FILE 349 / 29 December 2022 / 165 MIN / full

Blood Icicles

Oakley, UtahListen

The town

N ↑Town centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

We're going to Oakley, Utah ... this is in Summit County, Utah, area code 435, right outside Park City. about 0:04:57

History, in brief

Town note

The Ute Indians were in the area first, followed by the Mormon pioneers.

about 0:05:43

1850

Parley P. Pratt was sent from Salt Lake City by Brigham Young in 1850 to look at settling along the Weber River near the Provo River; he reported 'a good valley, abundant grass, and plenty of water'.

about 0:06:26

Town note

Thomas Rhodes was the first white man to winter there, an explorer, trapper, prospector and farmer, a friend of Brigham Young who was called back from California when the church needed money.

about 0:06:56

1886

Oakley's original name was Oak Creek; it was renamed Oakley in 1886, the name chosen by a contest among settlers.

about 0:07:29
All 8 history facts

Town note

The Ute Indians were in the area first, followed by the Mormon pioneers.

about 0:05:43

1850

Parley P. Pratt was sent from Salt Lake City by Brigham Young in 1850 to look at settling along the Weber River near the Provo River; he reported 'a good valley, abundant grass, and plenty of water'.

about 0:06:26

Town note

Thomas Rhodes was the first white man to winter there, an explorer, trapper, prospector and farmer, a friend of Brigham Young who was called back from California when the church needed money.

about 0:06:56

1886

Oakley's original name was Oak Creek; it was renamed Oakley in 1886, the name chosen by a contest among settlers.

about 0:07:29

Town note

At one time the town made a great deal of dairy products; more recently it has focused on cattle and horse feeding and haying.

about 0:07:50

Town note

The area is a big destination for outdoor recreation such as horseback riding, fishing and hiking.

about 0:08:03

1998

In 1998 Mayor Doug Evans and the town discovered an underground aquifer holding water that had not seen the surface in at least 18,000 years.

about 0:11:50

Town note

The water was found nearly 1,900 feet below the surface in a layer of Mississippian limestone, among the purest ever tested, free of tritium and modern contamination, and the town uses it from the Humbug well for its municipal supply.

about 0:12:28

The figures, as told

Religious

59%

Biggest faith: Mormon, 36%

about 0:15:44

Who lives here

White 89.7% · Black 0.0% · Asian 0.1% · Hispanic 10.2%

Ethnicity can overlap race.

Crime / national average

Property crime
▼ about half the average rate

about 0:25:03

Violent crime
▼ about one third

about 0:25:14

Money

Median home value$597,100
Two-bedroom rent1,176
Median household income$73,295
Cost of living132

For sale

$998,000

Four-bedroom, three-bath log cabin, 3,250 square feet

about 0:18:21

For sale

$2,799,999

Seven-bedroom, eight-bath log cabin mansion, 8,312 square feet

about 0:19:34

For sale

$3,400,000

Five-bedroom, seven-bath house on four acres, 7,188 square feet

about 0:20:11
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2022

Population

"1,763"

No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:14:10

Median age

"about 32.7"

No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:14:20

Married

"about 69%"

Comparison: "normally 50-50". No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:14:38

Divorced

"7%"

Comparison: "way lower than normal". Direction: below.

As told in 2022 about 0:14:46

Married with children

"54%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:14:50

Single with children

"5%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:14:54

Unemployment rate

"about half"

Comparison: "the rest of the country". Direction: below.

As told in 2022 about 0:16:49

Religious

"59%"

Comparison: "normally 50-50 in the rest of the country". Direction: above.

As told in 2022 about 0:15:44

Median household income

"$73,295"

No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:16:54

Cost of living

"132"

Comparison: "100 is the average". Direction: above.

As told in 2022 about 0:17:06

Median home cost

"$597,100"

No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:17:14

Average two-bedroom rental

"1,176"

Comparison: "national average". No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:17:58

Four-bedroom, three-bath log cabin, 3,250 square feet

"$998,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:18:21

Seven-bedroom, eight-bath log cabin mansion, 8,312 square feet

"$2,799,999"

No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:19:34

Five-bedroom, seven-bath house on four acres, 7,188 square feet

"$3,400,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:20:11

Property crime

"about half the average rate"

Comparison: "national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2022 about 0:25:03

Violent crime

"about one third"

Comparison: "national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2022 about 0:25:14

The reviews

No rated reviews

“Many people don't like the idea of living in a small town, but the reviewer loves it; they enjoyed a small high school where they knew everyone and hoped to move back when they grew up.”
about 0:13:25

In Utah

Closest episodes

  1. The Lego MurdersHolladay, Utah · 17 September 202047 km / 29 miShow on map
  2. Master Of DeceitSouth Salt Lake, Utah · 3 January 202653 km / 33 miShow on map
  3. Dr Serial KillerPleasant Grove, Utah · 26 September 202457 km / 35 miShow on map
  4. Starting Your Own Religion Can Be TrickyAmerican Fork, Utah · 9 April 202060 km / 37 miShow on map
  5. Remorseless HorrorsWashington Terrace, Utah · 25 October 201776 km / 47 miShow on map

The story

On 22 December 1990, three generations of the Tidwell family drove up to a cabin they owned in the mountains above Oakley, Utah, to spend Christmas together. Kay Tidwell, fifty-one, and her mother Beth Harmon Tidwell Potts, seventy-two and partially blind, arrived with Kay's twenty-year-old daughter Lanae at about half past three in the afternoon. The cabin, which the family called Tide's Tranquility, sat about two and a half miles off the road and could only be reached by snowmobile in winter. The family had been staying with relatives in Salt Lake City the night before and had come back with Christmas shopping. Kay's husband Rolf, also fifty-one, and their seventeen-year-old daughter Trisha were expected later.

What none of them knew was that two men had been hiding in the cabin since the night before.

Lanae went in first to warm her frozen hands and saw a grey flash behind the refrigerator. She assumed a cousin had arrived early, but a frizzy-haired man in a grey sweatshirt came out with a pistol pointed at her. A second man with thick glasses appeared from the back bedroom and pointed a gun at her mother. Kay asked what they wanted and offered them anything. Seconds later the shooting began. Kay was hit and went down; Beth was shot in the head and blood sprayed across the room. Lanae was bound with duct tape and put in a bedroom. She begged to call a hospital, but the men behaved as though nothing had happened. She began planning an escape, knowing the family car was outside and that her father kept the keys under the mat.

About two hours later Rolf and Trisha arrived on snowmobiles. A man in a full ski mask stepped out from behind the garage with a gun and ordered them inside. Rolf could see the tears in Lanae's eyes and understood that something terrible had happened. The men asked for money; he handed over the only cash he had, 105 dollars, and was made to take off his snow gear until he stood barefoot in a T-shirt. The first round apparently misfired; the next hit Rolf in the face and knocked him down. He lay still, pretending to be dead, as gasoline was poured over his legs, back and head. Then he was shot again in the back of the head. One of the two rounds was birdshot, which helped him survive.

The men forced Lanae and Trisha onto the snowmobiles, each with a man behind her, and told the girls they had to come because they had seen their faces. At the main gate the sisters passed their uncle Randy Zorn, who had just arrived for the holiday. They pretended not to know him, afraid the men would shoot him. The men abandoned the snowmobiles, took the family's Lincoln and drove off. Randy followed, and when his mobile phone found a signal he called 911. On Highway 189 the Lincoln crashed off the road at over ninety miles an hour. Lanae screamed at the police to kill them both.

Back at the cabin, Rolf came round, put out the flames on himself in the shower and, with two bullets in his face and blood freezing into icicles, rode a snowmobile two miles through twenty-below weather to the gate. He told Randy that his wife had been killed and his daughters kidnapped. A medical helicopter flew him to University Hospital; he was in critical condition but recovered in time to attend the funerals. Police found a scene like a miniature war zone: frozen pools of blood, blood icicles hanging through the floorboards, the top floor still burning, and the two women dragged onto the deck and covered with a blanket and snow. They also found ten other break-ins in the cabin complex and a videotape on the coffee table.

Levine challenged none of them.

The prosecution called medical examiner investigator James Bell and asked him to rate the killing on a scale of one to ten for grossness. He said about nine, because it was a stranger-to-stranger, face-to-face shooting. He chose lethal injection rather than the firing squad and said he had nothing else to say.

Lanae was made to handle the murder weapon in court, which she found revolting.

In 1992 Rolf remarried, Lanae married and moved to Billings, Montana, and Trisha began at BYU. Rolf rebuilt the burned cabin and the family kept going back, calling it magical and healing. He died of cancer in 2008, aged about seventy. In 2016 he claimed he was innocent and asked for a new hearing, which the state opposed.

The case

Murder of Kay Tidwell and Beth Potts at the Tidwell cabin

Victims

Kay Tidwell (51). mother and wife, shot dead at the family cabin
Beth Harmon Tidwell Potts (72). Kay's mother, partially blind, shot dead at the cabin
Rolf Tidwell (51). Kay's husband, shot twice in the face, survived

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 29 December 2022.

Accused

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Rolf Tidwell. Kay's husband and the girls' father, shot twice and left for dead, escaped the burning cabin and raised the alarm
Lanae Tidwell. twenty-year-old daughter, held hostage and later a witness
Trisha Tidwell. seventeen-year-old daughter, held hostage and later a witness
Randy Zorn. uncle who arrived at the gate, followed the car and got Rolf to hospital
Eliot Levine. Summit County public defender for both men, later suspended
Bob Atkins. prosecutor
Terry Christianson. assistant county attorney
Joseph Offrit. Summit County detective
James Bell. medical examiner investigator who rated the killing's grossness at the penalty phase
Claudia Goates. Beth's other daughter, who called the more dangerous of the two

The timeline

  1. 1967 , aged two, falls down a flight of stairs and is hospitalised with his first head injuryabout 0:47:59
  2. 1977 Aged twelve, is badly hurt when an aerosol can explodes in a campfire, embedding shrapnel in his face and armabout 0:48:07
  3. 1979 Aged fourteen, is hospitalised after being thrown from a pickup truck in a rolloverabout 0:49:03
  4. April 8, 1983 crashes his motorcycle and is hospitalised againabout 0:49:23
  5. November 23, 1990 is transferred to the Orange Street halfway house in Salt Lake City (Orange Street halfway house)about 0:40:15
  6. December 14, 1990 and leave for a routine job search and never return; both are placed on walkaway status and fugitive warrants are issued (Orange Street halfway house)about 0:38:02
  7. the days before December 22, 1990 The two men hitchhike to Oakley and spend several days breaking into empty cabins to eat and sleepabout 1:00:13
  8. the night before December 22, 1990 The men see the family leave the cabin and move in, staying the night (Tidwell cabin)about 1:00:46
  9. December 22, 1990, about 3:30 pm Kay, Lanae and Beth arrive at the cabin and find two armed men waiting (Tidwell cabin)about 1:00:57
  10. December 22, 1990 Kay is shot in the chest and Beth is shot in the head; Lanae is bound with duct tape and put in a bedroom (Tidwell cabin)about 1:04:16

Places and phrases

N ↑Town centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode