Murder league, by episodes
Why is the American Fork, Utah area so murdery, by episodes?
- Murders
- 11
- Episodes
- 5
- Towns
- 5
- Overall rank
- 15
- Rank in Utah
- 1
These are the show's cases, not crime statistics: the show picks the towns.
American Fork is in Utah County, about half an hour outside Salt Lake City. It had 28,507 people in 2020, began as a Mormon pioneer settlement in 1850, was first named Lake City in 1852, and before either was a seasonal hunting and fishing ground for the Ute. The American Fork area runs well beyond the town: five towns in a line, from Pleasant Grove three miles away to Holladay, South Salt Lake and Payson twenty to twenty-four miles out, tied by the same sprawl and the same drive into the city. It ranks fifteenth overall and first in Utah.
The cases run from 1978 to 2014, one or two at a time. Episode 166 has four victims across two dates three decades apart. The other four episodes have seven between them, two apiece apart from episode 617, which has one. No year turns up twice and no town dominates the list. That comes to eleven murders across five towns in five episodes.
The cases in this hotspot
File 166 / 9 April 2020
Starting Your Own Religion Can Be T...
American Fork / 4 victims / 0.0 miles
File 531 / 26 September 2024
Dr Serial Killer
Pleasant Grove / 2 victims / 2.9 miles
File 189 / 17 September 2020
The Lego Murders
Holladay / 2 victims / 20 miles
File 662 / 3 January 2026
Master Of Deceit
South Salt Lake / 2 victims / 23 miles
File 617 / 31 July 2025
Murder Mystery Gone Wild
Payson / 1 victim / 24 miles
Towns in this hotspot
American Fork , Pleasant Grove , Holladay , South Salt Lake , Payson