FILE 494 / 18 May 2024 / 73 MIN / express

Gossip & Brain Bashing

Cherryville, North CarolinaListen

The town

N ↑Town centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

We're going to Cherryville, North Carolina, in south-central western North Carolina, south but west of Charlotte. about 0:03:30

History, in brief

Town note

Agriculture, especially tobacco, was the base of the local economy for a long time.

about 0:04:57

Town note

In the late 1800s the textile industry started booming and a lot of mills were built.

about 0:05:09

1966

On July 13th, 1966, Seaboard Airline Railroad trains number 45 and 46 hit head-on.

about 0:05:17

1966

The 1966 train collision killed one person and injured three.

about 0:06:03
All 7 history facts

Town note

Agriculture, especially tobacco, was the base of the local economy for a long time.

about 0:04:57

Town note

In the late 1800s the textile industry started booming and a lot of mills were built.

about 0:05:09

1966

On July 13th, 1966, Seaboard Airline Railroad trains number 45 and 46 hit head-on.

about 0:05:17

1966

The 1966 train collision killed one person and injured three.

about 0:06:03

Town note

Early in the century industrialisation brought thousands of subsistence farmers into mill villages in the Carolina Piedmont, kept poor by company scrip and company housing.

about 0:10:12

Town note

A sociologists' study of mill town life was titled Like a Family.

about 0:10:36

The figures, as told

Money

Median home value$230,300
Median household income$51,000
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2024

Median household income

"$51,000"

Comparison: "almost $20,000 below the national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2024 about 0:04:07

Median home price

"$230,300"

Comparison: "lower than the national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2024 about 0:04:15

Population

"five thousand residents"

No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:09:41

The reviews

3.5 / 5 · average of 2

5 stars

“A small, pretty town with every store you may need, from Walmart and Dollar General to small businesses and restaurants.”
about 0:06:11

2 stars

“Living there since the age of 11, not much to do beyond a small park and the New Year shooters, but quiet and calm and never feeling in danger.”
about 0:06:37

In North Carolina

Closest episodes

  1. The Thirsty KillerKings Mountain, North Carolina · 29 August 202517 km / 11 miShow on map
  2. Confessions Of A MonsterGastonia, North Carolina · 10 April 202523 km / 14 miShow on map
  3. Sicker Than The Average StranglerGaffney, South Carolina · 18 June 202043 km / 27 miShow on map
  4. Sifting Through SuspectsRock Hill, South Carolina · 10 June 202359 km / 37 miShow on map
  5. Age Is Just A NumberChester, South Carolina · 15 December 202277 km / 48 miShow on map

The story

Cherryville is a small town in south-central western North Carolina, about 45 minutes from Charlotte, south but west of the city and nowhere near the coast. In 1991 it had roughly five thousand residents, a median household income of about $51,000, almost $20,000 below the national average, and a median home price of $230,300. It grew out of tobacco farming and, from the late nineteenth century, textile mills; the Washington Post described it that year as uncommonly close knit and impervious to the world at large.

William Fred Davis, 68, and his wife Margaret Shuford Davis, 67, had lived there all their lives. Fred had served in the Army Air Corps in the Second World War, worked as a mechanic for the North Carolina Department of Transportation and farmed; Margaret had worked at Jenkins Food, the local sausage plant. Their daughter Ruth had married Joey James Melton, known as Joey Jimmy, a 29-year-old high school dropout whom the Davises had opposed her marrying and had supported financially, setting the couple up in a mobile home about 150 yards from their own house and later in the house Margaret grew up in.

On Sunday, 28 July 1991 the Davises went to church and were given a ride home. A neighbour borrowed a vacuum cleaner at about six that evening and, finding nobody home, let herself in through the unlocked back door. He beat Margaret in the kitchen and then Fred in his recliner in the den, where the television was loud and Fred, who was hard of hearing, never heard him coming. He took Margaret's pocket book and dress, burned the purse about three miles away, came back for it because it held identification, and threw it and the axe handle into a creek. Ruth found the bodies the next morning, her seven-year-old son walking in first.

Only the purse was taken and there was no evidence of sexual assault, though Margaret was found partly undressed. Suspicion fell at once on Joey Jimmy Melton, the only person in town with any friction with the Davises. Police camped outside his house for weeks, but found no physical evidence and no way to make him crack, and the pressure eased.

On Sunday, 8 September 1991 an intruder climbed through a bedroom window at the farmhouse of E.Z. Willis, 71, and his wife Sarah, 67, on Flint Mill Road. E.Z., who walked with a cane, got in a few blows with it before both were beaten to death with a tire iron in the kitchen. Their daughter Sheila, who lived next door, found them on the Monday morning. Nothing was taken. Both houses were rural and about a mile from the Cleveland County line, both couples were over 65, both had been at home on a Sunday evening, and in both houses the television was left blaring.

He said he liked the Davises, had no quarrel with either couple, and had learned only after the killings that E.Z. Willis was his third cousin. He said he would have killed again.

He said he was going to heaven and that he forgave everyone, and died at 2.14.

The case

Murders of William Fred and Margaret Davis

Victims

William Fred Davis (68). Retired North Carolina Department of Transportation mechanic and farmer, a World War Two Army Air Corps veteran, deaf in later life
Margaret Shuford Davis (67). His wife, who worked at the Jenkins Food sausage plant

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 18 May 2024.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Ruth Melton. daughter, who found her parents' bodies and later her husband's
Stephen Davis. son
Kathy Davis. Stephen's wife, who saw Fred and spoke with Margaret that day
Floyd Terry. owner of Terry's Groceries, who said police were all over Melton
C. Bert McGee. retired farmer who said the law killed that boy

The timeline

  1. 1961 is bornabout 0:36:09
  2. 1987 rents a mobile home on the Davises' property, about 150 yards from their house ('s mobile home)about 0:41:05
  3. a week or two before the murders has a huge argument with his grandmother (Maxine Willis's house)about 0:40:20
  4. July 28, 1991 The Davises attend church and are given a ride homeabout 0:17:08
  5. July 28, 1991, about 6 p.m. A neighbour borrows a vacuum cleaner; nobody is home but the back door is unlocked (Davis house)about 0:17:50
  6. July 28, 1991, between 6 and 8.45 p.m. parks behind the house, takes an axe handle from the car and walks in through the unlocked back door (Davis house)about 0:52:35
  7. July 28, 1991, that evening beats Margaret Davis in the kitchen and then Fred Davis in his recliner in the den (Davis house)about 0:52:42
  8. July 28, 1991, that evening takes the pocket book and dress, sets the purse alight about three miles away, returns for it and throws it and the axe handle into a creek (Creek near the Davis house)about 0:53:15
  9. July 28, 1991, that evening A resident finds the burning purse and calls the sheriff, but when they return it is gone; Margaret's dress is found nearby (Creek near the Davis house)about 0:22:15
  10. July 29, 1991 Ruth Melton comes over and the bodies are found, her seven-year-old son walking in first (Davis house)about 0:19:31

Murders of E.Z. and Sarah Willis

Victims

E.Z. Willis (71). Retired auto repair shop worker who walked with a cane and was still patching the garage roof
Sarah Willis (67). His wife, who still worked overtime at the mill

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 18 May 2024.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Sheila Willis. daughter, who found her parents' bodies and later opposed the death penalty before changing her mind

The timeline

  1. September 8, 1991, evening An intruder comes in through a bedroom window at the Willis farmhouse and confronts the couple in the kitchen (Willis farmhouse)about 0:25:59
  2. September 8, 1991, evening E.Z. Willis gets in a few blows with his cane before he and Sarah are beaten to death with a tire iron (Willis farmhouse)about 0:26:17

Shooting of Elizabeth Tipps

Victims

Elizabeth Tipps (81). Killed by her husband in the dark during the panic over the murders

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 18 May 2024.

Accused

Outcome

The timeline

  1. September 19, 1991, night Tipps hears a noise and feels a hand on his leg, grabs the loaded rifle and fires in the dark, hitting his wife as she comes back from the outhouse (Tipps mobile home)about 0:49:06

Last meals

Places and phrases

N ↑Town centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode