FILE 619 / 7 August 2025 / 181 MIN / full

Brutal Murder, Stupid Murderer

Garfield, New JerseyListen

The town

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placePublic placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

We are going to New Jersey this week and we're going to Garfield, New Jersey; this is in Bergen County about 0:04:10

History, in brief

1873

The area that is now Garfield was developed in 1873 as seven homes, and was known as East Passaic.

about 0:06:07

1881

In 1881 the town changed its name to Garfield in honour of President James Garfield, who was assassinated seven months later; the train station had been named for him and the name stuck.

about 0:06:20
All 6 history facts

1873

The area that is now Garfield was developed in 1873 as seven homes, and was known as East Passaic.

about 0:06:07

1881

In 1881 the town changed its name to Garfield in honour of President James Garfield, who was assassinated seven months later; the train station had been named for him and the name stuck.

about 0:06:20

1939

The town motto is the city of champions, from Garfield High's national high school football championship in 1939, the Garfield Cadets drum and bugle corps and Tippi Larkin, world junior welterweight champion in 1946.

about 0:07:31

1990

Garfield almost had a horse trolley in 1990, according to the town website.

about 0:07:09

The figures, as told

Religious

65%

Biggest faith: Catholic, 49.6%

about 0:11:22

Who lives here

White 56.4% · Black 3.6% · Asian 2.1% · Hispanic 35.8%

Ethnicity can overlap race.

Crime / national average

Property crime
▼ under the national average

about 0:18:51

Violent crime
▼ one quarter under the national average

about 0:19:04

Money

Median home value$433,600
Two-bedroom rent$1,760
Median household income$66,296
Cost of living141

For sale

$395,000

Three-bedroom, one-bath house listing

about 0:13:17

For sale

$600,000

Three-bedroom, two-bath house listing

about 0:13:47
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2025

Property crime

"under the national average"

Comparison: "national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2025 about 0:18:51

Violent crime

"one quarter under the national average"

Comparison: "national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2025 about 0:19:04

Population

"32,481"

No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:10:44

Women

"about 50.3%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:10:53

Median age

"38.3"

Comparison: "national average 38.4". No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:11:00

Married

"49%"

Comparison: "50-50 is the average". No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:11:03

Religious

"65%"

Comparison: "50-50 is the norm". Direction: above.

As told in 2025 about 0:11:22

Median household income

"$66,296"

Comparison: "national average $69,021". No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:11:51

Cost of living

"141"

Comparison: "100 is average". Direction: above.

As told in 2025 about 0:12:03

Median home cost

"$433,600"

Comparison: "about $100,000 more than the rest of the country". Direction: above.

As told in 2025 about 0:12:07

Average two-bedroom rental

"$1,760"

Comparison: "$500 more than the national average". Direction: above.

As told in 2025 about 0:12:38

Three-bedroom, one-bath house listing

"$395,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:13:17

Three-bedroom, two-bath house listing

"$600,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:13:47

Business with apartment at Passaic Street

"$999,999"

No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:14:48

The reviews

2.4 / 5 · average of 6

3.1 stars

“Only 3.1 out of five, way lower than normal for a town.”
about 0:08:05

5 stars

“A wonderful, safe and quiet town with lots of parks, stores and restaurants, close to the major highways and Manhattan, ideal for commuters.”
about 0:08:12

3 stars

“Great for a quiet suburb to start a family in, but Garfield lacks fun, with not many restaurants or activities in the neighbourhood.”
about 0:08:46

1 star

“Known as Garbage Field, with rents through the roof, no parking, the worst schools and the good restaurants driven out by greedy landlords.”
about 0:09:29

1 star

“The town is turning into trash with the type of people moving in; Prescott Avenue used to be nice.”
about 0:10:17

1 star

“The streets are dangerous because gangs are on every corner.”
about 0:10:30

In New Jersey

Closest episodes

  1. The Nightmare HouseFair Lawn, New Jersey · 25 November 20216 km / 4 miShow on map
  2. The Charming Susan StranglerDemarest, New Jersey · 22 October 202615 km / 9 miShow on map
  3. Too Fat To KillRamsey, New Jersey · 20 May 202320 km / 12 miShow on map
  4. The Disappearing CheerleaderHanover Township, New Jersey · 7 January 202128 km / 17 miShow on map
  5. A Very Unstable GeniusChatham Township, New Jersey · 12 March 202028 km / 17 miShow on map

The story

Sandra Terranova was born in about 1976, grew up in the Paramus area of Bergen County, New Jersey, and graduated from Paramus High School in 1993. She was small, about five foot three and a hundred pounds, close to her family and traditional in her plans: she told her neighbour Chad that all she wanted was to buy a house, get married and have children. In the spring of 1997 she moved into her own apartment in Garfield, having previously lived on Palisade Avenue and, for a time, with relatives in Italy, where her family had sent her to get her away from her boyfriend.

Their relationship was stormy and kept restarting, and Sandra's family disliked it enough to send her abroad. By 1997 he was also the father of a baby boy whose mother, Dana Kott, he was living with, sort of, on Route 46 West in Lodi, and he still saw Sandra Terranova.

She had told him she might be pregnant. The next day, Thursday, she did not come to work, which was unheard of, and on the Friday, payday, she did not come in for her cheque either. Her assistant manager and a co-worker called the police and told them to look at her ex-boyfriend.

On Saturday 16 August Detective John Prehart went to Sandra's apartment, saw that her mailbox was full and climbed the fire escape to get in through a window. The flat was empty. First he said Sandra had gone to Wildwood and had a long history of running away; later he admitted they had been closer than he had let on, that they had broken up on 10 August, and that he had seen her at one in the morning in her car with two long-haired men. Pressed about other women, he admitted the relationship with Dana Kott and their baby.

