FILE 486 / 20 April 2024 / 71 MIN / express

Date Night Death

Long Branch, New JerseyListen

The town

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

We're going to Long Branch, New Jersey, in central New Jersey on the east coast; later the detectives take back to Monmouth County. about 0:03:18

History, in brief

Town note

It emerged as a beach resort town in the late 1700s.

about 0:05:08

Town note

Early presidents went there and it was the spot to go.

about 0:05:16

Town note

In the 19th century theatrical performers would go there because people gathered there.

about 0:05:22

Town note

In the 20th century it stopped being a theatre hotspot and became more of a family holiday spot.

about 0:05:35
All 8 history facts

Town note

It emerged as a beach resort town in the late 1700s.

about 0:05:08

Town note

Early presidents went there and it was the spot to go.

about 0:05:16

Town note

In the 19th century theatrical performers would go there because people gathered there.

about 0:05:22

Town note

In the 20th century it stopped being a theatre hotspot and became more of a family holiday spot.

about 0:05:35

Town note

The Garden State Parkway opened, people could get south more easily, and demand for Long Branch fell.

about 0:05:49

Town note

Its mottos are the first seaside resort and the friendly city.

about 0:04:26

Town note

The Crazy Horse, Adriana's nightclub in The Sopranos, was in Long Branch.

about 0:06:00

Town note

The house Tony hides out in towards the end of The Sopranos was in Long Branch too.

about 0:06:25

The figures, as told

Money

Median home value$641,700
Median household incomeabout $65,000
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2024

Population

"31,734"

No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:03:53

Median household income

"about $65,000"

Comparison: "close to the normal for the rest of the country". Direction: about the same.

As told in 2024 about 0:04:01

Median home price

"$641,700"

No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:04:01

The reviews

3.0 / 5 · average of 4

5 stars

“Long Branch has been booming since Hurricane Sandy and is a beachy touristy city, though summer traffic is heavy; Pier Village is family friendly, with the beach for the day and dinner before heading home, and parking for about ten dollars a day.”
about 0:06:37

3 stars

“Close to Red Bank and Asbury Park but complains of drugs, guns and a lot of Hispanic people; the beach is a wonderful summer spot but winter is dead, and the streets and ocean need cleaning.”
about 0:07:32

3 stars

“A silly little city with a nice beach and good schools, clean streets, parks great for young children and a local pool alongside the beaches.”
about 0:08:43

1 star

“The schools and the town suck, and the people and kids are not friendly at all.”
about 0:09:09

In New Jersey

Closest episodes

  1. A Nasty Pair Of MurdersOcean Grove, New Jersey · 21 June 20179 km / 6 miShow on map
  2. Murder AuditionNeptune City, New Jersey · 19 September 202411 km / 7 miShow on map
  3. Sex, Greed & Vice PrincipalsToms River Township, New Jersey · 2 November 202337 km / 23 miShow on map
  4. Suitcases Full Of MurderWoodbridge Township, New Jersey · 25 December 202538 km / 24 miShow on map
  5. That's Not Junk In That TrunkOcean Township, New Jersey · 28 November 201959 km / 37 miShow on map

The story

The marriage had been through rough patches and divorce had been discussed, but Ann did not want one, saying it would bring shame on her large Italian family.

She had been a star CYO basketball player at Shore Regional High School, spent her senior year at Red Bank Catholic school, and then attended the Grace Institute, a secretarial school in New York run by nuns, before working for a law firm, in reception, and finally at Bear Stearns. Friends called her a paradox: outgoing but slow to make friends, fierce on the court and easily hurt off it. She became pregnant twice in less than a year and had two abortions, and she later said she had breast surgery because she thought it would stop him looking at other women.

Between 16 February and 20 March 1982 the pair discussed ways of killing Ann, including shooting her, staging a bathtub accident, an overdose and a brake failure, before settling on a staged robbery and a stabbing. He coached her on using the knife and taped the handle with electrical tape so it would not slip. He also took Ann out often, he said, so that a date night would look normal.

She took Ann's purse and the gold crucifix from her neck to make it look like a robbery, ran off and drove to Atlantic City, where she threw the knife into the Atlantic and the purse into a river, checked in and gambled at the Playboy Club.

On 10 April 1982, less than three weeks after the murder, the pair began appearing together, starting with an arranged accidental meeting at the Museum of Natural History in New York.

She called a lawyer, and at 6.30 a.m. detectives told him they were taking her back to Monmouth County.

She testified for five hours, and the psychiatrist John P. Motley diagnosed borderline personality disorder.

The case

Murder of Ann Carras

Victims

Ann Carras (43). volunteer worker, wife of police officer Carras and mother of two

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 20 April 2024.

Accused

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Christina Carras. and Ann's daughter, 13 at the time of the murder and 15 when she testified
Patricia Geezey. sister, who wrote a poem about Ann's death to publicise the case
Tony Gayeta. Ann's brother, whom said would kill them both if he found out
Peter Johns. Long Branch police lieutenant who called about the case
John P. Motley. psychiatrist who diagnosed with borderline personality disorder

The timeline

  1. 1977 sophomore year at Shore Regional High School (Shore Regional High School)about 0:20:15
  2. the following year She spends her senior year living with an aunt who was a nun in Illinois and attends Red Bank Catholic school (Red Bank Catholic school)about 0:20:15
  3. after high school She attends the Grace Institute, a secretarial school in New York run by nuns, then works for a law firm and in reception before joining Bear Stearns (Grace Institute)about 0:22:43
  4. fall of 1981 meets Carras on the commuter train to New York and the affair beginsabout 0:23:34
  5. fall 1981 to 1982 becomes pregnant twice and has two abortionsabout 0:26:15
  6. November 1981 leaves Ann and moves in with about 1:03:10
  7. January 1982 moves back home; Ann calls and threatens to wipe the streets of Oceanport with her, calling her a tramp and a whore (Carras house)about 0:27:07
  8. February 16, 1982 The pair begin working out how to kill Ann, rejecting shooting, a bathtub accident, an overdose and brake failure in favour of a staged robbery and stabbingabout 0:52:03
  9. March 20, 1982 and Ann go out on a date, park near the movie theater and walk towards it; goes back to the car for the keys (movie theater parking lot)about 0:14:27
  10. March 20, 1982 , hiding behind a dumpster, stabs Ann 22 times outside the Italian restaurant and takes her purse and gold crucifix (Italian restaurant near the movie theater)about 0:47:56
  11. March 20, 1982 drives to Atlantic City, throws the knife into the Atlantic and the purse into a river, checks in and gambles at the Playboy Club (Playboy Club)about 0:54:03
  12. at the wake collapses and sobs; his police colleagues post rewards and set up a trust fund for the childrenabout 0:17:48
  13. within a week of the funeral is seen at Hoboken train station with 21-year-old (Hoboken train station)about 0:18:23
  14. five days after the murder calls Hoboken police to report a threatening phone call saying you're nextabout 0:27:58
  15. shortly after the funeral moves into the Carras house with the children (Carras house)about 0:28:15
  16. April 10, 1982 Less than three weeks after the murder the pair start spending time together, beginning with an arranged meeting at the Museum of Natural History (Museum of Natural History)about 0:55:09
  17. last weekend in May 1982 accompanies to a Lions Club convention in Atlantic City but stays away from the social eventsabout 0:55:32
  18. June 1982 begins living most of the week at the Carras house and holidays with in the Poconos while the children are at camp (Carras house)about 0:55:46
  19. Christmas 1982 moves out and the affair ends after finds another womanabout 0:28:38
  20. May 28, 1983 At 3 a.m. calls the police from her apartment, saying she cannot take the pressure any more and mentioning the murder of Ann Carras (East 95th Street apartment)about 0:32:08
  21. May 28, 1983 She calls a lawyer at 4 a.m.; at 6.30 a.m. detectives tell him they are taking her back to Monmouth County (East 95th Street apartment)about 0:32:31
  22. May 29, 1983 makes a recorded call to , who tells her to keep quiet, says they planned it and it was perfect, and calls her an idiotabout 0:33:18
  23. at trial testifies for five hours that planned the killing and she carried it out (Superior Court)about 0:50:24
  24. at trial Christina Carras testifies that rang her at 4 a.m. saying your father killed your mother, then apologised in a letter (Superior Court)about 0:57:50

Places and phrases

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Italian restaurant near the movie theater

crime scene

about 0:14:58

Heard in this episode