FILE 416 / 19 August 2023 / 69 MIN / express

The Incredible Disappearing Head

North Canton, OhioListen

The town

N ↑Public placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

this week we're going to North Canton, Ohio... so this is in Stark County about 0:04:21

History, in brief

1831

North Canton began in 1831 as New Berlin, so named because most of its residents were German.

about 0:05:29

1873

H. 'Boss' Hoover moved his family and tannery business from the family farm to the town in 1873; he owned the W. H. Hoover Company, the future Hoover vacuums.

about 0:06:06
All 7 history facts

1831

North Canton began in 1831 as New Berlin, so named because most of its residents were German.

about 0:05:29

1873

H. 'Boss' Hoover moved his family and tannery business from the family farm to the town in 1873; he owned the W. H. Hoover Company, the future Hoover vacuums.

about 0:06:06

Town note

During the First World War the town changed its name from New Berlin to North Canton because it was no longer acceptable to be associated with Germany.

about 0:06:57

1903

By 1903 or 1933 the Hoover Company was the world's largest manufacturer of vacuum cleaners.

about 0:07:08

2007

By 2007 the Hoover Company was officially out of business.

about 0:07:16

The figures, as told

Money

Median home value$231,700
Median household income$62,303
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2023

Population

"17,884"

No direction stated.

As told in 2023 about 0:04:29

Median household income

"$62,303"

Comparison: "higher than the national average". Direction: above.

As told in 2023 about 0:04:51

Median home cost

"$231,700"

Comparison: "way lower than the national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2023 about 0:05:01

The reviews

3.6 / 5 · average of 5

5 stars

“A nice small city with a mall, plenty of restaurants, well-maintained roads and little crime.”
about 0:07:26

4 stars

“A great town if you want to feel like you know everyone but know nobody; written by a 19-year-old college student about to leave for college in West Virginia.”
about 0:07:37

3 stars

“If I had it to do all over again I would have moved away the first chance I had and joined the military; the area is either poor or rich and feels like a dead end.”
about 0:08:15

3 stars

“Local representatives will say anything to the people, then turn around and tell a higher authority the complete opposite.”
about 0:08:54

3 stars

“The people where I live can be very deceiving; one has to look deep through the weeds to find the true people.”
about 0:09:15

In Ohio

Closest episodes

  1. Disturbing, Depraved & DisgustingCoventry Township, Ohio · 13 May 202119 km / 12 miShow on map
  2. Wife Swap SnapBeach City, Ohio · 25 January 202429 km / 18 miShow on map
  3. The Bragging BruteCuyahoga Falls, Ohio · 9 October 202637 km / 23 miShow on map
  4. Best Friends MurderHudson, Ohio · 24 April 202541 km / 25 miShow on map
  5. Video Games Or Hitler?Montville Township, Ohio · 14 April 202244 km / 27 miShow on map

The story

North Canton, Ohio, is a small city of 17,884 people in Stark County, about 25 minutes from Akron and north of Canton. Brett W. 'Bubba' Smith was born there on June 10th, 1974, the son of Judy and Ronald Smith. Epileptic and bipolar, with a speech impediment that made some neighbours think him slow, he was remembered as a gentle, friendly man who played percussion in the school band, graduated from Lake High School in 1993, loved music, fishing and computers, and took his four-year-old niece to McDonald's every week. In 2008 he moved into lot 81 on Balsam at the Evergreen Mobile Home Park, in a trailer he was constantly remodelling.

He played football at Canton's McKinley High School and graduated in 1986. On February 13th, 1987, he married Laura Seacome in Niagara Falls; they divorced two years later. On June 19th, 1993, he married Leslie Phillips, with whom he had two children, and the family moved to Georgia before the marriage ended in 1999. In 2008 he moved into lot 94 on Cedar at the Evergreen park, next door to Brett Smith.

On September 6th he was fired from Dimensions 3 hair salon.

On October 3rd, 2008, Brett's disability payment arrived. He withdrew $1,182 in cash, bought several packs of Marlboro Lights, had lunch with his mother at the Mall Food Court in Jackson Township, shopped at Walmart and arranged to come to her house for dinner. The Hansons later saw him in Brett's doorway in a heated argument.

Brett never arrived for dinner. On the morning of October 4th his mother found his car outside the trailer and smelled a smoky odour, but got no answer; when she returned at 6.30 p.m. the police declined to force entry. Neighbour Chris Connley crowbarred the door open. Inside they found the oven on, blue and white paint splashed through the kitchen and hallway, and Brett's headless body in the bathroom with a knife in its chest. His head was in the oven, wrapped in burnt newspaper and cloth and roasting. His fingers and thumbs had been cut off and scattered, his body wrapped in plastic and painted, his wallet emptied, and a broken silver bracelet lay on the floor. The autopsy found rib fractures, a fractured hyoid bone and blunt force trauma: he had been beaten and strangled.

On October 4th he had cashed a $100 bill at Vulcart's party store and bought Bud Ice, rolling papers and a snack cake, and he had cut Whitney Gould's hair at the European Spa with a cigarette behind his ear, leaving without his pay cheque. In August 2009 Chad Long, removing carpet at Susan Lockard's house, found two black trash bags in a duct: clothing, boots, a nine-millimetre handgun, paint, bleach, Brett's blood and the matching sock.

His lawyers offered his Marine service, PTSD, bipolar diagnosis and addictions in mitigation. He turned to Judy Smith and apologised; she said she had never before been in touch with evil. Brett's sister Alicia did not believe the apology was sincere, while his mother said justice had been done.

The case

Murder of Brett 'Bubba' Smith

Victims

Brett W. 'Bubba' Smith (30). Born June 10th, 1974; lived alone in a trailer, was epileptic and bipolar, and was remembered as a gentle, friendly man who doted on his young niece.

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 19 August 2023.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Judy Smith. Brett's mother, who found the body
Alicia. Brett's sister
Chris Connley. neighbour who crowbarred the trailer door open
Mary Louise Erb. neighbour
Les Erb. neighbour
Barb Hanson. neighbour
James Hanson. neighbour
Dan McFarland. Office Depot worker threatened by in September 2008
Brian Fatterson. McFarland's co-worker
Susan Lockard. girlfriend
Sarah. Susan Lockard's daughter
Chad Long. Sarah's boyfriend, who found the hidden bags
Dustin Lockard. Susan Lockard's son, given the cigarettes
Adam Vulcart. owner of Vulcart's party store
Heather Newman. co-worker at the European Spa who identified the bracelet
Lisa Powell. co-worker at the European Spa
Whitney Gould. employee whose hair cut on October 4th, 2008
Laura Seacome. first wife
Leslie Phillips. second wife
Mark Phillips. schoolmate of Brett Smith

The timeline

  1. 1967 is born.about 0:24:16
  2. June 10th, 1974 Brett W. 'Bubba' Smith is born.about 0:12:42
  3. 1986 graduates from high school, having played football at Canton's McKinley. (Canton McKinley High School)about 0:24:52
  4. February 13th, 1987 marries Laura Seacome in Niagara Falls.about 0:24:56
  5. two years later and Laura divorce; he keeps a 1984 Chevy Chevette and two Rottweilers.about 0:25:04
  6. 1993 Brett Smith graduates from Lake High School. (Lake High School)about 0:14:03
  7. June 19th, 1993 marries Leslie Phillips, using the first name 'Jez' on the legal documents.about 0:29:17
  8. 1994 Brett's father Ronald dies.about 0:15:20
  9. November 2004 throws an accessory stand at staff in the Belden Village Sprint store, hitting a man in the eye, then punches a man at the Holiday Inn bar; he serves 30 days. (Sprint store)about 0:33:26
  10. 2008 Brett Smith moves into lot 81 on Balsam at Evergreen Mobile Home Park; moves into lot 94 on Cedar next door. (Brett Smith's trailer)about 0:19:14
  11. September 6th, 2008 is fired from his part-time job at Dimensions 3 hair salon. (Dimensions 3 hair salon)about 0:36:38
  12. October 3rd, 2008 Brett's SSI cheque is deposited; he withdraws $1,182 in cash, buys several packs of Marlboro Lights, has lunch with his mother at the Mall Food Court and shops at Walmart. (Mall food court)about 0:40:27
  13. October 3rd, 2008, 2.30 p.m. Brett and his mother leave Walmart in separate cars; he says he will come to her house for dinner. (Walmart)about 0:41:13
  14. October 3rd, 2008, 4.15 p.m. Brett calls his mother to ask what time she will be home.about 0:41:28
  15. October 3rd, 2008, about 5.15 p.m. asks the Hansons if he can take a kitchen sink from their yard; when refused he screams at them, wearing a silver bracelet. (Evergreen Mobile Home Park)about 0:41:53
  16. October 3rd, 2008, afternoon The Hansons see in the doorway of Brett's trailer having a heated argument with him. (Brett Smith's trailer)about 0:42:27
  17. October 3rd, 2008, evening approaches Sarah and Chad's car at his trailer, angry and holding a firearm, while Susan collects laundry. ( 's trailer)about 0:51:01
  18. October 3rd, 2008, 10 to 10.30 p.m. breaks up with Susan Lockard and drops her at home.about 0:51:27
  19. October 3rd, 2008, 10.30 p.m. gives Dustin Lockard a pack of Marlboro Lights, saying 'keep 'em because nothing matters any more anyway'. (Susan Lockard's house)about 0:51:47
  20. October 4th, 2008, 7 a.m. cashes a $100 bill at Vulcart's party store and buys three six-packs of Bud Ice, rolling papers and a snack cake. (Vulcart's party store)about 0:52:44
  21. October 4th, 2008, morning goes to the European Spa to cut Whitney Gould's hair, a cigarette behind his ear, and leaves without collecting his pay cheque. (European Spa)about 0:53:36
  22. October 4th, 2008, morning Judy Smith finds Brett's car outside his trailer, smells a smoky odour and gets no answer; she returns at 6.30 p.m. (Brett Smith's trailer)about 0:43:45
  23. October 4th, 2008, 6.30 p.m. Police attend Judy Smith's welfare check but refuse to enter the trailer. (Brett Smith's trailer)about 0:44:23
  24. October 4th, 2008 Chris Connley forces the door with a crowbar; he and Judy find the oven on, paint everywhere and Brett's headless body in the bathroom, with his head in the oven. (Brett Smith's trailer)about 0:45:44

Places and phrases

N ↑Public placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode