Murder league, by episodes
Why is the Fair Lawn, New Jersey area so murdery, by episodes?
- Murders
- 14
- Episodes
- 8
- Towns
- 8
- Overall rank
- 6
- Rank in New Jersey
- 1
These are the show's cases, not crime statistics: the show picks the towns.
Fair Lawn sits in Bergen County, New Jersey, about thirty-five minutes from New York City. It's an affluent commuter town that started as Lenape land sold to Dutch and Irish settlers, was cut into farm lots, and then spent years as Sluder Dam, a name so unappealing that nobody would move there until the lots were broken up again in 1791. The hosts note the area code, 201, as though that settles the matter.
The Fair Lawn area, as this hotspot runs, is the northern New Jersey commuter belt plus one hamlet over the New York line. Eight episodes spread across eight towns: Fair Lawn itself, then Garfield, Demarest, Ramsey, Hanover Township, Chatham Township, Denville and Chappaqua, the last twenty-four miles away.
No single case carries the count. The fourteen murders come in ones, twos and one three, and the case dates run from 1971 to 2010, four decades across a handful of quiet, expensive towns where the train to the city is the main fact of life.
The cases in this hotspot
File 251 / 25 November 2021
The Nightmare House
Fair Lawn / 2 victims / 0.0 miles
File 619 / 7 August 2025
Brutal Murder, Stupid Murderer
Garfield / 2 victims / 3.9 miles
File 745 / 22 October 2026
The Charming Susan Strangler
Demarest / 2 victims / 8.6 miles
File 390 / 20 May 2023
Too Fat To Kill
Ramsey / 1 victim / 8.8 miles
File 205 / 7 January 2021
The Disappearing Cheerleader
Hanover Township / 3 victims / 18 miles
File 162 / 12 March 2020
A Very Unstable Genius
Chatham Township / 2 victims / 19 miles
File 341 / 1 December 2022
Never Gonna Pig You Up
Denville / 1 victim / 20 miles
File 603 / 12 June 2025
Murder By Moonlight
Chappaqua / 1 victim / 24 miles
Towns in this hotspot
Fair Lawn , Garfield , Demarest , Ramsey , Hanover Township , Chatham Township , Denville , Chappaqua