Murder league, by episodes
Why is the Chester, Pennsylvania area so murdery, by episodes?
- Murders
- 24
- Episodes
- 10
- Towns
- 10
- Overall rank
- 2
- Rank in Pennsylvania
- 1
These are the show's cases, not crime statistics: the show picks the towns.
Chester is the oldest city in Pennsylvania, founded by Swedish settlers in 1644 and renamed after an English city in 1682, when it was set aside as a haven for Quakers. It's in Delaware County, about twenty-five minutes outside Philadelphia, and it has a motto: "What Chester makes, makes Chester."
The city is in the Philadelphia commuter belt, and the ten episodes run from Chester itself out to Collegeville, twenty-four miles away, through small boroughs and townships in three states: Claymont, Wilmington, New Castle and Hockessin in Delaware, Pitman and Berlin in New Jersey, Upper Merion and Bridgeport in Montgomery County.
The cases stretch from July 1978 to February 2013, three and a half decades with no obvious cluster. The twenty-four are spread across the ten. Episode 405 has five victims and episode 497 four, but most of them have one or two apiece. That's second overall and first in the state.
The cases in this hotspot
File 601 / 5 June 2025
Angriest Serial Killer Around
Chester / 3 victims / 0.0 miles
File 422 / 9 September 2023
Dead In A Ditch
Claymont / 1 victim / 5.5 miles
File 475 / 14 March 2024
One Too Many Girlfriends
Wilmington / 2 victims / 11 miles
File 143 / 31 October 2019
A Scary Story On A Quiet Street
Pitman / 2 victims / 15 miles
File 528 / 14 September 2024
Murder Math
New Castle / 1 victim / 16 miles
File 405 / 13 July 2023
The Horny Teacher's Lounge
Upper Merion Township / 5 victims / 17 miles
File 367 / 2 March 2023
Band Names & Blood Stains
Hockessin / 3 victims / 17 miles
File 497 / 30 May 2024
The Serial Killing Nerd
Bridgeport / 4 victims / 18 miles
File 285 / 20 May 2022
An Arrow For Your Thoughts
Berlin / 1 victim / 23 miles
File 33 / 30 August 2017
A Basement Dwelling Predator
Collegeville / 2 victims / 24 miles
Towns in this hotspot
Chester , Claymont , Wilmington , Pitman , New Castle , Upper Merion Township , Hockessin , Bridgeport , Berlin , Collegeville