FILE 742 / 9 October 2026 / 76 MIN / express

The Bragging Brute

Cuyahoga Falls, OhioListen

The town

N ↑Town centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

We are going to Cuyahoga Falls, Ohio; Summit County, area code 330 and 234. about 0:05:20

History, in brief

1812

Cuyahoga Falls was formed in 1812, among a group of towns that already existed.

about 0:06:53

Town note

It was originally called Manchester, but the post office said there were already several other Manchesters in Ohio, so it became Cuyahoga Falls.

about 0:07:00

Town note

The Cuyahoga River waterfalls provided power for manufacturing.

about 0:07:34

1812

In 1812 a couple of people built a dam on the Cuyahoga River where a railroad bridge crossed, then built a flour mill, an oil mill and a saw mill, which led to houses and started the town.

about 0:07:48
All 5 history facts

1812

Cuyahoga Falls was formed in 1812, among a group of towns that already existed.

about 0:06:53

Town note

It was originally called Manchester, but the post office said there were already several other Manchesters in Ohio, so it became Cuyahoga Falls.

about 0:07:00

Town note

The Cuyahoga River waterfalls provided power for manufacturing.

about 0:07:34

1812

In 1812 a couple of people built a dam on the Cuyahoga River where a railroad bridge crossed, then built a flour mill, an oil mill and a saw mill, which led to houses and started the town.

about 0:07:48

1940

On July 31st, 1940, the Doodlebug disaster, a train wreck, killed forty-three people.

about 0:08:06

The figures, as told

Money

Median home value$182,500
Median household income$62,294 a year
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2026

Population

"50,906"

Comparison: "a little higher than the towns usually covered". Direction: above.

As told in 2026 about 0:06:12

Median household income

"$62,294 a year"

Comparison: "a little below the national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2026 about 0:06:32

Median home cost

"$182,500"

Comparison: "less than half the national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2026 about 0:06:39

The reviews

3.3 / 5 · average of 4

5 stars

“Has a lot to offer and is a quiet neighbourhood, close to everything including Walmart, Lowe's, Target, Menards and grocery stores; a perfect area to live.”
about 0:08:47

3 stars

“Wants more cultured entertainment and nightlife rather than just bars; microbreweries help but finer restaurants would be nice as people seem to accept only franchise eateries.”
about 0:09:48

3 stars

“A few decent spots but mostly not a fan; a violent crime at a Taco Bell five minutes away killed two people and the reviewer does not want his son growing up there.”
about 0:10:23

2 stars

“Has all the things needed but is pretty boring all of the time.”
about 0:11:08

In Ohio

Closest episodes

  1. Best Friends MurderHudson, Ohio · 24 April 202511 km / 7 miShow on map
  2. Disturbing, Depraved & DisgustingCoventry Township, Ohio · 13 May 202120 km / 12 miShow on map
  3. Video Games Or Hitler?Montville Township, Ohio · 14 April 202225 km / 16 miShow on map
  4. The Incredible Disappearing HeadNorth Canton, Ohio · 19 August 202337 km / 23 miShow on map
  5. Wife Swap SnapBeach City, Ohio · 25 January 202459 km / 37 miShow on map

The story

In January 1994 Loretta May Foster was 67 and had lived in Cuyahoga Falls, Ohio, her whole life. Born Loretta May Halbert on 14 October 1926, one of nine children, she married Charles Leon Foster in 1944 and had one son, Michael. She weighed 313 pounds and was remembered as generous and nurturing.

By his late twenties he was an alcoholic who had been drinking heavily since about fourteen. His family sent him into the army; he served four years, reenlisted for two more and spent eighteen months in Korea, still drinking. He came home with a girlfriend and a son, but she refused to move to Ohio with him.

A month or so before the murder he painted Loretta's basement, claiming she had agreed to pay $300 and had paid only $100.

On 11 January her sister-in-law Norma took her to a doctor's appointment. He ran into two friends, Brian Baker and Jim Fernando, and told them he had killed someone and was leaving town. He said Loretta owed him $200, and described knocking on her door and claiming he had something from her sister, then attacking her with a tent pole and a rope, hitting her, going through her purse, ripping the telephone out of the wall, tying her up and trying to strangle her. He said he left her naked in the living room with $40 and a blank check. At the Rainbow Bar he added detail. When his friends said they did not believe him, he took them to the house, where they saw her body through the living-room window. Jason went inside with him at about 1.30 a.m. and saw her too.

The next morning Baker and Fernando told Officer Joe Orcine, whose son was a friend, and made statements at the police station. Police found Loretta in her living room, beaten about the head and strangled with a rope, tied up while still alive. Her bra was cut and her top pulled up, and her pants and pantyhose had been rolled down and pulled off. There was blood and a clump of hair by the rear door, broken glasses and an earring in the kitchen, and the other earring and her purse in the dining room. The autopsy found no sperm and no evidence of sexual conduct.

Police found a camouflage outfit, gloves, a tent pole, white rope, a knife and a blank check. The rope matched the one used to tie and strangle her, hair on it matched Loretta, and blood on the overalls was the same type as hers.

Jason, his father and his mother all testified for the defence.

The case

Murder of Loretta Foster

Victims

Loretta May Foster (67). Born Loretta May Halbert on October 14th, 1926; one of nine children; married Charles Leon Foster in 1944; widowed in 1975; the neighbourhood grandmother who babysat local children; weighed 313 pounds.

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 9 October 2026.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Brian Baker. friend told by at Northgate Lanes who reported it to police
Jim Fernando. friend told by at Northgate Lanes who reported it to police
Joseph Hindle. Jason friend, at Northgate Lanes that night
Joe Orcine. police officer, father of a friend, told by Baker and Fernando
Norma. Loretta's sister-in-law, who drove her to the doctor
Charles Leon Foster. Loretta's husband, married 1944, died 1975

The timeline

  1. October 14th, 1926 Loretta May Halbert is born in Cuyahoga Falls, one of the nine children of Frank and Mary. (Cuyahoga Falls)about 0:15:58
  2. 1944 Loretta marries Charles Leon Foster during the war. (Cuyahoga Falls)about 0:16:36
  3. 1966 is born. (Cuyahoga Falls)about 0:18:28
  4. 1975 Charles Leon Foster dies, leaving Loretta widowed. (Cuyahoga Falls)about 0:16:51

Last meals

Places and phrases

N ↑Town centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode