FILE 688 / 3 April 2026 / 72 MIN / express

A Mystery Of Stupidity

Pound, VirginiaListen

The town

N ↑Public placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

"We're going to Pound, Virginia" ... "this is in Wise County, area code 276, population of this town, 828" about 0:03:45

History, in brief

1751

The Pound area was explored by Christopher Gist in 1751 and is said to be the oldest settlement in Wise County.

about 0:05:54

1815

The town is nicknamed the Pound; the name may be a family name or come from a pounding mill built in 1815.

about 0:06:27

1848

The county's first post office opened there in 1848.

about 0:06:35

1950

It was not incorporated until 1950, the last town in Wise County to incorporate.

about 0:06:39
All 9 history facts

1751

The Pound area was explored by Christopher Gist in 1751 and is said to be the oldest settlement in Wise County.

about 0:05:54

1815

The town is nicknamed the Pound; the name may be a family name or come from a pounding mill built in 1815.

about 0:06:27

1848

The county's first post office opened there in 1848.

about 0:06:35

1950

It was not incorporated until 1950, the last town in Wise County to incorporate.

about 0:06:39

Town note

It was a big coal town, with tough bars across the Kentucky border that catered to coal miners until the mining declined and the economy collapsed.

about 0:06:57

Town note

In the 1990s and 2000s the Virginia General Assembly passed a law to revoke the town's charter unless improvements were made.

about 0:07:16

Town note

The town had closed its police department, failed to pass a budget and lost its wastewater facility to the county.

about 0:07:42

1981

Dancing without a permit has been banned in the town since 1981.

about 0:08:05

The figures, as told

Money

Median home value$86,000
Median household income$26,417
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2026

Median household income

"$26,417"

Comparison: "national average $69,000". No direction stated.

As told in 2026 about 0:05:01

Median home cost

"$86,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2026 about 0:05:26

The reviews

3.0 / 5 · average of 4

5 stars

“A small town with financial issues that almost lost its right to be a town, with buildings starting to crumble; new shops are opening and the reviewer wants the new income spent on repaving the roads.”
about 0:08:35

5 stars

“Lived here all my life and would not want to live anywhere else; residents have to leave town for most things but most work in other towns and get what they need before coming home.”
about 0:09:14

1 star

“There is nothing to do here; residents travel to Pikeville, Kentucky or Wise, Virginia for errands and work, and it is a very small town in the middle of nowhere.”
about 0:09:41

1 star

“Lived here basically all my life; everyone is on meth and in and out of jail, there is nothing to do and the economy is so bad they shut down the high school. A really sad excuse for a town.”
about 0:09:55

In Virginia

Closest episodes

  1. The Recipe For A ButcherFleming-Neon, Kentucky · 4 October 201712 km / 7 miShow on map
  2. When Stupid People KillRaccoon, Kentucky · 12 May 202243 km / 27 miShow on map
  3. Horror In The HillsHensley, West Virginia · 3 December 202289 km / 55 miShow on map
  4. Shocking Backwoods BrutalityDingess, West Virginia · 17 November 202191 km / 57 miShow on map
  5. Evil Deeds & Ouija WritingsBaileyton, Tennessee · 23 March 202491 km / 57 miShow on map

The story

Pound, Virginia is a small coal town in Wise County in the far western tip of the state, near the Kentucky border. In 1981 it had 828 people and a median household income of $26,417 against a national average of $69,000. After the coal industry collapsed the town closed its police department, failed to pass a budget and lost its wastewater facility to the county, and the General Assembly passed a law that would have revoked its charter; the charter was restored in 2023. Dancing without a permit has been banned since 1981.

In 1971 he married Judy K. Cantrell, then about eighteen. Her uncle Orby Cantrell had sat in the Virginia House of Delegates for thirty years. The marriage was unhappy.

On December 8th, 1981, Judy was at a karate class. At about nine o'clock Mac Mullins heard two loud booms three to five seconds apart and rang Bill Cantrell. Bill heard him screaming that they had shot Judy. Judy, twenty-eight, had been shot twice at close range with a 12-gauge shotgun, in the chest and neck, and was dead. Her karate bag was by her feet and her keys were on the steps. A neighbour who watched every passing car had heard Judy's car at about five past nine and nothing else until the rescue squad. Officer Mullins arrived at 9.30.

Inside, drawers and cabinets stood open, Christmas presents had been unwrapped, and "fuck you" was written on the television screen with an oddly formed K. Judy's wedding rings, two men's watches and a camera were left in plain sight. A tracking dog followed a scent from the back of the house to a boundary fence around a field and stopped, and some stolen items were found there. There were no fingerprints on the shotgun.

On December 31st he gave a handwritten statement. Three men had seized him when he came home at 6.40 p.m., struck him with a glass, tied him with his own long johns and had the largest sit on him for two or three hours while the others ransacked the house. He heard Judy's car, screamed a warning, was hit again, heard two blasts, and the men ran out the back.

On April 17th, 1982 an anonymous man telephoned the Wise County police station claiming to be one of the intruders and sent officers to a flower box at Pound Hardware, where they found a bag holding the stolen .38, Judy's nightgown and underwear and two photographs of her.

A federal habeas petition was rejected on plain view grounds and the Fourth Circuit affirmed in February 1990. He later got out. Judy is buried at the Benjamin Bolling cemetery at Flat Gap, Virginia.

The case

Murder of Judy Cantrell

Victims

Judy K. Cantrell (28). Cantrell's wife, mother of a five-year-old son, was taking karate classes

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 3 April 2026.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Bill Cantrell. father, lived next door; heard the booms and screaming
Mac Mullins. brother-in-law, lived two doors down; first at the scene
Randall Dean Donahue. cousin; testified said he would marry the other woman
Gary Smith. co-worker at the coal mine; testified passed Judy's notes around
Carl MacAffey. private attorney retained by Judy's parents, acted as lead prosecutor
Roy Nixon. officer who took the anonymous telephone call
Donny Ray Mullins. officer who listened on the line and recognised voice
Cecil Bowling. rescue squad member who attended at the scene
Orby Cantrell. Judy's uncle, member of the Virginia House of Delegates for thirty years
Evelyn Cantrell. Judy's mother
Ezra Cantrell. Judy's father, who retained MacAffey
Clella Minor. of the Minor Funeral Home, handled the exhumation
Joyce Parker. runs Joyce's restaurant in Pound
PSC. Judy's lover, who wrote the letters found hidden in the walls

The timeline

  1. 1971 Cantrell marries Judy K. Cantrell, then about eighteen; both come from Cantrell families in Wise Countyabout 0:12:54
  2. 1976 Their son is bornabout 0:14:07
  3. 1981 works as an engineer at Bethlehem Steel's coal mine number 26 and is seeing at least four women (Bethlehem Steel Company coal mine number 26)about 0:14:14
  4. July 16th, 1981 Date of the first love letter to Judy from her boyfriendabout 0:59:41
  5. September 5th, 1981 Date of the second love letterabout 0:59:41
  6. October 19th, 1981 Date of the third love letterabout 0:59:41
  7. December 8th, 1981 Judy Cantrell attends a karate class and drives homeabout 0:20:34
  8. December 8th, 1981, about 9 p.m. Mac Mullins hears two loud booms three to five seconds apart (Cantrell house)about 0:21:00
  9. December 8th, 1981, about 9.05 p.m. A neighbour hears Judy's car pass her house, the first vehicle all evening (Orby Cantrell Highway)about 0:34:05
  10. December 8th, 1981, 9.15 p.m. telephones his parents saying the house has been robbed and someone has broken in (Cantrell house)about 0:22:21
  11. December 8th, 1981 Bill Cantrell hears screaming that they have shot Judy; Mac Mullins finds him holding her at the foot of the steps (Cantrell house)about 0:22:54

Places and phrases

N ↑Public placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode