FILE 602 / 6 June 2025 / 79 MIN / express

Real Life Murder Songs

Farmville, VirginiaListen

The town

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

We are going to Farmville, Virginia... This is in central Virginia... this is in both Prince Edward and Cumberland counties. about 0:03:29

History, in brief

1798

Farmville was formed in 1798 but was not incorporated until 1912.

about 0:05:58

1833

John Flornoy was the first to mine coal near Farmville, starting in 1833 on a seam two feet thick.

about 0:06:12

1837

In 1837 a charter was granted to the Prince Edward Coal Mining Company to mine and sell coal; the company lasted until about the 1880s.

about 0:06:22
All 9 history facts

1798

Farmville was formed in 1798 but was not incorporated until 1912.

about 0:05:58

1833

John Flornoy was the first to mine coal near Farmville, starting in 1833 on a seam two feet thick.

about 0:06:12

1837

In 1837 a charter was granted to the Prince Edward Coal Mining Company to mine and sell coal; the company lasted until about the 1880s.

about 0:06:22

Town note

Another coal pit in the 1880s was worked at another property, and its coal fuelled a blacksmith's shop.

about 0:06:33

Town note

Vince Gilligan, creator of Breaking Bad, is from Farmville.

about 0:07:16

Town note

Joseph E. Johnston, a Confederate general in the American Civil War, is from Farmville.

about 0:07:55

The figures, as told

Crime / national average

Violent crime
very little

about 0:52:18

Money

Median home value$214,000
Median household income$35,690
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2025

Population

"7,266"

No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:04:24

Median household income

"$35,690"

Comparison: "about half the national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2025 about 0:04:38

Median home cost

"$214,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:04:43

Congregation size

"about 50 members"

No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:16:23

House size

"2,600 square feet"

No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:47:35

Violent crime

"very little"

No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:52:18

The reviews

4.0 / 5 · average of 4

5 stars

“A great place to live once a person retires; the people are loving and polite.”
about 0:08:01

5 stars

“A few good historical places to learn the town's history and a college called Longwood College.”
about 0:08:12

5 stars

“The employees were very polite and welcoming and provided cups and plates for the meal.”
about 0:09:10

1 star

“Everyone around here is lazy and sucks at their job.”
about 0:09:34

In Virginia

Closest episodes

  1. Four Murders & A GetawayAmherst, Virginia · 14 February 201866 km / 41 miShow on map
  2. Murder For My LoveLynchburg, Virginia · 20 November 202571 km / 44 miShow on map
  3. A Web Of Deceit, Sex & MurderKeeling, Virginia · 17 September 2026102 km / 63 miShow on map
  4. We Will Dig Up That Basement!Vinton, Virginia · 24 September 2020132 km / 82 miShow on map
  5. The CSI EffectCollinsville, Virginia · 31 December 2022149 km / 93 miShow on map

The story

Farmville, Virginia, sits in both Prince Edward and Cumberland counties in the middle of the state, an hour and a quarter from Richmond. In 2009 it was a town of about 7,300 people and a college town, home to Longwood University, where Dr Deborah Kelly taught sociology and criminal justice studies. Deborah, born in Richmond in 1955, had divorced the pastor Mark Neeterbrock at the end of 2008 after a long marriage. Mark, born in Benton, Illinois, in 1959, had been pastor of the fifty-strong Walker's Presbyterian Church in Hicksburg, in Appomattox County, since 2003. The divorce was amicable: the two remained friends and shared the parenting of their sixteen-year-old daughter Emma, a home-schooled girl who liked fashion, music and the online world, where she called herself Ragdoll.

Emma's main interest was horrorcore rap, a genre of graphic, violent hip-hop. In late 2008 she began an online relationship with a twenty-year-old rapper from Castro Valley, California, who performed as Psycho Sam. He had never met Emma in person, but in September 2009 he flew to Virginia to see her.

On 12 September 2009 Deborah drove Emma, Emma's friend Melanie Grace Wells, eighteen, who was staying with them while she worked towards her GED, and Sam to Southgate, Michigan, for the Strictly for the Wicked horrorcore festival, run by Andres Schrim's Serial Killing Records. Schrim later described Sam as a brilliant web designer and said the label had commissioned work from him. During the festival Emma was texting, and Sam grew angry and jealous. The party returned to Deborah's four-bedroom house at First Avenue in Farmville, and Sam's mood darkened.

At about three in the morning on 15 September, furious about Emma, he took a wood-splitting maul and a ball-peen hammer and went through the house as the family slept. He killed Melanie first, in the downstairs den, then Deborah in an upstairs bedroom, and finally Emma in her downstairs bedroom, striking each of them repeatedly about the head. There were no defensive wounds. He then dragged the bodies into Emma's room. Two days later, on 17 September, Mark arrived at about five in the evening to check on the family; Sam attacked him in the living room and killed him too, before moving the body upstairs. He stayed in the house with the dead for several days, recorded a video of himself on a digital camera in which he said he knew he would have to pay for what he had done, and called the police once about noises in the basement on Melanie's mother's advice.

Melanie's mother, in West Virginia, had been telephoning the Farmville police. On 17 September officers called at the house and Sam told them the women had gone to the cinema. On 18 September she called again; officers returned, noticed the smell of decaying bodies, forced entry and found three women bludgeoned beyond recognition on the floor of the downstairs bedroom, and Mark's body in an upstairs bedroom. Mark's Honda was missing. The next day a sheriff's deputy stopped Sam in the car, issued him a summons for driving without a licence and had it towed; the tow-truck driver left him at a petrol station. At 11.30 that morning police found him asleep in the baggage claim at Richmond Airport with a ticket to California. Asked by a reporter how he had done it, he said, 'Jesus told me to do it.'

Investigators recovered the maul, the hammer and the camera with his video. Two self-styled occult experts, Don Rimmer and Paul Calcagno, publicly blamed horrorcore music and a satanic cult, but the prosecution said the music had nothing to do with it: Sam was a rejected young man who could not take no for an answer, and the other three were in the wrong place at the wrong time.

A letter of his later offered for sale on a murderabilia website asked for photographs of two of his victims, to keep in photo albums 'for memories'.

The case

Murder of Emma Neeterbrock and her family

Victims

Emma Neeterbrock (16). Mark and Deborah's daughter; Sam's online girlfriend
Dr Deborah Kelly (53). Associate professor of sociology and criminal justice studies at Longwood University; Emma's mother
Melanie Grace Wells (18). Emma's friend from West Virginia, staying with the family
Mark Neeterbrock (50). Pastor of Walker's Presbyterian Church in Hicksburg; Emma's father

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 6 June 2025.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Andres 'SicTanic' Schrim. owner of Serial Killing Records, which put on the festival
Melanie's mother. called Farmville police from West Virginia when she could not reach her daughter
Don Rimmer. police occult expert called in by investigators
Paul Calcagno. occult author who claimed Sam was part of a satanic cult
Jan and David Neeterbrock. Mark's parents
Tom and Margaret Kelly. Deborah's parents

The timeline

  1. September 28th, 1955 Deborah Kelly is born in Richmond, Virginia.about 0:16:50
  2. March 20th, 1959 Mark Neeterbrock is born in Benton, Illinois.about 0:13:58
  3. December 26th, 1988 is born.about 0:23:59
  4. 2003 Mark begins serving as pastor of Walker's Presbyterian Church in Hicksburg, Appomattox County. (Walker's Presbyterian Church)about 0:15:30
  5. the end of 2008 Mark and Deborah divorce but remain on friendly, co-parenting terms.about 0:20:44
  6. late 2008 Emma, posting as Ragdoll, begins an online relationship with Sam , built around horrorcore rap.about 0:23:03
  7. 2008 Sam starts rapping under the name Psycho Sam.about 0:35:15
  8. spring 2009 Sam's parents break up; Sam is devastated.about 0:40:57
  9. 2009 Melanie Wells, 18, is staying with Emma and Deborah while working towards her GED. (Neeterbrock house)about 0:21:27
  10. September 7th, 2009 Emma posts on MySpace counting down the days until Sam's visit, saying he will be at her house.about 0:41:13
  11. September 12th, 2009 Sam lands in Virginia and Deborah drives Emma, Melanie and Sam to Southgate, Michigan, for the Strictly for the Wicked festival. (Strictly for the Wicked festival)about 0:41:59
  12. September 12th, 2009 At the festival Sam, Emma and Melanie meet label owner Andres Schrim. (Strictly for the Wicked festival)about 0:43:20
  13. September 12th, 2009 Emma's texting during the festival angers Sam. (Strictly for the Wicked festival)about 0:47:55
  14. September 12th, 2009 The group returns to Deborah's house at First Avenue in Farmville. (Neeterbrock house)about 0:47:23
  15. late on September 14th or early on September 15th, 2009 After beer, cannabis and possibly painkillers, Sam kills Melanie, Deborah and then Emma with a maul and hammer as they sleep. (Neeterbrock house)about 1:01:35
  16. September 17th, 2009 Mark arrives at about 5 p.m. to check on the family; Sam attacks and kills him in the living room. (Neeterbrock house)about 1:03:04
  17. September 17th, 2009 Melanie's mother calls Farmville police; Sam answers the door and says the women have gone to the cinema. (Neeterbrock house)about 0:49:12
  18. September 18th, 2009 Sam logs into MySpace for the last time, listing his status as out of town and his mood as determined.about 0:50:15
  19. September 18th, 2009 Melanie's mother calls again; police return, smell decaying bodies and find three women downstairs and Mark upstairs, all bludgeoned. (Neeterbrock house)about 0:50:35

Places and phrases

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode