Town note
Nicknamed Titletown, for reasons the hosts cannot explain.
about 0:05:31Spoilers are covered until your reading preferences load.
FILE 666 / 17 January 2026 / 70 MIN / express
We're going to Missouri this week. Here we go, Maryville, Missouri, northwestern Missouri, about an hour and a half to Kansas City. This is in Nottaway county, which is the same county Skidmore's in. about 0:04:03
Nicknamed Titletown, for reasons the hosts cannot explain.
about 0:05:31Named after the wife of the first postmaster, Amos Graham, whose name was Mary.
about 0:05:51Incorporated in 1856, annulled in 1857, reincorporated in 1859, annulled again during the Civil War, reincorporated in 1869, disincorporated later that year and finally incorporated for good in July 1869.
about 0:06:06A controversial case arose in 2012 when a 17-year-old boy was arrested for rape and sexual assault of a 14-year-old girl, a 15-year-old boy was accused of the same against the girl's 13-year-old friend, and a third boy admitted recording the first assault on a phone.
about 0:07:10Nicknamed Titletown, for reasons the hosts cannot explain.
about 0:05:31Named after the wife of the first postmaster, Amos Graham, whose name was Mary.
about 0:05:51Incorporated in 1856, annulled in 1857, reincorporated in 1859, annulled again during the Civil War, reincorporated in 1869, disincorporated later that year and finally incorporated for good in July 1869.
about 0:06:06A controversial case arose in 2012 when a 17-year-old boy was arrested for rape and sexual assault of a 14-year-old girl, a 15-year-old boy was accused of the same against the girl's 13-year-old friend, and a third boy admitted recording the first assault on a phone.
about 0:07:10In 2013 the county prosecutor dropped felony and misdemeanour charges against the first boy, who was related to an influential former state representative, which critics called a backwoods good-old-boy network.
about 0:07:34A 2016 Netflix documentary called Audrey and Daisy was made about the case; the young woman killed herself in 2020 and her mother killed herself four months later.
about 0:07:51"11,070"
No direction stated.
As told in 2026 about 0:04:46
"$39,768"
Comparison: "about $30,000 less than the national average". Direction: below.
As told in 2026 about 0:05:13
"$201,500"
No direction stated.
As told in 2026 about 0:05:24
2.3 / 5 · average of 3
“Everyone is so welcoming and it is like a large family, but the reviewer would like more community gatherings so newcomers can connect.”about 0:08:20
“An absolutely terrible place to raise a family, where cops and government officials plant evidence, falsify documents and tear families apart, and drug lords, alcoholics and thieves run the businesses and streets.”about 0:08:44
“I hate this place: about ten parks, three bars and a closing movie theatre, and the only good entertainment is the weekly bar fight. This place is hell.”about 0:09:14
Deborah Jo Taylor was born in 1956 in Iowa to Robert and Joanne. She graduated from Valley High School in Des Moines in 1974, took a degree in elementary education from Northwest Missouri State University in 1978 and later a master's degree. They settled on his family farm just south of Maryville, Missouri, where his parents Charles and Betty lived less than a mile away, and had two children, Lori in 1983 and Doug in 1985. Deborah taught junior high at St. Gregory Catholic School and the GED programme, led Girl Scout troops and was known as a kind, high-energy teacher who loved animals and children.
In the spring of 1994, at 38, Deborah became depressed and anxious. She took a leave of absence and saw a counsellor, Ken Thong, from March. He recorded her as sad and tearful, worried that she could not meet everyone's expectations and that parents were questioning her teaching, and noted marital problems and a lack of intimacy. She worked meanwhile as a secretary for Dr Kanti Havaldar.
On November 10, 1994, at about five in the afternoon, twelve-year-old Lori called for help from the farmhouse. Deborah was found outside, crushed, her right arm stretched towards a dead black cat. She was declared dead at the scene.
Sheriff Ben Espey of Nodaway County thought the scene did not fit. He had tied twine to the hydrostat lever so he could start the machine moving backwards from where he stood. He told the sheriff the same story, saying he acted because he believed she had been unfaithful, and investigators believed he had talked about killing the children too.
At autopsy the coroner found, besides combine injuries, lacerations to Deborah's forehead, bruising around her left eye and other facial injuries from blunt force, and concluded a blow to the face killed her. The cat had no lacerations from machinery, only bruising around the neck and a fatal hammer blow to the head; the coroner then disposed of its remains.
In June 1995 the defence won a motion to suppress everything seized in the warrantless searches of November 11 and 12, including the twine and measurements, leaving only the cat autopsy. In July 1995 the state obtained a warrant, but the combine had gone from the shed; it was found on Charles Taylor's property and taken to a John Deere facility for measuring and video. The children filed a wrongful death suit, and an insurer asked the court to rule that the family policy did not cover the killing.
Both sides agreed not to mention Deborah's relationship with her mother or an abortion. The prosecution argued that the cat ruse failed, that Deborah struggled with her husband and that he beat her and put her under the combine. State psychiatrists, including Dr Daniel Birmingham, rejected that, and the state produced Deborah's notebook with references to divorce and child support.
Lori testified about calling the ambulance, and ten-year-old Doug, the state's key witness, said his father gave him a pocket knife to cut string from the combine and then sent him back outside to put the dead cat near his mother's arms. Both children said the family had been happy and that they had never seen their father hurt their mother.
November 10, 1994 / the Taylor farm south of Maryville, Missouri
As told in the episode, on 17 January 2026.
Accused
Public places are marked on the map.
crime scene
about 0:15:27home
about 0:24:57other
about 0:31:09other
about 0:39:10other
about 0:41:30other
about 0:15:37hospital
about 0:30:40school
about 0:16:48school
about 0:14:36school
about 0:14:45business
about 0:49:21police
about 0:34:18