Murder league, by episodes
Why is the Simsbury, Connecticut area so murdery, by episodes?
- Murders
- 16
- Episodes
- 8
- Towns
- 8
- Overall rank
- 5
- Rank in Connecticut
- 1
These are the show's cases, not crime statistics: the show picks the towns.
Simsbury is in north central Connecticut, in Hartford County, a town of about 24,000. Its hotspot claimed eight episodes and 16 murders across eight towns, fifth overall and first in Connecticut, a title nobody is racing for. The town's own history includes an 1859 explosion at a fuse factory near the centre, which killed seven women and one man.
The Simsbury area takes in the town itself plus Barkhamsted, New Britain, Middletown, Ellington and Bantam, and reaches over the state line to Agawam and Chicopee in Massachusetts. Hartford County sits at the centre of that radius, Litchfield County at the edge, and Massachusetts beyond.
The cases run from 1965 to 2015 in a steady drip. There are single murders in Barkhamsted, Agawam, Ellington, Simsbury and Chicopee, two apiece in Bantam and Middletown, then episode 613 in New Britain, which brings seven victims from 2003 and carries most of the 16. Strip that one out and eight episodes become seven, and 16 murders become nine.
The cases in this hotspot
File 704 / 29 May 2026
Mystery On The Path
Simsbury / 1 victim / 0.0 miles
File 328 / 20 October 2022
Is Granny A Psychopath?
Barkhamsted / 1 victim / 8.6 miles
File 613 / 17 July 2025
The Sick Ripper
New Britain / 7 victims / 14 miles
File 513 / 25 July 2024
Music Box Murder
Agawam / 1 victim / 16 miles
File 525 / 5 September 2024
Detective Fitbit
Ellington / 1 victim / 20 miles
File 261 / 3 February 2022
Scrap Metal & Sexual Urges
Bantam / 2 victims / 24 miles
File 185 / 20 August 2020
A Double Murder In Stereo Sound
Middletown / 2 victims / 24 miles
File 560 / 4 January 2025
Solving A Murder Puzzle
Chicopee / 1 victim / 25 miles
Towns in this hotspot
Simsbury , Barkhamsted , New Britain , Agawam , Ellington , Bantam , Middletown , Chicopee