FILE 529 / 19 September 2024 / 167 MIN / full

Murder Audition

Neptune City, New JerseyListen

The town

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

We're going to a good place for it is Neptune City, New Jersey. about 0:04:33

History, in brief

1891

Steiner and Sons pyjama factory was the first factory built in Neptune City, in 1891.

about 0:06:30

Town note

Emmanuel Steiner was a silk dealer in Austria before he came to New York City in the late 1860s and began making pyjamas and nightgowns.

about 0:06:51

Town note

The company's flagship product was the Universal Nightshirt, which became enormously popular.

about 0:07:10
All 10 history facts

1891

Steiner and Sons pyjama factory was the first factory built in Neptune City, in 1891.

about 0:06:30

Town note

Emmanuel Steiner was a silk dealer in Austria before he came to New York City in the late 1860s and began making pyjamas and nightgowns.

about 0:06:51

Town note

The company's flagship product was the Universal Nightshirt, which became enormously popular.

about 0:07:10

Town note

Within a couple of years the company built another factory three blocks north.

about 0:07:18

Town note

The company's first advertising slogan was 'we put the world to sleep'.

about 0:07:25

1929

The first murder in Neptune City happened in 1929 during a payroll robbery of the pyjama company.

about 0:07:46

Town note

George Danielson, a 65-year-old courier from First National Bank, was shot point blank at the employee entrance on Fourth Avenue; the bandits got $7,280 in payroll, equivalent to $134,000 today, but were later caught, tried and convicted.

about 0:07:51

Town note

The town has one motel, the Charlene Motel.

about 0:08:26

The figures, as told

Crime / national average

Property crime
▲ about a third high

about 0:21:54

Violent crime
▼ about 20% below

about 0:22:04

Money

Median home value$355,900
Two-bedroom rent$1,640
Median household income$64,940 a year
Cost of living129

For sale

$110,000

One-bedroom, one-bath, 550 square foot trailer

about 0:13:59

For sale

$549,000

Three-bedroom, one-bath, 1,462 square foot house

about 0:14:24

For sale

$725,000

Three-bedroom, two-bath house of over 2,000 square feet

about 0:15:14
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2024

Population

"4,637"

No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:11:19

Median age

"about 39.9"

Comparison: "near the national average". No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:11:39

Share of residents aged 18 to 20

"almost 10%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:11:39

Married population

"33%"

Comparison: "usually 50-50 is the normal". No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:11:47

Unemployment rate

"6.8%"

Comparison: "well above the national average". Direction: above.

As told in 2024 about 0:11:57

Median household income

"$64,940 a year"

Comparison: "below the national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2024 about 0:12:12

Cost of living index

"129"

Comparison: "100 is regular". Direction: above.

As told in 2024 about 0:12:28

Housing index

"120"

Comparison: "above the average". Direction: above.

As told in 2024 about 0:12:33

Median home cost

"$355,900"

No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:12:37

Average two-bedroom rental

"$1,640"

Comparison: "above the national average". Direction: above.

As told in 2024 about 0:13:17

Annual property tax bill on a small home

"$10,000"

Comparison: "above what it costs in nearby towns". Direction: above.

As told in 2024 about 0:10:51

One-bedroom, one-bath, 550 square foot trailer

"$110,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:13:59

Three-bedroom, one-bath, 1,462 square foot house

"$549,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:14:24

Three-bedroom, two-bath house of over 2,000 square feet

"$725,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:15:14

Property crime

"about a third high"

Comparison: "national average". Direction: above.

As told in 2024 about 0:21:54

Violent crime

"about 20% below"

Comparison: "national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2024 about 0:22:04

The reviews

3.3 / 5 · average of 3

4 stars

“A quiet, calming and inviting neighbourhood with good schools; the high school has a swimming pool open to the community and there is an allied health school in town.”
about 0:08:56

3 stars

“A great community despite a few problems, with friendly people, sporting events, the beach and good nightlife.”
about 0:09:35

3 stars

“It would be an awesome place to live if it were close to affordable; small homes come with a $10,000 annual tax bill and property taxes are above nearby towns.”
about 0:10:26

In New Jersey

Closest episodes

  1. A Nasty Pair Of MurdersOcean Grove, New Jersey · 21 June 20173 km / 2 miShow on map
  2. Date Night DeathLong Branch, New Jersey · 20 April 202411 km / 7 miShow on map
  3. Sex, Greed & Vice PrincipalsToms River Township, New Jersey · 2 November 202326 km / 16 miShow on map
  4. Suitcases Full Of MurderWoodbridge Township, New Jersey · 25 December 202545 km / 28 miShow on map
  5. That's Not Junk In That TrunkOcean Township, New Jersey · 28 November 201948 km / 30 miShow on map

The story

At 2.46 a.m. on 3 December 2016, Neptune Township police officer Shane Leaming was sent to the Route 35 bridge in Belmar, New Jersey, after an Uber driver reported an abandoned car. The car was a 1994 Oldsmobile 88 registered to 96-year-old Lillian Stern, but its usual driver was her 19-year-old granddaughter, Sarah Stern, who lived in Neptune City. The keys were still inside. Officers searched the bank and the water below the bridge, and dive teams were called in, but they found no body and no personal effects. Sarah's mobile phone had last registered on a tower near her house at 7.49 p.m. the night before. At her home, which was cluttered with her late mother's belongings, there was no sign of her.

Sarah had graduated from Neptune High School in 2015. Her mother had died a few years earlier, leaving her father, Michael Stern, as her only surviving parent. Sarah had found a lock box containing between $20,000 and $100,000 in old, damaged cash, which she believed her mother had left for her, and she had also put money in a safe deposit box at a local bank. She had been packing her mother's things into bins and leaving them with friends and relatives.

The pair first discussed a burglary, then settled on murder. They bought walkie-talkies and carried out a dry run at the Route 35 bridge. Curry thought it was a plot for a horror movie.

He later said the killing took about half an hour and that he timed it on his phone; he put a shirt in her mouth and held her nose. He dragged her to a back bathroom and went to work. At the bridge he could not lift her over the rail; he fell and hurt his leg. Her body was never recovered.

The abandoned car was found hours later. He also said that she had lost several jobs. Police found her passport, Social Security card and American and Canadian currency in her bedroom, which suggested that she had not left the country.

In January 2017 Anthony Curry went to the police. Detectives wired Curry's car, and on 31 January 2017 the two met in Bradley Beach. He said that he had planned it for six months, that Sarah had said his name as she died and that he felt no different. He mentioned that about $9,300 had been taken, that the money was old and damaged, and that the safes had been buried. Curry's recording made the case.

The two safes were recovered on 6 February 2017, one from Sandy Hook and the original from Shark River Park. The money inside amounted to about $9,300; the safe deposit box held $25,250.

Because no body was found, the prosecution was only the second bodyless murder case in Monmouth County history.

A memorial was held on the Route 35 bridge on what would have been Sarah's 22nd birthday.

The case

Murder of Sarah Stern

Victims

Sarah Stern (19). Aspiring artist and YouTube fan who drove her grandmother's car and worked at the Bradley Beach Fire Company as a volunteer

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 19 September 2024.

Accused

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Michael Stern. Sarah's father
Lillian Stern. Sarah's grandmother and the registered owner of the car
Wayne Rainer. detective with the prosecutor's office
Shane Leaming. Neptune Township police officer who found the car
Carlos Diaz-Cobo. defence attorney
Christopher Decker. prosecutor
Robert J. Brown. Neptune City mayor at the time
Jenna Marbles. YouTuber who tweeted condolences to the family

The timeline

  1. about 2002 and Sarah Stern meet in Sunday school at about six years oldabout 0:36:52
  2. middle school and Sarah become close friendsabout 0:37:01
  3. 2015 Sarah, and graduate from Neptune High School (Neptune High School)about 0:38:25
  4. about three or four years before 2016 Sarah's mother diesabout 0:30:39
  5. August or September 2016 is first approached about a plot to rob Sarah Stern at Clancy's bar in Neptune (Clancy's bar)about 1:32:53
  6. Thanksgiving 2016 tells Anthony Curry his idea for a film in which he strangles a girl and throws her off a bridge with a friendabout 1:03:45
  7. late November 2016 brings a six-pack of Mike's Hard Lemonade to Sarah's house in an unsuccessful attempt to get her drunk and rob her (Sarah Stern's house)about 1:34:48
  8. December 2, 2016 calls Sarah at 12.57 p.m., takes her to Taco Bell and the bank, and plays video games with her at her house (Sarah Stern's house)about 0:43:45
  9. December 2, 2016 leaves Sarah's house at 5.45 p.m. to go to work at Brennan's Steak House (Sarah Stern's house)about 0:53:47
  10. December 2, 2016 strangles Sarah at her house, timing the killing on his phone; it takes about half an hour (Sarah Stern's house)about 1:17:41
  11. December 2, 2016 moves Sarah's body from the bathroom to the bushes in her backyard while is at work (Sarah Stern's house)about 1:19:00

Places and phrases

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode