FILE 509 / 11 July 2024 / 172 MIN / full

Almost Got Away With It

Idaho Falls, IdahoListen

The town

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Going to Idaho Falls, Idaho today; it's southeastern Idaho, and this is in Bonneville County. about 0:04:24

History, in brief

1864

In 1864 Matt Taylor built a timber-frame toll bridge across a narrow black gorge of the river, and the settlement became known as Taylor's Crossing.

about 0:05:56

1866

By 1866 postmarks show the town was known as Eagle Rock, named for an island where about 20 eagles nested.

about 0:06:32

Town note

It was later renamed Idaho Falls, although James could not find a falls there.

about 0:06:51

1949

In 1949 the Atomic Energy Commission opened the National Reactor Testing Station in the desert west of Idaho Falls.

about 0:07:11
All 8 history facts

1864

In 1864 Matt Taylor built a timber-frame toll bridge across a narrow black gorge of the river, and the settlement became known as Taylor's Crossing.

about 0:05:56

1866

By 1866 postmarks show the town was known as Eagle Rock, named for an island where about 20 eagles nested.

about 0:06:32

Town note

It was later renamed Idaho Falls, although James could not find a falls there.

about 0:06:51

1949

In 1949 the Atomic Energy Commission opened the National Reactor Testing Station in the desert west of Idaho Falls.

about 0:07:11

1951

On December 20th, 1951, a reactor at the station produced usable electricity for the first time in history.

about 0:07:21

Town note

More than 50 unique reactors were built at the facility for testing.

about 0:07:32

1961

On January 3rd, 1961, the site saw the only fatal nuclear reactor incident in US history; the reactor vessel was thrown nine feet into the air and one man was impaled on a shield plug in the ceiling.

about 0:07:39

1961

Three men died in the 1961 accident and were buried in lead coffins because they were radioactive.

about 0:09:05

The figures, as told

Crime / national average

Property crime
exactly average

about 0:22:41

Violent crime
exactly average

about 0:22:52

Money

Median home value$344,700
Two-bedroom rent$980
Median household income$57,412
Cost of living$94,000

For sale

$2,425,000

Six-bedroom, 7,212-square-foot house

about 0:19:09
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2024

Mormon population

"about 70%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:05:26

Population

"64,399"

No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:13:57

Population when the murders happened

"about 40,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:14:05

Sex ratio

"more females than males"

Comparison: "about exactly normal". No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:14:25

Median age

"33.6"

Comparison: "a little bit lower than the national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2024 about 0:14:38

Married population

"52 percent"

Comparison: "usually 60-something percent in Utah and high-Mormon areas". Direction: above.

As told in 2024 about 0:15:15

Divorce rate

"higher than normal"

Comparison: "the normal rate". Direction: above.

As told in 2024 about 0:15:17

Widow rate

"lower than normal"

Comparison: "the normal rate". Direction: below.

As told in 2024 about 0:15:21

Unemployment rate

"3.4 percent"

Comparison: "insanely low". Direction: below.

As told in 2024 about 0:15:39

Median household income

"$57,412"

Comparison: "normally almost $70,000". No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:15:51

Cost of living

"$94,000"

Comparison: "$100,000 is regular". Direction: below.

As told in 2024 about 0:15:58

Median home cost

"$344,700"

Comparison: "right around the national average". Direction: about the same.

As told in 2024 about 0:16:04

Average two-bedroom rent

"$980"

Comparison: "much less than the national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2024 about 0:16:41

Three-bedroom, two-bath trailer

"$85,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:17:39

Five-bedroom, three-bath house

"$325,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:18:32

Six-bedroom, 7,212-square-foot house

"$2,425,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:19:09

Property crime

"exactly average"

Comparison: "national average". Direction: about the same.

As told in 2024 about 0:22:41

Violent crime

"exactly average"

Comparison: "national average". Direction: about the same.

As told in 2024 about 0:22:52

The reviews

2.4 / 5 · average of 5

5 stars

“Loved it since the family moved there on the writer's twelfth birthday; family friendly, lots of culture and love for everyone.”
about 0:09:46

3 stars

“It's a good town but the writer has no specifics about what they like or would change.”
about 0:10:17

2 stars

“A beautiful place, but the local Mormons are rude to non-Mormons and too many people are moving in and taking farm and country land.”
about 0:10:44

1 star

“A city run by teenagers, with terrible hygiene, rude people and a mayor who behaves badly online.”
about 0:11:38

1 star

“The worst town the writer has lived in, overrun with meth, a sex slave kidnapping ring and drug dealers; would give zero stars if possible.”
about 0:12:25

In Idaho

Closest episodes

  1. A Skull In The Wood StoveBlackfoot, Idaho · 2 December 202141 km / 25 miShow on map
  2. Natural Born Killer IdiotsChubbuck, Idaho · 21 May 202071 km / 44 miShow on map
  3. A Very Beloved & Dead CoupleBellevue, Idaho · 3 May 2018179 km / 111 miShow on map
  4. No Body, No Crime... Except For That HeadHazelton, Idaho · 24 August 2023198 km / 123 miShow on map
  5. Murder Colors Don't RunJerome, Idaho · 5 March 2026219 km / 136 miShow on map

The story

Betty Lou Hales was born in Long Beach, California, on 12 June 1942, the daughter of Joseph, a Navy veteran who built and flipped houses, and Dorothy. She had an older sister, Joanne, and a younger brother, Dan.

Their daughter Sarah Lynn was born on 21 April 1963 and their son Jeff in 1964. Betty never knew what he earned, was given barely enough for groceries, and had to ask permission for the smallest purchase. In 1971 he crashed his truck while swerving to avoid a coyote, spent sixteen days in hospital and lost his spleen and one kidney. The family moved to Fontana in California to raise worms, and the worm shed burned down shortly before they moved to Jackson Hole, Wyoming, in 1978. In Jackson he bought Gene's Pawn Shop on Main Street and renamed it Gray's Pawn Shop. By 1982 it had outgrown the building, so he took a second loan, moved to 560 West Broadway, and bought a two-storey house at Stacey Lane. He sold guns and jewellery, wore a great deal of the stock, and told people he was a bounty hunter.

In 1987 his remaining kidney began to fail and he started dialysis, four times a day. At Christmas that year he needed hospital dialysis twice a week at the Eastern Idaho Regional Medical Center.

Betty had begun an affair in the autumn of 1987 with Roy Leavitt, a salesman for Fanning Wholesale who was also married. Only Rita Roundy knew. Rita, born in 1940 in Utah, worked at Fanning's, had been married and divorced three times, and was Betty's closest friend in Idaho Falls.

That spring and summer a series of fires struck Jackson: Jackson Hole Hardware at 4.04 a.m., the Virginian Lodge at 5.43 a.m., and Gray's Pawn Shop at 6.50 a.m., followed by attempts on the Ramada Snow King Resort and the Pioneer Cafe. Investigators found cigarette-and-match delays and thirty to fifty gallons of fuel, but nobody could explain where the fuel came from. The pawn shop was gutted and rebuilt with the insurance money, and the balloon payment on the business loan was due.

On Sunday 23 July 1989 Betty was staying with Rita at South 45th East Crowley Road in Idaho Falls. Roy had been there the previous evening and had left to clean out a camper. In the early hours of Monday 24 July a security guard, Stephen Mackley, saw a man on a bicycle at the Eastern Idaho Regional Medical Center, put the bike into an International Scout and drive off in a vehicle with Wyoming plates. Five minutes later a patrolman, Greg Black, saw a man on a bicycle on Channing Way. At seven that morning Roy arrived to take Rita to the airport for a flight to Las Vegas. The front door was open and the screen door locked. He went round to the patio door, let himself in and found the two women dead.

Rita was sitting up in bed, shot once above the left ear. Betty lay on her stomach, shot once in the back of the head at close range, her legs straight and her heels together as if posed. On the kitchen island were six saucers with burned-down red candles arranged to spell 666, and the words 'Satan loves you' written in Betty's blood. A scouring pad had been used to scrape blood from beside Betty's body. There were nine cigarette butts although neither woman smoked, footprints in the carpet and a toilet seat left up. The detective concluded that the scene was staged and that Betty was the target.

Roy admitted the affair, passed a polygraph, and was eliminated. Rita's former boyfriend C.J. Walker also passed a polygraph, as did Roy's wife LaDana and another of Rita's men, Howard Wilson. It was eventually found at Jack Hurley's ranch in Bondurant, thirty-five miles from Jackson, with a bicycle inside.

They settled out of court in March 1992.

The prosecution sought death.

Betty was cremated and the location of her ashes is unknown. Rita is buried in the Fairview Upper Cemetery in Fairview, Utah.

The case

Murders of Betty Lou Gray and Rita Roundy

Victims

Betty Lou Gray (47). Gray's wife, mother of Sarah Lynn and Jeff, having an affair with Roy Leavitt
Rita Lorraine Roundy (49). worked at Fanning Wholesale, Betty's closest friend in Idaho Falls, three times married and divorced

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 11 July 2024.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Sarah Lynn Gray. and Betty's daughter; joined the civil suit against her father
Jeff Gray. and Betty's son
Joanne. Betty's older sister
Dan. Betty's younger brother
Janice Robey. Betty's best friend in Jackson
DeeDee. neighbour across the street in Jackson
Jack Hurley. friend, a rancher in Bondurant where the Travelall was found
Lee Brown. friend and handyman
Stephen Mackley. hospital security guard who saw the man with the bicycle
Greg Black. patrolman who saw the cyclist on Channing Way
C.J. Walker. Rita's former boyfriend; passed a polygraph and was eliminated
LaDana Leavitt. Roy Leavitt's wife
Houston Riley. Rita's married boyfriend

The timeline

  1. December 4th, 1939 is born in North Dakotaabout 0:39:49
  2. June 12th, 1942 Betty Lou Hales is born in Long Beach, Californiaabout 0:36:22
  3. 1952 Betty's sister Joanne marries at sixteenabout 0:38:15
  4. The Hales family moves to Crestline, California, when Betty is sixteen (Hales house, Crestline)about 0:39:32
  5. Gray's family moves to Crestline when he is fourteenabout 0:40:37
  6. Joseph Hales hires to clear trees, and meets Betty (Hales house, Crestline)about 0:45:11
  7. June 13th, 1960 and Betty elope in Las Vegas, the day after her eighteenth birthdayabout 0:48:09
  8. April 21st, 1963 Daughter Sarah Lynn is bornabout 0:50:02
  9. 1964 Son Jeff is bornabout 0:50:05
  10. 1971 crashes his truck dodging a coyote and loses his spleen and one kidneyabout 1:13:55
  11. 1978 The Grays move to Jackson Hole and buy Gene's Pawn Shop, renaming it Gray's Pawn Shop (Gene's Pawn Shop)about 1:19:50
  12. 1982 The growing pawn shop moves to 560 West Broadway and the family buys Stacey Lane (Gray's Pawn Shop)about 1:22:40
  13. 1984 DeeDee, the neighbour across the street, meets Betty (Gray house)about 1:27:20
  14. 1987 starts dialysis four times a day (Gray house)about 1:40:11
  15. the fall of 1987 Betty and Roy Leavitt's affair becomes full-blownabout 1:51:50
  16. Christmas 1987 needs supplemental dialysis twice a week at the Eastern Idaho Regional Medical Center (Eastern Idaho Regional Medical Center)about 1:49:12
  17. 1988 Betty has a hysterectomyabout 1:53:05
  18. receives a kidney transplant from a nineteen-year-old donorabout 1:58:25
  19. Fires destroy Jackson Hole Hardware, the Virginian Lodge and Gray's Pawn Shop, and attempts are made on the Ramada Snow King Resort and the Pioneer Cafe (Gray's Pawn Shop)about 1:34:27
  20. July 23rd, 1989 Roy Leavitt visits Betty and Rita at Rita's house in the evening (Rita Roundy house)about 0:28:01
  21. July 24th, 1989 About 3 a.m. a security guard sees a man with a bicycle and an International Scout with Wyoming plates at the hospital (Eastern Idaho Regional Medical Center)about 2:20:39
  22. July 24th, 1989 At 3.05 a.m. a patrolman sees a man on a bicycle on Channing Wayabout 2:22:58
  23. July 24th, 1989 At 7 a.m. Roy Leavitt arrives, finds the two women shot dead and calls 911 (Rita Roundy house)about 2:03:10
  24. July 24th, 1989 Police find 'Satan loves you' written in blood, six saucers spelling 666 and nine cigarette butts (Rita Roundy house)about 2:11:05
  25. July 24th, 1989 Gray is told at the pawn shop that Betty is dead (Gray's Pawn Shop)about 2:14:00

Places and phrases

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode