FILE 591 / 24 April 2025 / 179 MIN / full

Best Friends Murder

Hudson, OhioListen

The town

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placePublic placePublic placePublic placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

We are going to Ohio this week; northeastern Ohio, about 20 minutes outside Akron; this is in Summit County, area code 330 and 234. about 0:05:24

History, in brief

1799

Hudson is named for its founder David Hudson, who came from Goshen, Connecticut in 1799.

about 0:06:09

1837

The village of Hudson was incorporated in 1837 and David Hudson built the first log house in Summit County.

about 0:06:23

1826

It was home to the Western Reserve College and Preparatory School, founded in 1826 by David Hudson and others, and called the Yale of the West.

about 0:06:49

1882

The college moved to Cleveland in 1882 and later, as Western Reserve University, merged with the Case Institute of Technology to form Case Western Reserve University.

about 0:07:11
All 7 history facts

1799

Hudson is named for its founder David Hudson, who came from Goshen, Connecticut in 1799.

about 0:06:09

1837

The village of Hudson was incorporated in 1837 and David Hudson built the first log house in Summit County.

about 0:06:23

1826

It was home to the Western Reserve College and Preparatory School, founded in 1826 by David Hudson and others, and called the Yale of the West.

about 0:06:49

1882

The college moved to Cleveland in 1882 and later, as Western Reserve University, merged with the Case Institute of Technology to form Case Western Reserve University.

about 0:07:11

1892

A fire on the west side of Main Street in 1892 destroyed the buildings between Park Lane and Clinton Street, including Lockhart's Saloon and the Mansion hotel.

about 0:07:28

1903

A Pennsylvania coal mine owner named James Ellsworth helped rebuild Main Street after another fire in 1903 and refinanced the Western Reserve Academy.

about 0:07:55

1903

The Western Reserve Academy was closed from 1903 to 1916 because there was no money to operate it.

about 0:08:11

The figures, as told

Religious

about 47%

about 0:11:57

Who lives here

White 90% · Black 1.8% · Asian 3.8% · Hispanic 2.9%

Ethnicity can overlap race.

Crime / national average

Property crime
▼ about one quarter

about 0:20:00

Violent crime
▼ about one third

about 0:20:14

Money

Median home value$431,500
Two-bedroom rent$1,400 a month
Median household income$143,143
Cost of living80

For sale

$705,000

Four-bedroom Victorian farmhouse listing

about 0:14:09

For sale

$2,650,000

Five-bedroom, six-bath house listing

about 0:15:24
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2025

Population

"23,000 and one"

No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:10:51

Women

"about 51%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:10:57

Median age

"about 43 and a half"

Comparison: "about five years above the national average". Direction: above.

As told in 2025 about 0:11:01

Married

"71%"

Comparison: "normally 50-50". No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:11:26

Divorce rate

"6%"

Comparison: "extremely low". Direction: below.

As told in 2025 about 0:11:43

Married with children

"43%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:11:43

Single with children

"5.9%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:11:43

Religious

"about 47%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:11:57

Median household income

"$143,143"

Comparison: "more than double the national average". Direction: above.

As told in 2025 about 0:12:28

Cost of living index

"80"

Comparison: "100 is regular". Direction: below.

As told in 2025 about 0:12:46

Median home cost

"$431,500"

No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:12:51

Average two-bedroom rent

"$1,400 a month"

Comparison: "not that far above the national average". Direction: above.

As told in 2025 about 0:13:21

Four-bedroom Victorian farmhouse listing

"$705,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:14:09

Five-bedroom house listing

"$1,599,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:14:29

Five-bedroom, six-bath house listing

"$2,650,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:15:24

Property crime

"about one quarter"

Comparison: "national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2025 about 0:20:00

Violent crime

"about one third"

Comparison: "national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2025 about 0:20:14

The reviews

3.8 / 5 · average of 4

5 stars

“A tight-knit, safe community with little to no crime, great schools, a big library and a cute new shopping district; family friendly, though the reviewer would like more involvement with the high school youth.”
about 0:08:38

5 stars

“A family that moved from the Chicago area three years ago finds Hudson quaint, clean and quiet, with a relaxed and friendly culture, and recommends it.”
about 0:10:03

3 stars

“There is not a lot of crime in the area at all; crime is not a problem.”
about 0:10:25

2 stars

“The area is known for its downtown but there is barely anything to do there apart from summer weekend events, restaurants and overpriced shopping.”
about 0:10:33

In Ohio

Closest episodes

  1. The Bragging BruteCuyahoga Falls, Ohio · 9 October 202611 km / 7 miShow on map
  2. Disturbing, Depraved & DisgustingCoventry Township, Ohio · 13 May 202127 km / 17 miShow on map
  3. Video Games Or Hitler?Montville Township, Ohio · 14 April 202237 km / 23 miShow on map
  4. The Incredible Disappearing HeadNorth Canton, Ohio · 19 August 202341 km / 25 miShow on map
  5. Just My ImaginationHowland Township, Ohio · 14 May 202658 km / 36 miShow on map

The story

By the 1980s she was living in Greenville, Pennsylvania, and working as the personal secretary and de facto manager for a wealthy orthopaedic surgeon, Dr John F. Steele. She lived rent free in a large house he owned, drove company cars including two Cadillacs and a Corvette, and earned $75,000 a year. She kept two Rottweilers, seven horses and two snakes, one a Burmese python said to be 38 feet long.

His father owned a furniture store and was a Jefferson County commissioner, and the family was prominent locally. Ed was polite and formal as a child, the only first grader with an attaché case, and grew into a confident, manipulative young man, a weightlifter and kickboxer who carried a gun.

Roger Pratt, known as Butch, grew up in Munhall, Pennsylvania, the youngest of three children of a divorced couple. At five he had a bone disease in his right leg and wore a brace for more than two years, yet he became Steel Valley High School's best male athlete of 1984, an all-conference guard in football and a strong wrestler. He was the first in his family to go to college. His father talked him out of the Marines, and the family found about $3,000 a year to send him to Thiel College in Greenville.

They became fraternity brothers at Delta Sigma Phi, lived across the hall from one another, played football and were best friends. Ed was the leader and Butch the impressionable follower. In March 1987 about $3,500 of televisions, stereos and other equipment was stolen from the Delta Sigma Phi house and the Phi Theta Phi house next door. Ed paid two fraternity brothers $500 each to keep quiet, and Butch borrowed $500 from his family to cover his share.

He was 21 and she was 35. She bought him a Jeep, co-signed the loan and made him assistant manager at Old Town Furniture, where Butch also worked. By 1988 Ed was living in her house, and she had fitted out a room as a law office for him.

On 15 May 1988 both men graduated from Thiel. Within a day Butch packed his belongings and left without explanation. A week later, on 22 May, the Old Town Furniture warehouse in Greenville burned down.

On 27 May 1988 Butch was taken to the police station in Munhall and questioned about the fire. He denied any part in the fire but said that anyone burning the store would be trying to destroy financial records.

The next day he took a 12.05 bus from the Greyhound station in downtown Pittsburgh to Akron, carrying a thank you note from his mother and two plastic containers of leftover fruit salad and stuffed cabbage. Butch got out to let her pass, the women shut the doors and drove away.

By noon the next day everyone was back home as if nothing had happened.

Rose Pratt reported her son missing on 21 June. For 15 months she wrote to blood banks, the IRS, social security and the Salvation Army, hired a private detective and put up posters.

The fire had been set in a second-floor bedroom to cover a burglary and caused more than $100,000 of damage. On 5 October she showed them the grave. Every bone in his face was fractured.

The prosecution said she had wanted to stop Butch testifying about the furniture-store arson and had sent a spy to his preliminary hearing. Her defence was that she was terrified of Ed, and she sobbed throughout her evidence.

He testified without emotion that Butch had attacked him and that he could not remember the fight, admitting only that he may have picked him up and hit his head on a rock.

A later Supreme Court decision forced a rehearing.

The case

Murder of Roger 'Butch' Pratt

Victims

Roger 'Butch' Pratt (22). Recent Thiel College graduate, first in his family to go to college, named Steel Valley High School's best male athlete of 1984

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 24 April 2025.

Accused

Accused

Accused

Accused

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Rose Pratt. Butch's mother, who reported him missing and investigated for 15 months
Dr John F. Steele. orthopaedic surgeon, employer and owner of Old Town Furniture
Jody Snodgrass. assistant
Liz Wertz. Butch's girlfriend and roommate
Robert Garshack. Pratt family attorney
Ed Wurr. Butch's friend who drove him to the Pittsburgh bus station
Rich Baker. Butch's friend who helped search for him
Christine Cassandra. girlfriend, picked up in Kent
Craig Closer. Jefferson County school superintendent and former mayor of Yorkville
Dorothy Fudrogovich. teacher who taught four of the family
Mark Stanton. later lawyer

The timeline

  1. December 1952 is born.about 0:20:55
  2. 1966 is born.about 0:28:35
  3. 1968 is born, two years after his brother.about 0:29:14
  4. age five Butch Pratt develops a bone disease in his right leg and wears a brace for over two years.about 0:36:18
  5. 1980 is hired by Dr John F. Steele as his personal secretary.about 0:21:06
  6. 1984 Butch Pratt is named Steel Valley High School's best male athlete of 1984. (Steel Valley High School)about 0:36:44
  7. fall 1985 Ed and Butch Pratt are sophomores, fraternity brothers and neighbours across the hall at the Delta Sigma Phi house. (Delta Sigma Phi house)about 0:43:18
  8. December 1986 Ed moves out of the fraternity house into an off-campus house and asks Butch to live with him. (Delta Sigma Phi house)about 0:47:22
  9. March 3, 1987 About $3,500 of electronics and appliances are stolen from the Delta Sigma Phi house and the Phi Theta Phi house next door. (Delta Sigma Phi house)about 0:49:04
  10. May 1987 meets Ed at the Pro Body Shop; she is 35 and he is 21. (Pro Body Shop)about 1:55:25

Last meals

  • Roger 'Butch' Pratt. Two plastic containers of leftover fruit salad and stuffed cabbage Packed by his mother for his bus trip to Akron, June 17, 1988about 1:12:22

Places and phrases

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placePublic placePublic placePublic placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode