eye, a split lip, fractures to both sides of the skull, petechial haemorrhages, bruising to the neck and voice box, four or five fractured ribs and a defensive bruise on the hand. The cause was manual strangulation and blunt head trauma. He said she had dizzy spells, then that he was pretty sure he had not knocked her down, then that there had been pushing and shoving in the garage.

He had two life insurance policies on Tanya worth $1.7 million with accidental death benefits, and on 12 November 1999 he told his agent, "I'm going to kill the bitch, you know I can do it." A neighbour, Carol, had heard him talk of killing his wife and hiring a hitman.

The prosecution expert Dr Sammy Shibani claimed physics made the fall impossible, though he was later exposed as a fraud.

The case

Murder of Tanya Asoff

Victims

Tanya Jean Asoff. Nurse and mother of five, married to Asoff

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 12 June 2026.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Lee Bird. her divorce lawyer in Sioux Falls
Mike Vollick. Hyde County sheriff who responded to the farm
Martin Wortman. former Hyde County sheriff called first
Dan Jahala. DCI agent she spoke to in 1993
Father Randy Phillips. priest she was due to meet on the day she died
Father Anderson. priest she told of her fears
Rebecca. oldest daughter, a foreign exchange student in Italy
Jessie. youngest daughter, 16 at the time
Robin. her sister
Vicky. her cousin
Carol. neighbour who heard talk of killing his wife
Dr Sammy Shibani. prosecution expert later exposed as a fraud

The timeline

  1. October 8, 1949 Tanya Jean Bushler is bornabout 0:11:59
  2. October 1975 Tanya marries about 0:12:26
  3. 1993 Tanya asks the DCI to record her fear that will kill her if she divorces himabout 0:14:42
  4. 1994 Tanya consults divorce lawyer Lee Bird, alleging extreme cruelty (Lee Bird's law office)about 0:20:28
  5. 1994 Tanya withdraws the divorce and returns to the farm (Asoff farm)about 0:20:56
  6. the summer of 1999 , drunk, threatens to throw Tanya through a wall during an argument (Asoff farm)about 0:53:25
  7. October 1999 Tanya emails a daughter that she is looking for a place in Faulkton and will file for divorceabout 0:24:29
  8. November 1999 Tanya buys a car at Har Motors in Aberdeen (Har Motors)about 0:24:56
  9. November 7, 1999 Tanya moves out with her youngest daughter while sleeps (Apartment)about 0:25:46
  10. November 12, 1999 tells his insurance agent he is going to kill his wifeabout 0:58:00
  11. November 16, 1999 Tanya calls Lee Bird to reinstate the divorce (Lee Bird's law office)about 0:31:09
  12. November 18, 1999, 9.30 a.m. Tanya drives to the farm for a joint meeting with a court services officer (Asoff farm)about 0:32:14
  13. November 18, 1999, late morning After the meeting drives Tanya to the bank and they meet an attorney in Highmore (Bank in Highmore)about 0:33:17
  14. November 18, 1999, 11.10 a.m. Sheriff Mike Vollick sees and Tanya driving back to the farmabout 0:34:04
  15. November 18, 1999, 11.43 a.m. and Tanya call their daughter Rebecca in Italy for twelve minutes (Asoff farm)about 0:34:21
  16. November 18, 1999 Tanya is killed by strangulation and blunt head trauma (Asoff farm)about 0:55:49

Places and phrases

N ↑Town centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode