FILE 510 / 13 July 2024 / 68 MIN / express

The Scariest Barn On Earth

Delta, OhioListen

The town

N ↑Public placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Delta Ohio is where we're going to here. It is west of Toledo. about 0:03:22

History, in brief

Town note

The first settlement was made in the early 1830s.

about 0:04:43

1837

There has been a post office in the town since about 1837.

about 0:04:47

Town note

The area around the town was known as the Six-Mile Woods, an area six miles wide and 20 miles long with giant oak and walnut trees four feet in diameter.

about 0:05:17

Town note

The town was called Tad Moore, then Tad Pole, then Green Springs, then Slab Shanty, then Fingerville, before it became Delta.

about 0:05:32
All 7 history facts

Town note

The first settlement was made in the early 1830s.

about 0:04:43

1837

There has been a post office in the town since about 1837.

about 0:04:47

Town note

The area around the town was known as the Six-Mile Woods, an area six miles wide and 20 miles long with giant oak and walnut trees four feet in diameter.

about 0:05:17

Town note

The town was called Tad Moore, then Tad Pole, then Green Springs, then Slab Shanty, then Fingerville, before it became Delta.

about 0:05:32

Town note

The town motto is 'the community of opportunity'.

about 0:04:18

Town note

One of the earliest industries was the export of eggs by Mr Howard and Mr Moore, who shipped 60 to 80 barrels each week, averaging 80 dozen eggs per barrel.

about 0:08:59

Town note

When the Delta Chicken Festival began in the 1950s, Delta was home to one of the largest chicken hatcheries in the area as well as many chicken finishing farms.

about 0:09:23

The figures, as told

Money

Median home value$176,400
Median household incomeabout $67,000
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2024

Population

"2,790 people"

No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:03:54

Median household income

"about $67,000"

Comparison: "national average". No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:03:58

Median home price

"$176,400"

No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:04:06

The reviews

3.3 / 5 · average of 4

5 stars

“Great small town, very safe, friendly people, good school system, an excellent place to raise children, affordable housing; moved here 30 years ago and never regretted it.”
about 0:06:35

4 stars

“One sentence only: there is a lot to do, but not everyone uses it.”
about 0:07:03

3 stars

“It can be unpredictable sometimes, with roads that seem to move overnight.”
about 0:07:15

1 star

“Calls it Deltucky: a dumpy, dirty, corrupt town, the worst town in the county, with hundreds of freight trains, thousands of semi trucks, traffic jams at shift changes, expensive taxes and utilities, seven mobile home parks in the zip code and not one decent, horrible schools and loads of misdemeanour crime.”
about 0:07:34

In Ohio

Closest episodes

  1. I Killed The Devil... You're WelcomeJackson, Michigan · 1 August 201980 km / 50 miShow on map
  2. Possessed By StupidityBrownstown Township, Michigan · 3 December 202088 km / 55 miShow on map
  3. Satan's CarnivalAuburn, Indiana · 3 June 202189 km / 55 miShow on map
  4. A Chance EncounterWebster Township, Michigan · 4 October 201890 km / 56 miShow on map
  5. Jeepers Creepers MurderColdwater, Michigan · 18 July 202591 km / 57 miShow on map

The story

In July 2016 Sierra Joughin, known to everyone as C, was 20 years old and living west of Toledo, Ohio. She had grown up in Lyons, a small place near Delta, and was studying at the University of Toledo, going into her junior year. She was a member of the Alpha Kappa Psi business fraternity, loved horses and was remembered as vivacious. Her boyfriend was Josh Colasinsky, who rode a motorcycle.

On July 19th, 2016, Sierra rode her purple bicycle to Josh's house a little after four in the afternoon. She left at about 6.45 p.m. to ride home down County Road 6, and Josh followed her on his motorcycle for part of the way before turning off. He asked her to text when she got home; she never did. At about 7.20 p.m. a motorist, Mary Stein, saw a bicycle lying beside the west side of County Road 6 and a man bent over two or three rows into the cornfield, wearing red shorts and a white or off-white shirt. By about 9.30 p.m. Josh had called Sierra's mother, Sheila, and found the bicycle was not at the house; the two searched, then found a police officer at the fire department. Sierra did not come home.

At about one in the morning a sheriff's deputy with a canine found the purple bicycle in a cornfield about half a mile from Sierra's home. Nearby were disturbed corn, a strong smell of petrol, motorcycle tyre tracks, a box of fuses and a pair of women's sunglasses. There was blood on the bicycle's handlebars and seat, and a checkered dish towel with a bloodstain was found a thousand feet north. A farmer had found a bloodstained motorcycle helmet at the roadside at about seven the previous evening and taken it home, and he brought it to police the next day. The FBI joined the case, the community searched the cornfields, and an anonymous donor offered a $100,000 reward. Blood was found on corn leaves, along with a green sock, men's sunglasses and an orange-handled screwdriver.

None of those items had been made public. When he later rang to ask for his helmet back, investigators returned and spent 14 hours on the property, then obtained a search warrant. They found women's laundry in a green crate, an air mattress hidden behind straw bales, duct tape, rope, adult nappies, handcuffs, zip ties, bleach and a carpet-lined chest freezer sunk into the barn floor with blood in it. The barn became known as the Barn of Horrors. Tire casts from County Road 6 matched his pickups. Security video from Evergreen High School showed a motorcycle travelling north on County Road 6 on July 19th.

On July 22nd a volunteer, Scott Hoodick, found drag marks in a cornfield on County Road 7 and a yellow latex glove. She was wearing an adult nappy. The cause of death was asphyxiation from the gag, and she had a head wound and a hairline skull fracture that could have come from the motorcycle helmet.

The case had an older echo. She escaped with one cuff on her wrist, jumped on a passing motorcycle and survived with a concussion and a fractured skull.

Robin Gardner testified. The prosecution argued that he had taken Sierra intending to kill her and had used a dog toy rather than a ball gag because he wanted to watch her die.

Sierra's family set up a scholarship fund for one graduate of Evergreen High School each year and a nonprofit, Justice for Sierra. Their campaign led to Sierra's Law, Ohio Senate Bill 231, passed in 2018, which created a searchable violent crime database of repeat offenders.

The case

Murder of Sierra Joughin

Victims

Sierra Joughin (20). Known as C; University of Toledo student from Lyons, Ohio, going into her junior year, a member of the Alpha Kappa Psi business fraternity who loved horses

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 13 July 2024.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Sheila. Sierra's mother, who reported her missing
Mary Stein. motorist who saw the bicycle and a man in the cornfield
Megan Roberts. special agent with the Ohio Bureau of Criminal Investigation
Scott Hoodick. volunteer searcher who found the drag marks and the body site
Mark Fauble. high school friend who gave a helmet
Jeffrey Whittaker. high school friend who rode motorcycles with and testified

The timeline

  1. February 11th, 1996 Sierra Joughin is bornabout 0:11:36
  2. July 19th, 2016, a little after 4 p.m. Sierra rides her purple bicycle to her boyfriend's house (Boyfriend's house)about 0:13:53
  3. about 7 p.m., July 19th, 2016 A farmer finds a bloodstained motorcycle helmet at the side of the road and takes it home in his pickup (County Road 6)about 0:22:36
  4. about 6.45 p.m., July 19th, 2016 Sierra leaves her boyfriend's house and rides home down County Road 6; he follows on his motorcycle for part of the way and they say goodbye (County Road 6)about 0:14:12
  5. about 7.20 p.m., July 19th, 2016 Mary Stein sees a bicycle lying beside the west side of County Road 6 and a man bent over two or three rows into the cornfield (County Road 6 abduction site)about 0:15:37
  6. about 7.42 to 7.45 p.m., July 19th, 2016 phone data places him at the abduction site; he makes a call at 7.43 (County Road 6 abduction site)about 0:57:22
  7. about 8.30 to 9 p.m., July 19th, 2016 Sierra's boyfriend texts her when she does not get home and gets no replyabout 0:16:16
  8. about 9.30 p.m., July 19th, 2016 The boyfriend calls Sheila; the bicycle is not at the house and Sierra is not home (Sierra's home)about 0:16:29
  9. the evening of July 19th, 2016 Sheila and the boyfriend search for Sierra and then find a police officer at the fire department (Delta fire department)about 0:16:49
  10. about 1 a.m., July 20th, 2016 BCI agent Megan Roberts is called to assist; a sheriff's deputy with a canine finds the bicycle in a cornfield about half a mile from Sierra's home (County Road 6 abduction site)about 0:18:22
  11. July 20th, 2016 Investigators find disturbed corn, a strong smell of gasoline, motorcycle tyre tracks, a box of fuses and women's sunglasses on County Road 6 (County Road 6 abduction site)about 0:18:36
  12. July 20th, 2016 Blood is found on the bicycle's handlebars and seat; her mother and boyfriend identify the bicycle as hers (County Road 6 abduction site)about 0:19:58
  13. July 20th, 2016 A checkered dish towel with a bloodstain is found about a thousand feet north of the abduction site (County Road 6)about 0:20:13
  14. July 20th, 2016 The FBI joins the case and the community begins a mass search of the cornfields; blood is found on corn leaves and a bloodstained green sock and men's sunglasses and an orange-handled screwdriver are recovered (County Road 6 abduction site)about 0:20:24
  15. July 20th, 2016 The farmer brings the bloodstained motorcycle helmet to police after hearing of the missing girlabout 0:22:56
  16. July 20th, 2016 Police interview at his home for about 90 minutes; he says his motorcycle stalled and that he lost a helmet, fuses, a screwdriver and sunglasses ( property)about 0:33:05
  17. July 21st, 2016 After asks for his helmet back, investigators return and spend 14 hours on his property ( property)about 0:42:00
  18. July 21st, 2016 Security video from Evergreen High School shows a motorcycle travelling north on County Road 6 on July 19th (Evergreen High School)about 0:44:33
  19. July 21st, 2016 Tyre impressions from red and green pickups are found consistent with casts from the County Road 6 scene ( property)about 0:49:46
  20. July 22nd, 2016 Volunteer Scott Hoodick finds 18-inch drag marks in a cornfield on the east side of County Road 7 and a yellow latex glove (County Road 7)about 0:51:07
  21. July 22nd, 2016 Sierra's body is found buried in a cornfield on the west side of County Road 7, about two miles from house, handcuffed, with her ankles bound with duct tape and a dog toy gag in her mouth (Burial site)about 0:52:20

Abduction of Robin Gardner

Victims

Robin Gardner (26). Riding her bicycle near her home when ran her off the road and attacked her; she escaped

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 13 July 2024.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

The timeline

  1. July 4th, 1990 Robin Gardner, 26, is riding her bicycle in a rural area of the county as she nears her houseabout 0:36:12
  2. July 4th, 1990 A red flatbed pickup truck hits her bicycle from behind and knocks her off onto the side of the roadabout 0:36:12
  3. July 4th, 1990 The driver, , asks if she is okay, then hits her in the back of the head with a hammer and puts her in a chokeholdabout 0:36:38
  4. July 4th, 1990 holds a screwdriver to her throat and threatens to kill her if she does not get into the truckabout 0:36:49
  5. July 4th, 1990 tries to handcuff her hands behind her back and gets one cuff on her wristabout 0:37:05
  6. July 4th, 1990 Gardner breaks away, pushes the truck door open and runs, with a handcuff hanging from her wristabout 0:37:11
  7. July 4th, 1990 She flags down a passing motorcycle and jumps on the back, escapingabout 0:37:28
  8. July 4th, 1990 Police have to cut the handcuff off because none of their keys fit itabout 0:37:48
  9. July 4th, 1990 Gardner is found to have a concussion and a fractured skull from the hammer blowabout 0:38:15

Disappearance of Claudia Tinsley

Victims

Claudia Tinsley. Reported missing by her mother, who last saw her leaving in car; never found

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 13 July 2024.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Claudia Tinsley's mother. reported her daughter missing

The timeline

  1. 1996 Claudia Tinsley's mother reports that she last saw her daughter leaving in carabout 0:40:29

Places and phrases

N ↑Public placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode