FILE 501 / 13 June 2024 / 172 MIN / full

Kill Them All

Pleasant Grove, ArkansasListen

The town

N ↑Public placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Pleasant Grove, Arkansas, just outside Dover; this is in Stone County, Arkansas. about 0:06:15

History, in brief

Town note

Originally called Red Stripe, because of the redness of the iron ore in the soil.

about 0:06:20

Town note

The community was first in Independence County and later in Stone County.

about 0:06:31

1912

A post office was established in 1912 with Mabel Estes Blair as postmaster.

about 0:07:35

Town note

It was renamed because of the bad publicity from the Connie Franklin murder case.

about 0:07:43
All 10 history facts

Town note

Originally called Red Stripe, because of the redness of the iron ore in the soil.

about 0:06:20

Town note

The community was first in Independence County and later in Stone County.

about 0:06:31

1912

A post office was established in 1912 with Mabel Estes Blair as postmaster.

about 0:07:35

Town note

It was renamed because of the bad publicity from the Connie Franklin murder case.

about 0:07:43

1929

In the spring of 1929 Connie Franklin was allegedly murdered near St. James and Red Stripe by four local men.

about 0:08:28

Town note

Franklin had arrived in St. James and began seeing a young woman; four men beat the couple, raped the woman, tortured and killed him and burned his corpse.

about 0:08:47

Town note

In the middle of the trial a man claiming to be Connie Franklin walked into the courtroom, and the defendants were found not guilty.

about 0:09:13

Town note

Many people believed the man was an imposter, possibly a friend of the defendants, though some said the real Franklin had been framed and others said it was his ghost.

about 0:09:42

Town note

The fake Connie Franklin died of appendicitis three years later.

about 0:10:20

The figures, as told

Religious

48%

Biggest faith: Baptists, 27%

about 0:14:44

Who lives here

Black one · Hispanic two

Ethnicity can overlap race.

Crime / national average

Property crime
right at average

about 0:20:55

Violent crime
▼ just below the average

about 0:21:18

People killed
16

about 2:08:34

Money

Median home value$125,200
Two-bedroom rentabout $710
Median household income$42,083 a year
Cost of living$73 out of $100

For sale

$230,000

Three-bedroom, two-bath house, 1,712 square feet on 1.97 acres

about 0:16:42

For sale

$234,900

Four-bedroom, two-bath house, 1,738 square feet on three and a half acres

about 0:17:10

For sale

$399,900

Three-bedroom, two-bath house, 2,688 square feet on 13 acres

about 0:17:43
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2024

Population of Dover

"1,200"

No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:10:46

Female residents

"73.1%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:13:37

Median age

"51"

Comparison: "national average of about 37". No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:14:13

Children aged zero to four

"0%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:14:18

Married residents

"20%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:14:26

Single with children

"0.0%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:14:29

Black residents

"one"

No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:13:21

Hispanic residents

"two"

No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:14:37

Unemployment rate

"a little bit higher than normal"

Comparison: "normal". Direction: above.

As told in 2024 about 0:14:56

Religious residents

"48%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:14:44

Median household income

"$42,083 a year"

Comparison: "national average over $69,000". Direction: above.

As told in 2024 about 0:15:02

Cost of living

"$73 out of $100"

Comparison: "the average is $100". Direction: below.

As told in 2024 about 0:15:15

Median home cost

"$125,200"

No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:15:19

Average two-bedroom rent

"about $710"

No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:15:52

Three-bedroom, two-bath house, 1,712 square feet on 1.97 acres

"$230,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:16:42

Four-bedroom, two-bath house, 1,738 square feet on three and a half acres

"$234,900"

No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:17:10

Three-bedroom, two-bath house, 2,688 square feet on 13 acres

"$399,900"

No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:17:43

Property crime

"right at average"

Comparison: "national average". Direction: about the same.

As told in 2024 about 0:20:55

Violent crime

"just below the average"

Comparison: "national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2024 about 0:21:18

People killed

"16"

Comparison: "second worst mass murder in America at the time, after Charles Whitman". No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 2:08:34

The reviews

4.3 / 5 · average of 3

5 stars

“A quintessential small town with a unique, close-knit community where everyone knows your name; community fairs and festivals, nature's tranquillity, a peaceful slower-paced lifestyle, and essential amenities including a Dollar General and a Harps.”
about 0:10:59

5 stars

“A small, quaint town where everyone knows everyone and it is amazingly safe, with great schools and involved teachers; the nightlife is not great but that is to be expected, and the Dollar General is the big store.”
about 0:12:20

3 stars

“More establishments could be opened to give Dover more of a real town feel; the reviewer goes to Russellville for basically all business and shopping.”
about 0:12:57

In Arkansas

Closest episodes

  1. A Killer So ClumsyKensett, Arkansas · 9 August 201768 km / 42 miShow on map
  2. The Deadly Grandma & The DoppelgängerAustin, Arkansas · 10 January 202691 km / 57 miShow on map
  3. On Deadly GroundCabot, Arkansas · 21 August 202595 km / 59 miShow on map
  4. The Murder Video ShockerPocahontas, Arkansas · 13 January 202497 km / 60 miShow on map
  5. Murdering As A FamilyJonesboro, Arkansas · 19 April 2025111 km / 69 miShow on map

The story

Ronald Gene Simmons was born in Chicago on 15 July 1940, the son of Loretta and William Simmons. His father died of a stroke before Gene was a year old, and his mother remarried quickly, a civil engineer, and the family moved to Hector, Arkansas. Gene was a bully from childhood: he beat his sister and half-brother and tortured the family cat, and in 1950 his stepfather beat him with a belt and a rubber hose for it.

In 1960, while stationed at Bremerton, Washington, he met Rebecca Ulibarri, known as Becky, then nineteen, at a USO dance. He proposed by mail and they married the same year. She was from Colorado and had little experience of the world. Immediately after the wedding he told her to stop wearing make-up and to wear her hair pulled back, and the marriage became violent. They had seven children: Ronald Gene junior in 1961, Sheila in 1963, William in 1964, Loretta in 1970, Eddie in 1973, Marianne in 1976 and Rebecca, known as Becky junior, in 1979. He left the Navy in 1962 and joined the Air Force in 1963, serving as a clerk and rising to master sergeant, with postings in Virginia, California and the United Kingdom and a year in Vietnam, where he was awarded a Bronze Star and marksmanship ribbons. The family lived in San Francisco, then England, then the small New Mexico town of Cloudcroft. He retired in 1979 and took a civilian job at Holloman Air Force Base.

At home he was a tyrant. The children were not allowed to socialise or join after-school activities, he read and censored all the family mail, he beat Becky and beat any child who intervened, and the house was run like a boot camp. In 1981 Sheila, then sixteen, became pregnant by her father. Her classmates told their parents, who told teachers, who told the school, and eventually the sheriff was called; Gene junior also telephoned the New Mexico Department of Human Services. Sheila told a friend that she had no boyfriends and that her father was molesting her. Three counts of incest were filed. Sheila gave birth to a daughter, Sylvia Gale.

The family had moved to Ward, Arkansas, near Little Rock. Simmons worked at a Veterans Administration hospital from October 1981 to January 1982, then for nine months as a clerk-typist at the Army Recruiting Command Office in Little Rock, then at a pickle factory in Atkins, then full time at a Mini Mart in Russellville, and from January 1985 part time there while also working as an accounts receivable clerk at Woodline Motor Freight.

The home was two old trailers welded together; he built a ten-foot cinder block wall with barbed wire around the trailer, posted no trespassing signs, collected rainwater, let the plumbing fail so the family used outhouses, refused a telephone and kept the family isolated. Sheila met Dennis McNulty at college; Simmons moved the family to get her away from him, but she married McNulty anyway, he adopted Sylvia and they had a son, Michael, in 1985. Gene junior, Sheila and William all married and left. At Woodline he became infatuated with Kathy Kendrick, a 25-year-old former teenage beauty queen and secretary, and pursued her repeatedly until she filed sexual harassment complaints; at the end of 1986 he quit, telling his supervisor Joyce Butts to take the job and shove it. He then worked at a Sinclair Mini Mart.

In the summer of 1987 Becky began to resist: she had her ears pierced, had her hair cut and wrote to her children that she had been a prisoner long enough and wanted to leave. On 18 December 1987 Simmons quit the Mini Mart. On 23 December he told the children he had gifts for them and would give them one at a time in their rooms. He strangled Loretta first and held her head in the rain barrel, then did the same to Eddie, Marianne and Rebecca. He shot Becky twice in the head, then shot Gene junior four times in the head and once in the stomach. He put the bodies in the pit the children had dug, soaked them in kerosene, and put three-year-old Barbara, Gene junior's daughter, in a plastic bag in the boot of an abandoned car.

On Christmas Eve he bought three dollars of petrol and a pack of cigarettes and was seen at Sears in Russellville, and again the day after Christmas. On 28 December William, Renata and their 20-month-old son Trey arrived; he shot William twice in the head and Renata five times in the head and once in the neck and throat, strangled Trey and put him in a green bag in another abandoned car. Sheila, Dennis, Sylvia and 21-month-old Michael arrived next; he shot Sheila six times in the head, shot Dennis once in the head at the door, then found six-year-old Sylvia in a bedroom and strangled her, and strangled Michael. He covered the bodies with coats and laid Sylvia on a bed under his wife's best tablecloth. Then he went to a bar for a beer.

He left on 28 December in his son's brown Toyota Corolla, after switching off the electricity, bought a second .22 at Walmart, called the law office of Richard Peel from the Delta service station on Interstate 40 and hung up, then walked in at 10.15 a.m. wearing a cowboy hat and carrying two .22 revolvers loaded with hollow points. The receptionist was Kathy Kendrick. He shot her repeatedly in the head at her desk and left. At 10.25 he shot dead J.D. Chaffin, a 33-year-old off-duty fireman and father of four, at Taylor Oil Company on West Main Street and wounded Rusty Taylor; at 10.40 he shot Roberta Woolery and David Saylor at the Sinclair Mini Mart, where a friend drove him off with cans of Coke; at 10.50 he shot Joyce Butts at Woodline Motor Freight, then told a clerk he had done what he came to do and waited for the police, handing his gun to Chief Herb Johnston.

That afternoon Sheriff James Bolin crawled through a window of the house and found the bodies. In all 16 people had been killed and 19 were victims including the wounded. At the time it was the second worst mass murder in America, after Charles Whitman. He was buried in a pauper's plot at Lincoln Memorial Lawn in Varner. A black granite monument in a Colorado cemetery marks the grave holding the ashes of five of the 16.

The case

The Ronald Gene Simmons Christmas murders

Victims

Ronald Gene Simmons Jr.. eldest son, known as Little Gene; visiting for Christmas with his daughter Barbara
Rebecca 'Becky' Simmons (40s). his wife, mother of seven
Barbara Simmons (3). daughter of Gene junior, living at the house
Loretta Simmons (17). daughter, a straight-A student who wanted to be a model
Eddie Simmons (14). son
Marianne Simmons (11). daughter
Rebecca Simmons (8). youngest daughter, known as Becky junior
William 'Billy' Simmons (23). son, married to Renata
Renata Simmons (21). William's wife
William 'Trey' Simmons Jr. (20 months). son of William and Renata
Sheila Simmons McNulty. daughter, married to Dennis McNulty
Dennis McNulty. Sheila's husband
Sylvia McNulty (6). Sheila's daughter, fathered by Simmons
Michael McNulty (21 months). son of Sheila and Dennis
Kathy Kendrick (25). former teenage beauty queen and secretary at Woodline Motor Freight, later at the Richard Peel law office
J.D. Chaffin (33). off-duty Russellville fireman and father of four

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 13 June 2024.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Abe Ulibarri. Becky's brother, known as Uncle Abe, who gave press interviews
Edith. Becky's sister-in-law, who visited the trailer at Easter 1985
Joyce Butts. his supervisor at Woodline Motor Freight, shot and wounded
Julie Mooney. new clerk at Taylor Oil Company, shot at but only grazed
Rusty Taylor. shot and wounded at Taylor Oil Company
Roberta Woolery. clerk shot at the Sinclair Mini Mart
David Saylor. Mini Mart manager, shot and wounded
James Bolin. sheriff who entered the house and found the bodies
Herb Johnston. police chief who took Simmons into custody
Wesley Lane. Cloudcroft school superintendent
Dennis McNulty's father. said he did not want Simmons to die because he was the last link to his family
Manuel. Becky's brother, who wanted to know the motive

The timeline

  1. July 15, 1940 Ronald Gene Simmons is born in Chicago to Loretta and William Simmonsabout 0:22:48
  2. 1941 His father William dies of a stroke, before Gene is oneabout 0:23:03

Last meals

Places and phrases

N ↑Public placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

New Mexico State University, Alamogordo branch

school

about 0:54:09

Heard in this episode