FILE 496 / 25 May 2024 / 71 MIN / express

Too Many Knots Tied

Tallapoosa, MissouriListen

The town

N ↑Public placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

We're going to Missouri... Talapusa, Missouri... This is in New Madrid county... in the boot heel of Missouri. about 0:04:58

History, in brief

Town note

Named after Tallapoosa County, Alabama; there are also Tallapoosa in Georgia and Michigan.

about 0:06:07

Town note

The name is of Creek origin, said to mean 'pulverized rock' in Choctaw or 'grandmother town' in Muscogee.

about 0:06:43
All 4 history facts

Town note

Named after Tallapoosa County, Alabama; there are also Tallapoosa in Georgia and Michigan.

about 0:06:07

Town note

The name is of Creek origin, said to mean 'pulverized rock' in Choctaw or 'grandmother town' in Muscogee.

about 0:06:43

The figures, as told

Money

Median home value$62,000
Median household incomeabout $47,000 a year
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2024

Population

"78 people"

No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:05:08

Area

"0.45 square miles"

No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:05:17

Median household income

"about $47,000 a year"

Comparison: "way below the national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2024 about 0:05:21

Median home cost

"$62,000"

Comparison: "below the national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2024 about 0:05:41

The reviews

2.7 / 5 · average of 3

3 stars

“Small and tight-knit, but hard for outsiders or people who are different to be accepted by the powerful cliques; overall a cute town with a lot of good people.”
about 0:07:05

3 stars

“Nothing at all to do for fun; you have to go three towns over to watch a movie at a single-screen cinema.”
about 0:08:09

2 stars

“The crime rate has gone up over the last four years, with the younger generation shooting at people and putting lives in danger.”
about 0:08:51

In Missouri

Closest episodes

  1. Three Is A Ring, Four Is A CrowdMarmaduke, Arkansas · 28 May 202062 km / 39 miShow on map
  2. Homicidal Bloodthirsty Energizer BunnyCape Girardeau, Missouri · 2 July 202692 km / 57 miShow on map
  3. The Murder Video ShockerPocahontas, Arkansas · 13 January 2024107 km / 67 miShow on map
  4. Murdering As A FamilyJonesboro, Arkansas · 19 April 2025109 km / 68 miShow on map
  5. Naked Aggression & Vicious ViolencePaducah, Kentucky · 7 October 2023122 km / 76 miShow on map

The story

In December 1996 Tallapoosa, a town of 78 people in New Madrid County in the Missouri boot heel, was the scene of a double murder. Candy had had back surgery four days earlier.

He decided to flee and to get money from Irene, whom he thought had some. On the evening of 15 December 1996 he told friends Daniel and Samantha Simmons that he was going to Tallapoosa to collect money, drove them past the Sisk house three times, said the girl was going to pay him and pointed to a note on the door. Samantha noticed him playing with a purple Crown Royal bag.

Candy telephoned her aunt Debbie Dubois, who was at work at the elementary school. Shortly after nine, a bank teller in nearby Risco saw a man in a white Ford Taurus with Candy in the passenger seat, dressed in a nightgown and wrapped in a blanket, and another person in the rear seat. The man presented a cheque for $1,000 signed by Candy and took the cash, $100 in $20 bills. At about 10:45 Debbie called the house and got no answer. She drove over, entered through the carport and found Candy on her bed, her neck cut and a knife sticking out of her chest; Irene lay in a pool of blood on her bedroom floor, hogtied. The telephones were gone. Debbie ran to a store where her brother worked and called the police.

Candy's hands had been bound with rope, her throat slashed six to eight times; a six-inch knife had been driven through her sternum and heart after death, and there were bite marks on her breast and a dildo inserted anally. Irene had 17 stab wounds, five of them through the chest and lung, three deep slashes to the throat and three wounds consistent with scissors; it took her 15 to 45 minutes to drown in her own blood. The purses had been opened, a cheque for $1,000 made out to cash lay unsigned, a television and VCR were missing, and the tape of Independence Day had been taken from its box.

Lieutenant Steve Hensley found an address at his parents' house, drove past around midnight and saw a white Ford Taurus matching the bank description. The motel showed he had not rented the room until the following day. At a second interview he asked to speak to his brother and then blurted out that he had not meant to kill them. He said he had gone for money, that Irene began a cheque and stopped, that Candy wrote one for $1,000 and he drove them to the bank; he tied them up to buy time, saw Irene watching him through the kitchen window, went back and hogtied her, and when both women screamed he 'shut them up'. He denied any sexual assault.

A search of his room found 32 ropes and cords, two matching the bindings, notes with directions to the Sisk house and a list of what to take ('things for first entrance: gun, back, handcuffs, pocket, twelve foot of rope, legs, into six foot pieces'), a Crown Royal bag holding handcuffs and a red duffel bag with ropes, more than 30 dildos, homemade sex tapes, a bondage magazine and the Independence Day tape. Blood on his mother's car door handle was a mixture of his DNA and Irene's.

The case

Murders of Irene and Candice Sisk

Victims

Candice 'Candy' Sisk (19). Shirley Niswanger's daughter, recovering from back surgery
Irene Sisk (74). Candy's grandmother, widowed in April 1996

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 25 May 2024.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Debbie Dubois. Shirley's sister, who found the bodies
Daniel and Samantha Simmons. friends visited the night before the murders
Kelvin Dennis. man said he bought meth from and to whom he gave a VCR

The timeline

  1. 1962 is born.about 0:12:59
  2. early 1993 and Shirley Niswanger begin a relationship.about 0:14:37
  3. August 7, 1995 A burglary takes place that later admits to.about 0:20:19
  4. April 1996 Irene Sisk's husband and Shirley's father dies.about 0:13:24

Places and phrases

N ↑Public placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode