FILE 626 / 29 August 2025 / 72 MIN / express

The Thirsty Killer

Kings Mountain, North CarolinaListen

The town

N ↑Town centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

We are going to North Carolina this week... we're going to Kings Mountain, North Carolina. It's up in the hills. about 0:03:06

History, in brief

Town note

The original settlement was called White Plains.

about 0:05:09

1874

It was incorporated in 1874 and the name was changed to Kings Mountain.

about 0:05:09

1780

The name was chosen because the community was close to the site of the historic Battle of Kings Mountain in 1780, in York County, South Carolina, a turning point in the Revolutionary War.

about 0:05:19
All 3 history facts

Town note

The original settlement was called White Plains.

about 0:05:09

1874

It was incorporated in 1874 and the name was changed to Kings Mountain.

about 0:05:09

1780

The name was chosen because the community was close to the site of the historic Battle of Kings Mountain in 1780, in York County, South Carolina, a turning point in the Revolutionary War.

about 0:05:19

The figures, as told

Money

Median home value$202,100
Median household income$42,336
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2025

Population

"10,775"

No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:03:58

Median household income

"$42,336"

Comparison: "the rest of the country, about $69,000; more than a third under the average". Direction: above.

As told in 2025 about 0:04:19

Median home cost

"$202,100"

Comparison: "lower than the national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2025 about 0:04:35

The reviews

3.5 / 5 · average of 4

5 stars

“A great town where everyone is connected by family or mutual friends, so people communicate and get along, and the community is amazing and you almost always feel included.”
about 0:05:47

5 stars

“The whole review is 'best high school and wonderful good'.”
about 0:06:25

2 stars

“The reviewer has frequently seen crimes being committed and heard of many more, does not think it is a safe place, and says police are not visible in the area.”
about 0:06:58

2 stars

“People stick with their families and do not spend much time helping others; they mind their own business and worry about their own families.”
about 0:07:32

In North Carolina

Closest episodes

  1. Confessions Of A MonsterGastonia, North Carolina · 10 April 202515 km / 9 miShow on map
  2. Gossip & Brain BashingCherryville, North Carolina · 18 May 202417 km / 11 miShow on map
  3. Sicker Than The Average StranglerGaffney, South Carolina · 18 June 202034 km / 21 miShow on map
  4. Sifting Through SuspectsRock Hill, South Carolina · 10 June 202345 km / 28 miShow on map
  5. Age Is Just A NumberChester, South Carolina · 15 December 202260 km / 37 miShow on map

The story

Kings Mountain, North Carolina, is a small town in the hills of the south-western corner of the state, in the western panhandle, about forty minutes from Charlotte and fifteen minutes from Gastonia. It borders Cleveland and Gaston counties and had a population of 10,775. The original settlement was called White Plains; it was incorporated in 1874 and renamed Kings Mountain after the nearby site of the 1780 Battle of Kings Mountain in York County, South Carolina, a turning point in the Revolutionary War. Its two mottos are 'the historical city' and 'the city of progress'. Median household income was $42,336 against a national figure of about $69,000, and the median home cost was $202,100, below the national average.

The story turns on a one-lane dirt road on the edge of town called Man Court, about two hundred yards long, which the county does not maintain and the residents pay to keep up. In the autumn of 2014 Jeffrey Wayne Oakes and his wife Mila moved in. Oakes was born in 1963 in Cleveland County, drove trucks and also worked part time at an auto shop. Mila was born in 1983 in Gaston County, twenty years younger than her husband, and ran a small business called Oakes Southern Charm. They had two sons, Jeffrey Jr., born about 2005, and Aiden, a couple of years younger, and the family attended Westwood Heights Baptist Church.

Almost at once the new arrivals fell out with the neighbours: ATVs and donuts on the road at all hours, gunfire into the woods at three or four in the morning, and Mila's stereo rattling windows a quarter of a mile away.

On the morning of Wednesday 27 January 2016 Oakes was driving his twelve-year-old son the hundred and fifty yards to the school bus stop at the end of Man Court. Both men got out and argued for about five minutes while the boy hid in the back seat. Oakes called Mila rather than the law, and she arrived within two minutes and joined in. Mila was hit once in the head and died at the scene. Oakes was hit twice in the head; another bullet pierced the car window and nearly struck his son. Jeffrey Jr. ran to his mother, could not work her phone, then ran to the arriving school bus and told the driver his father had been shot.

Deputies arriving at 7.16 a.m. found him walking towards them drinking it. He said Oakes had blocked the road and pointed a gun, and that he had shot in self-defence. Oakes's gun was still under his seat. Mila is buried at Sunset Cemetery in Shelby.

The case

Murder of Mila Oakes and shooting of Jeff Oakes

Victims

Mila Oakes (32). Born Mila Nicole Ellis in Gaston County in 1983, twenty years younger than her husband; ran Oakes Southern Charm, attended Westwood Heights Baptist Church, mother of two; shot once in the head and pronounced dead at the scene.
Jeff Oakes (51). Born in Cleveland County in 1963, truck driver and part-time auto shop worker; shot twice in the head, left unable to walk, talk or care for himself, and died in a nursing home on December 8th, 2021 aged 58.

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 29 August 2025.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Jeffrey Oakes Jr.. the victims' twelve-year-old son, in the car during the shooting; ran to the school bus and raised the alarm
Aiden Oakes. the victims' younger son, sent to live with relatives
Leslie England. fiancee, who filed restraining orders and testified at the bail hearing
Roy Blackman. neighbour on the corner of Man Court who called 911 before and after the shots
Justin Cunningham. Leslie England's son, quoted on the start of the feud over a water bar
Candice Pullman. paralegal for lawyer, who told him to call the police
Emily. Mila Oakes's friend, who spoke about her after the shooting
Manuel Fin Ellis. Mila's father, who gave a victim impact statement
Lina Pizzoli. Mila's mother, who gave a victim impact statement

The timeline

  1. 1963 Jeffrey Wayne Oakes is born in Cleveland County, North Carolina.about 0:13:30
  2. June 1977 is born.about 0:21:57
  3. 1983 Mila Nicole Ellis is born in Gaston County, twenty years younger than her future husband.about 0:15:19
  4. the fall of 2014 Jeff and Mila Oakes move into Man Court with their two sons. (Man Court)about 0:12:52
  5. January 1st, 2015 to January 27th, 2016 The Oakses call 911 twenty-one times about and he calls thirteen times about them; deputies stop coming out. (Man Court)about 0:25:47
  6. September 4th, 2015 turns up at the car dealership where Oakes works and the two men fight, leaving Oakes with a cut under his eye. (car dealership)about 0:27:37
  7. September 2015 Mila Oakes threatens to kill and Leslie England when gets home. ( house)about 0:31:52
  8. Thanksgiving 2015 stays home instead of going to his family in Knoxville, afraid the Oakses will burn his house down. (Knoxville)about 0:37:23
  9. December 2015 allegedly points a shotgun at Mila Oakes; Mila is said to have pointed one at Leslie England. (Man Court)about 0:38:22
  10. January 26th, 2016 Mila Oakes says she is going to the sheriff's office the next day to end it; tells his lawyer's paralegal that she shoots guns and makes threats.about 0:41:19
  11. January 27th, 2016, 7 a.m. Jeff Oakes drives his twelve-year-old son to the bus stop at the end of Man Court. (Man Court)about 0:41:56
  12. January 27th, 2016, about 7.05 a.m. follows in his truck, rams Oakes's car and spins it sideways; the two men argue for five minutes. (Man Court)about 0:43:41
  13. January 27th, 2016 Oakes calls Mila instead of the police; she arrives within two minutes and joins the argument. (Man Court)about 0:45:57
  14. January 27th, 2016 takes a gun from his truck, waits about five seconds while the couple run, and fires, killing Mila and hitting Jeff twice in the head. (Man Court)about 0:47:36
  15. January 27th, 2016, 7.11 a.m. Jeffrey Oakes Jr. runs to his mother, cannot unlock her phone, and runs to the school bus to raise the alarm. (Man Court)about 0:48:26
  16. January 27th, 2016 walks to a neighbouring house, puts the gun down in the yard and asks for a Coke.about 1:06:46
  17. January 27th, 2016 Mila Oakes is pronounced dead at the scene from a single gunshot wound to the head. (Man Court)about 0:52:41

Places and phrases

N ↑Town centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode