FILE 662 / 3 January 2026 / 71 MIN / express

Master Of Deceit

South Salt Lake, UtahListen

The town

N ↑Town centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

We're going to South Salt Lake, Utah ... it's in north central Utah where Salt Lake City is ... this is in Salt Lake County. about 0:04:03

History, in brief

1890

Jesse Fox Jr developed the area and named it Central Park around 1890, after visiting Central Park in New York.

about 0:05:52

1938

By 1938 the town still had no sewer system because it could not decide whether to join Salt Lake City or incorporate on its own.

about 0:06:29

Town note

The residents voted to incorporate the town of South Salt Lake so that it could start paying for a sewer.

about 0:06:51

1950

By 1950 the population had grown enough for South Salt Lake to be designated a third class city.

about 0:06:58
All 5 history facts

1890

Jesse Fox Jr developed the area and named it Central Park around 1890, after visiting Central Park in New York.

about 0:05:52

1938

By 1938 the town still had no sewer system because it could not decide whether to join Salt Lake City or incorporate on its own.

about 0:06:29

Town note

The residents voted to incorporate the town of South Salt Lake so that it could start paying for a sewer.

about 0:06:51

1950

By 1950 the population had grown enough for South Salt Lake to be designated a third class city.

about 0:06:58

Town note

Becoming a third class city changed the form of government to a mayor and city council, and the town president became the mayor.

about 0:07:21

The figures, as told

Money

Median home value$426,700
Median household income$50,589
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2026

Population

"26,086"

No direction stated.

As told in 2026 about 0:04:48

Population when the murder happened

"about 10,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2026 about 0:04:56

Median household income

"$50,589"

Comparison: "lower than the national average by almost $20,000". Direction: below.

As told in 2026 about 0:05:05

Median home cost

"$426,700"

No direction stated.

As told in 2026 about 0:05:17

The reviews

2.3 / 5 · average of 3

4 stars

“A good area, close enough to anything you could want and fairly safe, though the drivers are not great and you do not let your children wander around.”
about 0:07:41

2 stars

“Mostly industrial buildings with a lot of apartment complexes; the transit system is good, but there is trash on the streets, the roads are not kept up and nobody picks up their dog's poop.”
about 0:08:42

1 star

“A garbage wasteland full of crime, with rude people knocking on doors about Jesus, cops hanging around 7-11 or in church parking lots, break-ins and tweakers.”
about 0:09:14

In Utah

Closest episodes

  1. The Lego MurdersHolladay, Utah · 17 September 20208 km / 5 miShow on map
  2. Starting Your Own Religion Can Be TrickyAmerican Fork, Utah · 9 April 202037 km / 23 miShow on map
  3. Dr Serial KillerPleasant Grove, Utah · 26 September 202439 km / 24 miShow on map
  4. Remorseless HorrorsWashington Terrace, Utah · 25 October 201752 km / 32 miShow on map
  5. Blood IciclesOakley, Utah · 29 December 202253 km / 33 miShow on map

The story

South Salt Lake is a suburb of Salt Lake City in Salt Lake County, Utah, with a population of 26,086 today and about 10,000 when the murder happened. On 22 February 1989 a man searching the dumpsters outside the Smith's Food King grocery store at 851 East 45th South, collecting wilted lettuce for his rabbits, found garbage bags taped together. Inside were severed legs, cut at the mid thigh. Scars, a bloodstained sweater, blood type and baby footprints from an Indiana hospital identified them as Larry Dwayne White.

White was born in Fort Wayne, Indiana, in 1937. He had moved to Utah after high school and studied interior decorating at Brigham Young University without graduating. At 52 he was living with his 76-year-old father, Dale, working part time as a telemarketer and writing books. He had two unpublished manuscripts and was working on a third about the Mormon practice of baptising the dead. His father had reported him missing on 20 February 1989 and named the only friend his son saw regularly, a man he knew as Roy Anderson, who had been carpooling White to a new telemarketing job and had learned chess from him.

He had already left Utah. Federal authorities found him in Las Vegas on 6 April 1989, after he opened a post office box in White's name and applied for a copy of White's Indiana birth certificate. A search of his boarding house room produced White's identification papers, a five-shot .38 revolver, rubber gloves, electrician's tape, black plastic garbage bags, stolen licence plates and books on hiding an identity. His landlord said Bennett had rented East Kings Lane from December 1988 until he vanished in February 1989.

Detectives searched that house and noticed a bare patch in the yard between the house and a six-foot picket fence. Eight inches down they hit concrete. Beneath it, about 30 inches down and wedged between a pipe and the septic tank, was a torso wrapped in plastic, with no head and no arms. The next day they lifted another concrete patch along the southern foundation and found the head, wrapped in three bags and buried about 35 inches down. The torso showed five bullet holes from a .38, and the revolver matched. A hacksaw was found in the shed. The arms were never found. Leg bones went to the FBI crime laboratory at Quantico for comparison.

Bennett, held without bail, refused to answer questions.

Beaverton, Oregon, detectives had another reason to want him. His wife, Floy Jean Bennett, known as Genie, had vanished on 22 February 1978, eleven years to the day before White's legs were found. She was a court reporter for county circuit judge Richard J. Birke, earned $18,000 a year and had recently inherited $90,000. She left work, came home, and at about 7.30 p.m. went out to shop at Washington Square and was never seen again. Five days later Bennett told police her car was back in the driveway and clothes and suitcases were gone. He filed for divorce on 17 March 1978 and later asked to withdraw the petition. Police dug up ground looking for a body and found nothing. Her sister became conservator of her estate. Bennett went underground, moved to Reno, disappeared for ten years, travelled the country, returned to Oregon and in 1986 married his brother's widow. She has never been found.

In April 1991 Idaho authorities said mummified arms and legs found by artefact hunters in a cave near Dubois matched the torso of an unidentified man found deeper in the same cave about twelve years earlier, and compared the case with White's. He was still in custody at the Central Utah Correctional Facility in his eighties, offender number 53260.

The case

Murder of Larry Dwayne White

Victims

Larry Dwayne White (52). Telemarketer and aspiring writer, born in Fort Wayne, Indiana, living with his father; his legs were found in a grocery store dumpster

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 3 January 2026.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Dale White. Larry's father, then 76, who reported him missing and helped identify the legs
Unnamed man collecting lettuce. Man searching the dumpster for wilted lettuce for his rabbits who found the legs

The timeline

  1. 1937 Larry Dwayne White is bornabout 0:14:19
  2. 1938 is bornabout 0:20:04
  3. about two years before February 1989 White moves into an apartment with his father, Dale (White apartment)about 0:15:09
  4. December 1988 Bennett rents the house at East Kings Lane, where he lives until February 1989 (Bennett's rented house)about 0:24:51
  5. February 20, 1989 Dale White reports his son missingabout 0:18:02
  6. February 22, 1989 A man collecting wilted lettuce for his rabbits finds taped garbage bags holding severed legs in the dumpster at Smith's Food King (Smith's Food King Grocery Store)about 0:13:31
  7. February 22, 1989 The legs are identified as Larry White's from scars, a bloodstained sweater, blood type and baby footprints from an Indiana hospitalabout 0:15:42
  8. February 22, 1989 Police look for the man the father knew as Roy Anderson, the last person seen with Whiteabout 0:18:23
  9. April 1989 A search of Bennett's boarding house room recovers White's identification, a five shot .38 revolver, rubber gloves, electrician's tape, black garbage bags, stolen licence plates and books on hiding an identity (Las Vegas boarding house)about 0:22:18
  10. April 1989 Detectives dig up a torso wrapped in plastic from about 30 inches down between a pipe and the septic tank at East Kings Lane (Bennett's rented house)about 0:27:07
  11. the next day, April 1989 The head, wrapped in three plastic bags, is found under concrete along the southern foundation about 35 inches down (Bennett's rented house)about 0:27:22
  12. April 1989 The torso shows five bullet holes from a .38 and the recovered revolver matches themabout 0:29:52
  13. April 1989 A hacksaw is found in the shed on the property (shed at East Kings Lane)about 0:31:43
  14. April 1989 Leg bones are sent to the FBI crime lab at Quantico to be compared with the torso; the arms are never found (FBI Crime Lab)about 0:29:57
  15. April 5, 1991 Idaho authorities say mummified arms and legs found by artefact hunters in a cave near Dubois match the torso of an unidentified man found deeper in the same cave about twelve years earlier, and compare the case with White's (cave near Dubois)about 1:00:34
  16. 2026 Bennett, in his eighties, is still in custody at the Central Utah Correctional Facility, offender number 53260 (Central Utah Correctional Facility)about 1:07:21

Disappearance of Floy Jean Bennett

Victims

Floy Jean Bennett. Known as Genie; a court reporter for county circuit judge Richard J. Birke, earning $18,000 a year and recently inheriting $90,000

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 3 January 2026.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Joanna Rush. Genie's friend of 23 years
Richard J. Birke. County circuit judge she worked for
Genie's sister. Petitioned the court to become conservator of her estate

The timeline

  1. February 22, 1978 Floy Jean Bennett leaves work, comes home and about 7.30 p.m. goes out to shop at Washington Square; she is never seen again (Washington Square)about 0:36:40
  2. five days later, February 1978 Bennett tells police her car is back in the driveway and suitcases and some of her clothes are missing from the houseabout 0:39:51
  3. 1978 Police dig up a piece of ground where they believe a body could be buried and find nothingabout 0:46:36

Places and phrases

N ↑Town centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode