FILE 350 / 31 December 2022 / 69 MIN / express

The CSI Effect

Collinsville, VirginiaListen

The town

N ↑Public placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

We're going to Collinsville, Virginia, which is a small town just outside of Martinsville, Virginia. about 0:03:28

History, in brief

Town note

Founded by American Revolutionary War general Joseph Martin, who was born near here and developed a plantation on Scuffle Hill on the banks of the Smith River.

about 0:04:25

Town note

Patrick Henry lived here briefly and a county was named after him.

about 0:04:40

Town note

In the 20th century DuPont built a large plant producing textile nylon filament, which was important for the Second World War.

about 0:05:04

Town note

During the Cold War the Soviet Union identified the area as a strategic bombing target because of the nylon filament production.

about 0:05:16
All 9 history facts

Town note

Founded by American Revolutionary War general Joseph Martin, who was born near here and developed a plantation on Scuffle Hill on the banks of the Smith River.

about 0:04:25

Town note

Patrick Henry lived here briefly and a county was named after him.

about 0:04:40

Town note

In the 20th century DuPont built a large plant producing textile nylon filament, which was important for the Second World War.

about 0:05:04

Town note

During the Cold War the Soviet Union identified the area as a strategic bombing target because of the nylon filament production.

about 0:05:16

Town note

Nylon production jump-started the growth of the local textile industry.

about 0:05:50

1954

Martinsville Speedway opened in 1954 and was on the roster for the first NASCAR season in 1949.

about 0:05:57

Town note

For years Martinsville was known as the sweatshirt capital of the world.

about 0:06:13

Town note

In the 1980s Martinsville boasted more millionaires per capita than any other city in America.

about 0:06:29

Town note

In the 1990s textiles and furniture manufacturing became economically obsolete, the shops closed and thousands of workers were laid off; the city has tried to reposition itself as a centre for technology.

about 0:07:01

The figures, as told

Money

Median home value$106,200
Median household income$36,210
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2022

Population

"6,878"

No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:03:58

Median household income

"$36,210"

Comparison: "about $20,000 lower than the national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2022 about 0:04:09

Median home price

"$106,200"

No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:04:12

Millionaires per capita

"more millionaires per capita than any other city in America"

Comparison: "in the 1980s". No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:06:29

The reviews

3.0 / 5 · average of 3

4 stars

“A quiet city, good to live and study, with friendly and lovely people; the only problem is that you need a car, and on vacation there is not much to do so you have to go to another city.”
about 0:07:30

3 stars

“A small town where you meet lots of amazing people and friends; the middle schools are not that great and have serious insect problems, but the high schools are great with teachers who try hard to meet your needs.”
about 0:08:38

2 stars

“Lacking things to do, just some fast food places and a bowling place to go sometimes; a town in the middle of nowhere.”
about 0:09:44

In Virginia

Closest episodes

  1. A Web Of Deceit, Sex & MurderKeeling, Virginia · 17 September 202656 km / 35 miShow on map
  2. Cousins, Lovers & KillersSummerfield, North Carolina · 27 July 202358 km / 36 miShow on map
  3. We Will Dig Up That Basement!Vinton, Virginia · 24 September 202062 km / 39 miShow on map
  4. Mayberry: Chopped & PosedMount Airy, North Carolina · 13 January 202267 km / 42 miShow on map
  5. Handsome, Charming & DeadlyRadford, Virginia · 25 April 202473 km / 45 miShow on map

The story

In January 2006 the body of a 55-year-old woman named Nancy Motes Wingfield was found in pieces in and around her home in Collinsville, Virginia, a small town just outside Martinsville. The story of how she got there began nearly a decade earlier. Before 1997 Nancy was described as a good-natured, gregarious woman who ran a beauty shop out of her house. Nancy withdrew after that, stopped running the shop, and spent the following years on painkillers and sleeping pills. Her daughters, Tina and Jeanine, believed she was suffering from severe depression.

Neighbours, including Martha Lee, soon began gossiping. Tina last saw her mother on December 29th, 2005, and Nancy's boyfriend spoke to her by telephone on January 1st. When Tina came to the house on January 12th and found her mother's car still in the driveway, she reported her missing. Deputies searched the house and found nothing out of order except Nancy's dentures, her regular glasses and her pills left behind, and a single speck of blood behind the toilet handle.

He said he was angry that Nancy had been rude to their niece and had threatened their mother, and that she had wanted to die, so he had done her a favour. He described strangling her with a nylon cord while she napped on her bed on January 2nd, then carrying her to the bathtub and cutting her into small pieces with a hacksaw and a knife. He said the dismemberment took twelve hours. Over the next six days he packed the pieces into waterbed baffles and layers of plastic, buried them in five holes, scrubbed the bathroom with bleach and the acid used to remove mortar from bricks, and burned the tools and the rubbish bin behind the house.

The search had already used a bloodhound team from North Carolina and divers who went to 80 feet in an abandoned rock quarry near the house without finding anything.

He was taken to Memorial Hospital of Martinsville, intubated and put on a ventilator for several days, and was thought likely to die. He was later brought by ambulance to show where he had buried the remains. On January 24th three plastic bags of remains were unearthed in a wooded area along Richardson Drive, and the final bag was found on January 25th in another wooded area nearby. In all she had been cut into 19 pieces, buried at least three feet deep in each place, with the hole at her own house five feet deep and four feet wide.

A special prosecutor was appointed because the local prosecutor had worked with his public defender, and a psychological assessment found him sane. Nancy's daughters wept. The prosecutor called the killing cold and calculating and the product of a family feud.

The reason recorded was that he had no interest in it.

The case

Murder of Nancy Motes Wingfield

Victims

Nancy Motes Wingfield (55). Ran a beauty shop out of her home; withdrawn and depressed after her son was murdered in 1997

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 31 December 2022.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Tina. Nancy's daughter, who reported her missing
Jeanine. Nancy's daughter
Martha Lee. neighbour who described digging at night and keeping fires

The timeline

  1. 1997 Nancy's son David Dwayne Lawson is shot and killed in a trailer (Trailer in Collinsville)about 0:15:04
  2. early 2005 Nancy moves back to Collinsville, Virginiaabout 0:19:02
  3. the autumn of 2005 Motes joins his sister and moves into her house (Wingfield house)about 0:19:02
  4. the autumn of 2005 into January 2006 For about three months neighbours see digging in the yard in the middle of the night and keeping a fire going outside (Wingfield house)about 0:22:09
  5. December 29th, 2005 Tina last sees her motherabout 0:24:50
  6. January 1st, 2006 Nancy's boyfriend speaks to her on the phone, the last contact anyone has with herabout 0:24:50
  7. January 2nd, 2006 Motes strangles Nancy with a nylon cord while she naps on her bed (Wingfield house)about 0:37:00
  8. the next 12 hours He dismembers her in the bathtub with a hacksaw and a knife, cutting her into 19 pieces (Wingfield house)about 0:54:29
  9. over the next six days He packs the pieces into waterbed baffles and plastic bags and buries them in five holes, cleaning the bathroom with bleach and brick acid and burning the tools behind the house (Wingfield house)about 0:38:24
  10. January 12th, 2006 Tina comes to the house, is kept out of the guest bathroom, and reports her mother missing; deputies search and find her dentures, glasses and pills (Wingfield house)about 0:24:37
  11. January 24th, 2006 Three plastic bags filled with human remains are unearthed in a wooded area along Richardson Drive (Wooded area along Richardson Drive)about 0:49:59

Murder of David Dwayne Lawson

Victims

David Dwayne Lawson. Nancy Wingfield's son, shot in a trailer during a domestic dispute

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 31 December 2022.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

The timeline

  1. 1997 opens fire in a trailer, killing David Dwayne Lawson and wounding his own wife (Trailer in Collinsville)about 0:15:04

Places and phrases

N ↑Public placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode