FILE 536 / 12 October 2024 / 72 MIN / express

Cooking Up Murder

Lomita, CaliforniaListen

The town

N ↑Public placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

"We're going to Lomita, California... It's in LA County, but it's its own little suburb over here." about 0:04:03

History, in brief

Town note

The Sepulveda family established and started raising cattle on Rancho Los Palos Verdes, which angered the Dominguez family because the Sepulvedas had no land grant and simply started using the land.

about 0:05:21

1841

The dispute was not resolved until 1841, when the Sepulvedas finally got a signed deed.

about 0:05:49
All 9 history facts

Town note

The Sepulveda family established and started raising cattle on Rancho Los Palos Verdes, which angered the Dominguez family because the Sepulvedas had no land grant and simply started using the land.

about 0:05:21

1841

The dispute was not resolved until 1841, when the Sepulvedas finally got a signed deed.

about 0:05:49

1863

Swarms of grasshoppers ravaged the grasslands in 1863.

about 0:06:22

1865

By 1865 there was basically no cattle left and the five-year run of disasters had destroyed the whole Southern California ranching industry.

about 0:06:35

1935

In 1935 the vaudevillian actor Frank Gumm of Grand Rapids, Minnesota leased the Lomita Theater to present his singing and dancing daughters Mary Jane, Dorothy Virginia and Judy, who was Judy Garland.

about 0:06:58

The figures, as told

Money

Median home value$846,100
Median household income$85,852
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2024

Population

"20,884"

No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:04:46

Median household income

"$85,852"

Comparison: "$15,000 above the national average". Direction: above.

As told in 2024 about 0:04:58

Median home cost

"$846,100"

No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:05:10

The reviews

3.2 / 5 · average of 5

5 stars

“Loves Lomita; aside from living near a hospital and hearing ambulances and fire department sirens it is pretty quiet, graffiti is quickly covered, and the only change wanted is the grass cut more often on side streets.”
about 0:07:27

3 stars

“Wishes there were fewer drug addicts everywhere, and says the drinking water is disgusting and not safe for human consumption.”
about 0:08:05

2 stars

“Bad; would not want a vacation there.”
about 0:08:34

5 stars

“Great little neighbourhood with a small-town feel, 15 minutes from Redondo Beach and 20 from LA, with lots of fairs and festivals year-round that remind the reviewer of home.”
about 0:08:44

1 star

“Reply to the five-star review: 'What the hell are you talking about' - it is overcrowded, nasty and dirty, with homeless people defecating on lawns and bums everywhere; asks what small towns, meth towns?”
about 0:09:05

In California

Closest episodes

  1. Three Murders & A StranglingCanyon Lake, California · 23 May 201898 km / 61 miShow on map
  2. A Liar, A Killer & An IdiotCottonwood, California · 16 June 2022183 km / 114 miShow on map
  3. Sickness, Solvent & Snuff FilmsBorrego Springs, California · 29 July 2021192 km / 119 miShow on map
  4. The Most Interesting Murderer In The WorldSpringville, California · 22 January 2026263 km / 163 miShow on map
  5. The Cowboy & The Con ManOlancha, California · 5 September 2025277 km / 172 miShow on map

The story

Around 1994 he met Dawn, a waitress where he was the chef, and they married in 1997. In 2008 they settled in a two-bedroom apartment in Lomita, Los Angeles County.

In spring 2009 they opened the Time Contemporary Cafe in a Lomita shopping centre. It closed for a remodel from May to September while Dawn waited tables elsewhere. Dawn was a heavy drinker who also used cocaine and meth. That summer she gave $640 in cash to Joe Cakase to hold as a nest egg.

On Sunday, October 18, 2009, Richard 'Dicky' Stagneto installed a pot and pan rack at the cafe. There were a few more calls, then nothing.

On October 20 Dawn failed to meet Patterson at the hospital where Patterson was having cancer treatment. The receipts showed only about $25 missing, and he said 'good riddance to her'. On October 23 Patterson received a text from Dawn's phone signed 'Love Pixy', misspelt and full of uncharacteristic errors, saying she needed time and was moving back east. A neighbour, Donna Morton, recalled an argument and Dawn leaving with bags. On November 8 Dawn's sister filed a missing persons report with the Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department.

About two weeks after the disappearance he began a relationship with Kathy Galvan, who moved in during mid-November. His daughter Jackie came from South Carolina and, with Kathy, packed Dawn's clothes into storage. In a recorded phone interview on December 9 he claimed she drank about 18 beers a day.

On February 22, 2011, two sheriff's detectives interviewed Jackie in South Carolina. She told them what her father had said and, at their request, called him to say she had told the police everything. He asked Kathy to tell his mother and brother he loved them, then jumped off an 80-foot cliff. He survived the fall onto the rocks, was rescued by a police helicopter and taken to hospital.

Search warrants at his mother's house and the cafe found no physical evidence, though a cadaver dog stopped at a shed behind the restaurant. On March 1, 2011, detectives interviewed him at his hospital bed. He said he took Ambien and blockaded the bedroom door, and when Dawn kept raising hell he forced her down in the living room and taped her hands, feet and mouth. He said she did not resist, that he woke to find her dead and put her in a plastic bag, and first claimed he dumped her in a dumpster behind the restaurant. Pressed again four days later, he said he had placed her body face down in a 55-gallon drum of boiling water with weights on top, slow-cooked her for four days, strained the remains and mixed them with restaurant grease and debris in garbage bags in the dumpster. He said he kept her skull and jawbone in his mother's attic in Torrance; a search found nothing and her skull has never been recovered.

The defence was Ambien: forensic toxicologist Dr Marvin Pietruska testified that the drug could cause confusion, aggravated by alcohol.

The case

Murder of Dawn Vines

Victims

Dawn Vines. Vines's wife, hostess and server at their restaurant, described as a heavy drinker who also used cocaine and meth

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 12 October 2024.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Kathy Galvan. 22-year-old part-time waitress at the Time Cafe who became girlfriend and moved into the apartment
Karen Patterson. interior designer, close friend of the couple, who worked on the cafe remodel
Richard 'Dicky' Stagneto. friend and former business associate of family, who installed a pot and pan rack at the cafe
Joe Cakase. owner of a motorcycle repair shop next to the cafe, who held $640 of Dawn's money
Jacqueline 'Jackie' Vines. daughter, born about 1990, who came from South Carolina and later told police what her father said
Donna Morton. neighbour in the same apartment complex who overheard the argument
Sergeant Richard Garcia. led the homicide investigation

The timeline

  1. 1993 Vines is going through a divorce in Vermont; he has three children, the youngest Jacqueline born about 1990, and works as a chef.about 0:12:58
  2. around 1994 meets Dawn at a restaurant where he is the chef and she waits tables.about 0:16:27
  3. 1997 and Dawn marry.about 0:16:28
  4. 2008 and Dawn move to California and end up in a two-bedroom apartment in Lomita. (Vines apartment)about 0:22:23
  5. spring of 2009 They open the Time Contemporary Cafe in Lomita. (Time Contemporary Cafe)about 0:24:35
  6. May to September 2009 The cafe is closed for a major remodel; works 80 hours a week on it while Dawn waits tables elsewhere to pay the bills. (Time Contemporary Cafe)about 0:25:26
  7. summer of 2009 Dawn gives Joe Cakase an envelope containing $640 in cash, calling it a nest egg to hold for later. (Cakase's motorcycle repair shop)about 0:26:15
  8. September 2009 Dawn locks herself in the bathroom and calls Karen Patterson, saying was angry and she was afraid he would beat her; she refuses to let Patterson call police because would lose the restaurant. (Vines apartment)about 0:27:51
  9. September 2009 The cafe reopens with as chef and Dawn as hostess and server. (Time Contemporary Cafe)about 0:32:43
  10. October 18, 2009 Richard Stagneto installs a pot and pan rack at the cafe around 10pm; complains that Dawn is drinking too much and stealing, and says 'that bitch is stealing from me and nobody steals from me, and I will kill that bitch'. (Time Contemporary Cafe)about 0:34:00
  11. October 18, 2009 leaves the cafe with a chef applicant and they go to a pool hall for beers.about 0:34:32
  12. October 18, 2009, 11.01pm Dawn calls Joe Cakase saying she has more money saved and will drop it at the shop the next day.about 0:35:12
  13. October 19, 2009 At an early morning staff meeting says Dawn will not be working there any more and asks 22-year-old waitress Kathy Galvan to take on managerial duties. (Time Contemporary Cafe)about 0:36:16
  14. October 20, 2009 Dawn fails to meet Karen Patterson at the hospital; Patterson and her husband go to the cafe, where is sweaty, agitated and has a large bandage on his hand, and says Dawn packed and left on Sunday night. (Time Contemporary Cafe)about 0:37:31
  15. October 23, 2009 Patterson receives a text from Dawn's phone signed 'Love Pixy', spelt PIXY and full of uncharacteristic spelling errors, saying Dawn needs time and is moving back east.about 0:39:15
  16. October 2009 Neighbour Donna Morton overhears a 15-minute argument with objects thrown, then sees Dawn storm out with bags; she never sees her again. (Vines apartment)about 0:40:41
  17. November 8, 2009 Dawn's sister files a missing persons report with the Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department. (LA County Sheriff's Department)about 0:42:20
  18. November 11, 2009 Police interview at the apartment; he says Dawn left after an argument about his working too hard and never contacted him. (Vines apartment)about 0:43:21
  19. about two weeks after the disappearance and Kathy Galvan begin a romantic relationship; Kathy notices all of Dawn's belongings are still in the apartment. (Vines apartment)about 0:44:08
  20. November 2009 Jackie comes from South Carolina at request and stays about six weeks; she and Kathy pack Dawn's clothes into a rental storage unit.about 0:44:49
  21. mid November 2009 Kathy Galvan moves into the apartment with . (Vines apartment)about 0:45:10
  22. December 9, 2009 Police conduct a recorded phone interview with , who says Dawn drank about 18 beers a day and caused $200 to $300 cash shortages.about 0:47:44
  23. October 2010 Sergeant Richard Garcia arranges a search of the apartment, by then vacated; blood stains are found on the bedroom wall and bathroom floor but are too degraded to test. (Vines apartment)about 0:50:36
  24. February 22, 2011 Two Los Angeles County sheriff's detectives interview Jackie in South Carolina; she admits what her father told her and, at their request, calls him to say she told the police everything.about 0:51:08
  25. February 23, 2011 shows Kathy a newspaper article saying Dawn's disappearance is being investigated as a homicide, says he is sorry and that it was an accident, then drives to the cliffs, says goodbye and jumps off an 80-foot cliff. (the cliffs)about 0:52:29
  26. February 23, 2011 survives the fall onto the rocks, is rescued by a police helicopter and taken to hospital. (hospital)about 0:54:24
  27. March 2011 says he put her body in a 55-gallon drum of boiling water and slow-cooked it for four days, then strained the remains and mixed them with restaurant grease and debris in garbage bags in a dumpster. (Time Contemporary Cafe)about 1:02:21

Places and phrases

N ↑Public placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode