Murder league, by episodes
Why is the Skidmore, Missouri area so murdery, by episodes?
- Murders
- 4
- Episodes
- 3
- Towns
- 3
- Overall rank
- 54
- Rank in Missouri
- 3
These are the show's cases, not crime statistics: the show picks the towns.
Skidmore is a town of 250 in Nottaway County, northwestern Missouri. Maryville is 12 miles away; Rulo is 25 miles off, in Nebraska's far south-eastern corner where the Missouri River marks the meeting of Nebraska, Kansas and Missouri. It covers 0.63 square miles: a dying farm town of 165 people in the mid-1980s. Call it the Skidmore area: three small towns, two states, all within 25 miles of Skidmore.
The cases run from 1985 to 2004. In 1985, two people were killed in Rulo, high-school sweethearts married at sixteen and running a hog farm. In 1994, a teacher and mother was killed on a farm south of Maryville. In 2004, episode 625 spends its opening on a girl's violent childhood: belts, brooms and cords, raw onions, a winter night locked outside. No single episode carries the count: episode 74 has two victims, episodes 625 and 666 one each.
James and Jimmie introduce the town through its reputation: a 1981 shooting in front of a tavern, where fifty people saw it and all denied seeing anything. Three episodes and four murders put it third in Missouri and 54th overall, a lot of podcast for 250 people.
The cases in this hotspot
File 625 / 28 August 2025
Murders & Miracles
Skidmore / 1 victim / 0.0 miles
File 666 / 17 January 2026
The Killer, The Kitty & The Combine
Maryville / 1 victim / 12 miles
File 74 / 27 June 2018
The Imperfect Storm
Rulo / 2 victims / 25 miles