1882
A farming community here received a post office in 1882, with Thomas Shaw as postmaster, and the place was named Shaw after him.
about 0:05:53Spoilers are covered until your reading preferences load.
FILE 448 / 10 December 2023 / 72 MIN / express
We're going to Onaway, Michigan, in the far northern mainland panhandle, not in the UP, with Canada just across the water. about 0:04:20
A farming community here received a post office in 1882, with Thomas Shaw as postmaster, and the place was named Shaw after him.
about 0:05:53In 1886 Merit Chandler platted a community and called it Onaway, not Chandler.
about 0:06:15Chandler took over as postmaster in 1890 and changed the name to Onaway.
about 0:06:23Three years later Shaw became postmaster again and changed the name to Odalaska, Alaska with a d after the first a.
about 0:06:31A farming community here received a post office in 1882, with Thomas Shaw as postmaster, and the place was named Shaw after him.
about 0:05:53In 1886 Merit Chandler platted a community and called it Onaway, not Chandler.
about 0:06:15Chandler took over as postmaster in 1890 and changed the name to Onaway.
about 0:06:23Three years later Shaw became postmaster again and changed the name to Odalaska, Alaska with a d after the first a.
about 0:06:31Five years later a new postmaster changed the name back to Onaway.
about 0:06:46The town was incorporated in 1899.
about 0:07:06At the beginning of the 20th century it was home to one of the world's largest wooden automobile steering wheel manufacturers, producing 65% of the world's wooden steering wheels.
about 0:07:13"796"
No direction stated.
As told in 2023 about 0:05:09
"$28,162"
Comparison: "about $40,000 less than the national average". Direction: below.
As told in 2023 about 0:05:17
"$121,700"
No direction stated.
As told in 2023 about 0:05:27
4.0 / 5 · average of 2
“Someone who grew up there and came back after college loves its uniqueness, knowing almost everyone at the grocery store or gas station, and how people look out for each other.”about 0:07:48
“Everyone knows everyone and people are helpful, but there is no work and you have to travel 30-plus miles for a good job; good schools, sports, fishing, hunting, snowmobiling and cross-country skiing.”about 0:08:56
Heather Chantelle Young was born on 20 February 1974 in Cold Water, Michigan, and grew up around Marshall. She married Jeff Cunningham in 1997, when she was 23, and later married Tom Young; both marriages ended in divorce. By 2016 she was 42 and the mother of three: two daughters, aged 24 and 18, and an 11-year-old son. She liked swimming, thrillers and karaoke. Her boyfriend was Terry Gary, 58, a semi-retired mechanic from Traverse City who was 16 years her senior and lived near Onaway in the far north of Michigan. In July 2016 she drove up to stay with him for a few weeks, looking forward to meeting his adult daughter and her family.
She reached Terry's house in Onaway on 14 July 2016. After about two weeks the visit went wrong. Heather and Terry argued, and his daughter, who lived there with her husband and children, told them she would not have the fighting in her house. Terry took his daughter's side and told Heather to leave. Heather said she would go home to her mother and set off on the 300-mile drive south.
Instead of driving straight home she stopped at the Cabin Bar and Grill, a bar in a cabin in the woods where she and Terry had drunk before; there was karaoke that night.
He said he snapped. He walked to the front room, took a .22 rifle and shot her in the leg. He said there was no point of return. He put her body in the burn pit outside his door and let it burn for 18 hours, then pulled the charred body out, cut it up with a chainsaw and burned the parts again. The next day he went back to the bar, where two women teased him about picking up a younger woman; he told them nothing had happened and that she had left before he woke.
Heather's family reported her missing after a couple of days without word. He told them on the telephone that the night had been platonic and that Heather was gone when he woke. They also spoke to Terry Gary, who denied hitting her and had an alibi with his daughter.
The search found a firearm and a significant amount of Heather's blood inside the trailer. In the burn pit outside, police found buttons, pieces of jewellery and bones, and then the cross from a leather necklace she wore, matching one her ex-husband had. He said no woman would ever do that to him again, and that Heather, who had done nothing to him, had been made to pay for what his wife and girlfriends had done. He led police through tall grass to a field near an electrical tower deep in the woods, where her remains lay in about 10 or 12 pieces. She had been shot twice with a .22 rifle, burned, dismembered and burned again. She was identified by a tattoo and by DNA from her parents.
He said it happened in August 2016 at his brother's property on Rainy Lake Road in Millersburg.
July 2016 / her boyfriend's house in Onaway, then trailer near Onaway
As told in the episode, on 10 December 2023.
Accused
Public places are marked on the map.
home
about 0:17:54home
about 0:18:10business
about 0:21:16landmark
about 0:09:46other
about 0:25:38crime scene
about 0:40:05body found
about 0:49:09crime scene
about 0:57:18hospital
about 0:16:15