Inside were a chainsaw, a gas can, a pickaxe, a chopping axe, two shovels and a bow saw. The following day Sandra's black 1996 Mitsubishi Eclipse was found in the truck parking area of the Vince Lombardi service area on the New Jersey Turnpike, unlocked, sunroof open, keys on the passenger seat and her purse inside.

Ranieri saw a mound about a foot high and six feet long covered in dirt and sticks. He cut another tree across the road so nobody could drive back in. They were there about an hour. Ranieri drew a map. Detectives could not find the road that night in the rain and fog, but the next day he showed them the way, and at about 9.55 pm they uncovered Sandra's body.

The grave was on watershed property in Jefferson Township, off Berkshire Valley Road near Route 15, about half a mile into the woods. She had been buried under about eighteen inches of dirt in a grave six feet long and two feet wide. She was clothed except for her shoes, lying on her left side, her face and eyes swollen shut and her hands clenched. A rose tattoo on her ankle gave a tentative identification. Six or seven cigarette butts lay around the site. The autopsy found mechanical asphyxia and blunt trauma to the head and face, with a fractured hyoid bone; there were bruises from before death and bruising on her feet from being dragged.

Asked whether the killing was spontaneous or an accident, he paced and eventually muttered accident. He said he had gone to her apartment on 14 August to talk, they had sex, he left, drove around and called her from a payphone at about seven. Call waiting interrupted them, she said it was her mother, he did not believe her, so he went back up, hit star 69, got a male voice, struggled with Sandra for the phone, ripped it from the wall and stamped on it. He threw her on the bed; her crying aroused him, he said. He bit her breast, put his hands on her throat until she turned red and stopped breathing, then threw her body on the floor. He dressed her, carried her to the car, told his friend Mike Vasseel what he had done, borrowed a shovel from Pat Gallagher's shed, came back about midnight, drove her to Jefferson Township and buried her, returned the shovel, took her furniture to his own apartment and went to sleep. He also admitted taking her car to the Vince Lombardi service area and said he had used neckties round her neck during sex in the past.

In 2009 he sued Dana Kott for contact with his son and was refused. In 2015 he filed a 57-page complaint about conditions in the ADSEG segregation unit, and later a 114-page complaint about Odinist religious practice, both of which were rejected. Sandra is remembered among the state's domestic violence victims at an annual march and programme at the statehouse.

The case

Murder of Sandra Terranova

Victims

Sandra Terranova (21). Co-manager at the Rampage clothing store at the Garden State Plaza, Paramus; also worked at Old Navy in ; six weeks pregnant

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 7 August 2025.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Dana Kott. Mother of infant son, with whom he was living on Route 46 West in Lodi; consented to the searches of her car and apartment
Nicholas Ranieri. 16-year-old friend of ; drove with him to the grave and led police to the body
Chad. Sandra's neighbour and friend, who said she was petrified of
John Nardino. Man Sandra was on the phone with when used star 69 to call back
Barbie Kaskasas. Co-worker who called police and described threat at the store
Janati Zareski. Assistant manager at Rampage who called police
Pat Gallagher. Friend whose shed took a shovel from
John L. Weishel. Defence attorney, later standby and advisory counsel
Judge William Meehan. Judge at the arraignment and pretrial hearings
Detective John Prehart. Detective who led the missing-person inquiry
Detective Gregory Donatello. Bergen County homicide detective
Detective Brian Callahan. Bergen County Prosecutor's Office detective
William H. Schmidt. Bergen County prosecutor
Sharon Pfeiffer. Assistant Bergen County prosecutor
Amanda DeMartin. Close friend of Sandra

The timeline

  1. 1976 is born, a year after his brother Chris.about 0:33:00
  2. about 1976 Sandra Terranova is born.about 0:20:32
  3. 1993 Sandra graduates from Paramus High School. (Paramus High School)about 0:20:39
  4. after graduation Her family sends her to live with relatives in Italy to get her away from .about 0:23:04
  5. November or December 1996 and Sandra resume their relationship after his release.about 1:21:06
  6. spring 1997 Sandra moves into a new apartment in Garfield. (Sandra Terranova's apartment)about 0:22:35
  7. August 10th, 1997 says Sandra broke up with him and he helped her move furniture the same day. (Sandra Terranova's apartment)about 1:21:33
  8. August 13th, 1997 comes to the Rampage store, chases Sandra around calling her a whore and says he is going to kill her, after she tells him she may be pregnant. (Rampage store, Garden State Plaza)about 1:15:35
  9. August 14th, 1997 Sandra fails to turn up for her shift; that night John Nardino calls her and takes the phone and threatens him while Sandra cries in the background. (Sandra Terranova's apartment)about 0:27:23
  10. August 14th, 1997 kills Sandra in her apartment, strangles her, tries to stage a suicide with a phone cord, dresses her body and carries it to her car. (Sandra Terranova's apartment)about 1:46:40

Sexual assault of his girlfriend's daughters ()

Victims

His girlfriend's two daughters (20 and 21 at trial; 12 and 13 in 1983). Abused from preschool age until their early teens; both had arms broken and one had her nose broken

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 7 August 2025.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Bob Lax. uncle, who taught him to box

The timeline

  1. early 1980s is living with a girlfriend who has two young daughters.about 0:43:38
  2. June 1984 The abuse stops because the girls move away from New Jersey with their mother.about 0:47:15
  3. December The victims name as a defendant in a civil suit seeking punitive damages for physical and emotional abuse.about 0:49:19
  4. 2025 is out and free, aged 73, living in Newton, New Jersey, classed as tier two moderate risk. (Newton)about 2:48:31

Places and phrases

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placePublic placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode