FILE 334 / 8 November 2022 / 66 MIN / express

The Missing Blood Mystery

Grayson, KentuckyListen

The town

N ↑Public placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

We are going to Grayson, Kentucky; it is the seat of Carter County. about 0:03:03

History, in brief

Town note

Named after William Grayson, George Washington's aide-de-camp, who was given a 70,000-acre tract of land for his services.

about 0:05:06

1838

In 1838 a small portion of the tract was set aside as a town named after him.

about 0:05:21

Town note

The place was originally known as Crossroads, then Little Sandy Saltworks, then Little Sandy, then Grayson.

about 0:06:21

1811

It had a post office as early as 1811, and the name was shortened to Little Sandy in 1821.

about 0:05:45
All 6 history facts

Town note

Named after William Grayson, George Washington's aide-de-camp, who was given a 70,000-acre tract of land for his services.

about 0:05:06

1838

In 1838 a small portion of the tract was set aside as a town named after him.

about 0:05:21

Town note

The place was originally known as Crossroads, then Little Sandy Saltworks, then Little Sandy, then Grayson.

about 0:06:21

1811

It had a post office as early as 1811, and the name was shortened to Little Sandy in 1821.

about 0:05:45

Town note

The whole town was moved about a mile and renamed Grayson.

about 0:05:51

Town note

It is the seat of Carter County and was settled by salt makers.

about 0:05:51

The figures, as told

Money

Median home value$123,600
Median household income$31,105 per year
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2022

Population

"3,832 people"

No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:03:51

Median household income

"$31,105 per year"

Comparison: "very low". Direction: below.

As told in 2022 about 0:03:58

Share of people earning $8,000 or less per year

"47%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:04:05

Retail jobs

"25% of the jobs"

Comparison: "way above the normal, more than twice". Direction: above.

As told in 2022 about 0:04:15

Median home cost

"$123,600"

Comparison: "very low". Direction: below.

As told in 2022 about 0:04:21

The reviews

3.7 / 5 · average of 3

5 stars

“A fiance's family is from Grayson; the area is loved, with trees and hills everywhere, southern and kind people, and a nice tranquil place to live.”
about 0:06:48

3 stars

“A small, generally quiet town with not much to do; there is a bowling alley and a few bars, but the reviewer wishes for new businesses, better shops and different places to eat.”
about 0:07:06

3 stars

“The reviewer likes it okay but says it is not home; home is Ironton, Ohio, and since their daughter passed away on 6.3.2020 they feel home is where they need to be.”
about 0:07:35

In Kentucky

Closest episodes

  1. Shocking Backwoods BrutalityDingess, West Virginia · 17 November 202184 km / 52 miShow on map
  2. A Bloody MessNitro, West Virginia · 26 September 201899 km / 62 miShow on map
  3. When Stupid People KillRaccoon, Kentucky · 12 May 2022103 km / 64 miShow on map
  4. Hitchhiking Was Never SafeDunbar, West Virginia · 28 March 2019105 km / 65 miShow on map
  5. The Recipe For A ButcherFleming-Neon, Kentucky · 4 October 2017128 km / 80 miShow on map

The story

Within days he began a relationship with Minnie Burton, a few years older than him and also his ex-wife's aunt. Burton lived rent-free in a duplex apartment in Grayson in exchange for acting as chauffeur and helper to her 84-year-old neighbour, Bess Stidum Horton.

The argument became a rampage: he threw pickles and other food, hurled a chair, threw knives, smashed the television and other property, punched through a sliding glass door and cut his right arm badly, and threatened his brother with a knife before leaving with the remaining beer.

Burton, locked out of her own apartment, sat on the porch. He then ripped the screens off her windows; another tenant, Elmer Pritchard, called the police. Officers Lyndeman and Green, responding to Pritchard's call at about 1.57 am, saw a light on, found the garage door open and the inner door locked, and entered through the same window. Bess Horton lay dead on the bed, her throat slashed and a knife driven through her right temple so hard that the point came out of the left.

I stabbed her,' and later said he did not know she was in the house. Blood typing and DNA testing then produced the puzzle at the heart of the case: none of the blood on his clothing was Horton's, and none of the blood on her bed was his.

The case

Murder of Bess Horton

Victims

Bess Stidum Horton (84). Minnie Burton's neighbour and landlady, for whom Burton worked as a chauffeur and helper

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 8 November 2022.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Phyllis Berry. Minnie Burton's friend, in the car that night; she told police Horton kept about $4,000 in a metal box in her bedroom
Sharon. mother
Elmer Pritchard. fellow tenant who called the police
Scott Trent. Phyllis Berry's boyfriend, named in the police report
Officer Green. Grayson police officer who responded with Lyndeman

The timeline

  1. 1969 is born.about 0:14:01
  2. from the age of 10 to 18 lives in 11 homes in four states and changes schools seven times.about 0:12:41
  3. August 1993 begins dating Minnie Burton, his ex-wife's aunt.about 0:18:35
  4. August 1993 Bess Horton decides to evict Burton and cuts off the water to her apartment. (Minnie Burton's apartment)about 0:21:53
  5. August 18, 1993 From noon until midnight , Burton, Phyllis Berry and others drive around Carter and Boyd counties drinking, making two trips to Ashland for several cases of beer.about 0:25:30
  6. August 18, 1993 At Phyllis Berry's brother's house in Boyd County drinks whisky and takes horse tranquilizers. (Phyllis Berry's brother's house)about 0:28:11
  7. August 18, 1993, night and Burton go to his mother and brother's house in Grayson; starts a fight over cooking pickles and throws food, furniture and knives. ( family house)about 0:31:17
  8. August 18, 1993, night Burton flees to her apartment; smashes the house, cuts his right arm punching a glass door and threatens his brother with a knife. ( family house)about 0:34:25
  9. August 18, 1993, night leaves with the remaining beer, and Burton, locked out of her apartment, sits on the porch. (Minnie Burton's apartment)about 0:36:43
  10. August 18, 1993, night appears covered in blood, claims he killed his brother and gives Burton the knife, which she throws into the bushes. (Minnie Burton's apartment)about 0:38:11
  11. August 18, 1993, night tears the screens off Burton's windows; fellow tenant Elmer Pritchard calls the police. (Minnie Burton's apartment)about 0:38:56
  12. August 18, 1993, night goes next door to Bess Horton's apartment, drinks on the porch and enters through a window. (Horton apartment)about 0:39:45
  13. August 19, 1993, about 1:57 am Elmer Pritchard's call to police is made; the defence later puts the murder window at fewer than 50 minutes.about 0:55:37
  14. August 19, 1993, by 2:47 am Officers Lyndeman and Green find inside Horton's bedroom with jewellery in his pockets and a knife in his hand; Horton is dead on the bed with her throat slashed and a knife through her head. (Horton apartment)about 0:41:06

Places and phrases

N ↑Public placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode