Murder league
Why is New Britain, Connecticut so murdery?
- Murders within 25 miles
- 18
- Episodes
- 7
- Towns
- 7
- Overall rank
- 26
- Rank in Connecticut
- 1
New Britain sits in north central Connecticut, fifteen minutes outside Hartford, a hardware town that got its nickname from Stanley Works and the American Hardware Corporation and still calls itself Hardware City. The show's map around it is a ring of Connecticut towns: Middletown eleven miles out, Simsbury fourteen, Barkhamsted twenty, then Guilford, Bantam and Ellington all at twenty four. Seven episodes, eighteen murders, seven of them inside the city itself.
The decades are spread wide, from a Barkhamsted case in 1965 to an Ellington one in 2015, with stops in 1973, 1993, 2000 and 2003. But the count is not evenly shared. Episode 613 alone accounts for seven of the eighteen, and episode 129 for four, so two episodes carry more than half of it while the rest add a victim or two each.
It is worth saying plainly that this is a count of the show's cases, not of crime. James and Jimmie pick the towns, and a quiet borough of about 725 people can get a full hour of history before the murders start. New Britain simply sits at the middle of a patch of Connecticut they keep returning to.
The cases within 25 miles
File 613 / 17 July 2025
The Sick Ripper
7 victims / 0.0 miles
File 185 / 20 August 2020
A Double Murder In Stereo Sound
2 victims / 11 miles
File 704 / 29 May 2026
Mystery On The Path
1 victim / 14 miles
File 328 / 20 October 2022
Is Granny A Psychopath?
1 victim / 20 miles
File 129 / 25 July 2019
A Bloody Surprise
4 victims / 24 miles
File 261 / 3 February 2022
Scrap Metal & Sexual Urges
2 victims / 24 miles
File 525 / 5 September 2024
Detective Fitbit
1 victim / 24 miles